ABC sues the FCC alleging a retaliatory campaign that violates the First Amendment
ABC and Disney sued the FCC, saying Brendan Carr's early license review punishes the network for its speech.
Objective Facts
ABC, The Walt Disney Co. and eight ABC-owned television stations sued the Federal Communications Commission on Aug. 18, arguing the agency under Chairman Brendan Carr is retaliating against the network's news and entertainment programming. The complaint targets an April order requiring the eight stations to seek license renewal early, which the FCC tied to an inquiry into Disney's diversity, equity and inclusion practices, and asks the court to stop the FCC from acting on it. Carr told NPR the suit lacks merit, and an FCC spokesperson accused Disney of spreading disinformation. On Aug. 20, Judge Loren AliKhan of the U.S. District Court in Washington declined Disney's request for a quick hearing on a temporary restraining order and set briefing for late September, with a hearing in early October.
Left-Leaning Perspective
NPR gave the suit sustained attention on Aug. 19. Media correspondent David Folkenflik reported that the FCC's yearlong review had widened from DEI policies to internal ABC News conversations about politics, and noted that Carr has opened inquiries into every major broadcast network except Fox. On Morning Edition, host Leila Fadel interviewed Anna Gomez, the FCC's lone Democratic commissioner, who said Disney "has found its courage, and it is pushing back" and rejected Carr's use of the public interest standard. NPR disclosed that Disney is a financial supporter of the network.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Right-leaning commentary on the lawsuit in the Aug. 19 to 22 window was sparse. Broadband Breakfast, a telecom trade outlet, framed the Aug. 20 scheduling decision as a win for Carr, with a headline crediting the chairman with the first round and noting the judge was a Biden appointee, and quoted the FCC calling Disney's push for a quick hearing a "meritless attempt to rush into court." Carr's own argument, as reported by NPR, is that broadcasters struck a deal to serve the public interest in exchange for free use of the airwaves and that some now want to break it. No in-window pieces from Fox News, The Wall Street Journal or National Review on the suit turned up in searches.
Deep Dive
The lawsuit grew out of a dispute that has escalated since Brendan Carr, whom Trump named FCC chairman, opened an inquiry into Disney's diversity practices. In April the agency ordered ABC's eight owned stations, in markets including New York, Los Angeles and Chicago, to seek renewal years ahead of schedule, shortly after a Jimmy Kimmel joke angered Trump. Carr has also questioned whether "The View" is exempt from equal-time rules, and after ABC declined in July to carry a prime-time Trump speech, Trump called for the network to lose its licenses, according to The Next Web and Law Commentary. Disney's complaint, filed Aug. 18, argues these steps add up to punishment for protected speech. Disney's case draws strength from the timeline and from public statements by Trump and Carr that the complaint quotes, including a warning Carr issued about Kimmel last year. The FCC's position has its own footing: the agency has not revoked anything, Carr says no renewal decision has been made, and the Justice Department argues that an administrative hearing is the normal route for a licensee to defend itself. Coverage favorable to Disney gives little attention to the procedural hurdles a court may weigh, while the FCC's statements do not address why the review was ordered so far ahead of the normal cycle. The next steps are set. Briefs on Disney's request for a temporary restraining order are due Sept. 24, with a hearing expected in early October, and the FCC must give 48 hours' notice before designating the licenses for a hearing, which would bring the parties back to court the next day. Whether the FCC issues such an order before October will shape how quickly AliKhan has to rule.