ACA shoppers face higher premiums and insurer exits as 2027 open enrollment nears
ACA marketplace shoppers face roughly 11% to 15% higher 2027 premiums and fewer insurers when enrollment opens Nov. 1.
Objective Facts
Shoppers on the Affordable Care Act marketplaces will see a second straight year of double-digit premium increases when open enrollment begins Nov. 1. Federal figures reviewed by The Washington Sun show average premiums for the most popular HealthCare.gov plans rising about 11%, while a preliminary KFF analysis puts the median increase nationwide at 15%. Insurer participation is shrinking: HealthCare.gov will have 152 insurers in 2027, down 14%, and KFF counted 11 carriers exiting some or all states, led by Cigna's departure from all 11 of its markets. The changes follow the expiration of enhanced federal premium tax credits at the end of 2025 and an enrollment drop of nearly 3 million people this year, which the Trump administration attributes largely to a fraud crackdown and critics attribute to higher costs.
Left-Leaning Perspective
Left-leaning coverage ties the 2027 price increases to Republican decisions, chiefly letting the enhanced tax credits lapse and cutting immigrant eligibility in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. Talking Points Memo's Emine Yücel framed the $500 refund checks as an effort to make voters forget what Republicans did to health care weeks before the midterms. The Center for American Progress's Brian Keyser and Natasha Murphy calculated that the check covers under 5% of the premium increase facing a 60-year-old earning $65,000.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Right-leaning coverage gives more weight to fraud and to the administration's refunds. Fox News's Peter D'Abrosca reported the $500 checks as money returned to consumers after what Donald Trump's letter called Biden-era overcharges. The Wall Street Journal editorial board, in a piece reposted by the House Budget Committee, cited Paragon Health Institute estimates of at least 6.2 million improper enrollments. The Washington Examiner's Gabrielle M. Etzel reported the 2027 rate filings straight, setting the administration's fraud explanation beside critics' affordability explanation without choosing between them.
Deep Dive
The 2027 enrollment season is the second since the enhanced, pandemic-era premium tax credits expired at the end of 2025. Net premiums paid by enrollees rose 58% in 2026, according to KFF, and marketplace enrollment fell from about 22 million to about 19 million. Insurers have now priced a smaller and likely sicker pool into 2027 rates: The Washington Sun's review of federal figures shows an 11% average rise on HealthCare.gov's most popular plans, KFF's nationwide median is 15%, and states range from under 7% in Vermont and New York to 29% in Arizona, per healthinsurance.org. Insurer exits compound the disruption: Cigna alone covers about 369,000 marketplace enrollees in the 11 states it is leaving, and Baylor Scott & White is leaving Texas. The administration's fraud argument rests on real evidence of improper broker enrollments, which Paragon documented and CMS acted on, but the Daily Caller and KFF Health News reported that some people removed in the August cancellations were eligible and have been reinstated. The affordability argument is strengthened by the concentration of losses among higher earners, yet subsidized enrollees, who are most marketplace customers, will see a smaller share of the 2027 increase because subsidies rise with benchmark premiums. Unsubsidized buyers above 400% of poverty, and many lawfully present immigrants losing eligibility under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, carry the largest burden. Cost pressure is also not limited to the marketplace: KFF's Oct. 22 survey found workers' share of employer family coverage rose 9%, outpacing 3.7% wage growth. Watch for CMS's official release of 2027 HealthCare.gov rates before Nov. 1, the outcome of the broker groups' suits over the registration freeze, and how many enrollees get auto-reassigned when their insurer leaves. The Dec. 15 deadline for Jan. 1 coverage falls after the midterm elections, so the first sign-up numbers will arrive while both parties argue over who is to blame for higher costs.