Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche pledges to make Dobbs permanent nationwide
Leaked audio shows Todd Blanche promising to make Dobbs permanent everywhere, putting abortion pills at the center of his confirmation fight.
Objective Facts
Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche told members of the Christian ministry Intercessors for America on a July 30 call, hosted by the White House Faith Office, that the Justice Department was working with HHS, the FDA and the White House on what he called permanent solutions so the 2022 Dobbs decision would hold in every state, according to EWTN News and OSV News. He tied that goal to stopping abortion pills from being mailed into states that ban abortion. A recording surfaced online and was reported by Politico, and the Justice Department then told The Hill that his words had been mischaracterized and concerned only mail-order abortion drugs. The remarks landed during his confirmation fight: the Senate Judiciary Committee advanced him on August 4, and by August 7 Republican Sens. Susan Collins and Lisa Murkowski had said they would oppose him while Sen. Bill Cassidy said he would support him.
Left-Leaning Perspective
The 19th's Shefali Luthra, in a story republished by Salon on August 7, framed the remarks as a hint that the Justice Department could make national limits on medication abortion a priority, which she described as a shift from how the Trump administration has handled abortion so far. Luthra noted that Blanche gave no timeline or specific steps, and that the administration has not moved to block telehealth abortion. She quoted Democrats who say the remarks disqualify him, including Sen. Richard Blumenthal and Sen. Patty Murray.
Right-Leaning Perspective
EWTN News reporter Tyler Arnold framed the same remarks as a commitment to protect pro-life state laws from out-of-state groups that mail abortion pills, noting that New York and California have passed laws shielding providers who do that. The Washington Examiner's Kaelan Deese reported on August 7 that a coalition of anti-abortion groups sent the Justice Department a letter praising Blanche's promised review of the Biden-era Comstock opinion and urging him to overturn it. In this coverage the pledge reads as a defense of states' choices after Dobbs rather than a federal ban.
Deep Dive
The comments came from a July 30 call that participants were told was private, hosted by the White House Faith Office with Intercessors for America. The recording appeared on YouTube, was reported by Politico, and was then removed. Blanche was acting attorney general and awaiting a full Senate vote, and the Judiciary Committee had advanced him on a party-line vote on August 4. At a July hearing he had already promised to review the Biden Justice Department's opinion that the Comstock Act does not bar mailing abortion pills, according to The Nation and The 19th. Critics are right that the phrase he used goes beyond what Dobbs did, since the ruling left abortion law to states, and the Justice Department's clarification does not explain how stopping mailed pills into ban states would work without reaching providers in states where abortion is legal. Supporters, as reported by EWTN News, have a point that Blanche tied the pledge to cross-border shipments and shield laws, not to a federal statute banning abortion. Both sides tend to skip the gap between words and action: OSV News reported that the administration has asked courts to pause state suits against the mail rule and has left that rule in place, and The 19th reported that no telehealth restrictions have been issued. The next markers are the full Senate vote on Blanche, now dependent on a narrow Republican margin with Collins and Murkowski opposed; the Office of Legal Counsel review of the Comstock opinion; the FDA's mifepristone safety review; and the Louisiana case set for the 5th Circuit in September, according to The 19th. The U.S. Catholic bishops also plan a call to prayer and action beginning August 18 focused on mailed abortion pills, OSV News reported.