Ambassador Perdue says Trump asked Xi whether China wants to buy US weapons
Ambassador David Perdue said Trump asked Xi to buy US arms; Trump and the State Department pushed back.
Objective Facts
US Ambassador to China David Perdue said on Fox News Sunday on Sept. 27 that Donald Trump once asked Xi Jinping whether China would like to buy American weapons, days after Xi's state visit to Washington. Perdue said the question came up as Trump played down US arms sales to Taiwan by noting that the US sells weapons around the world, and he did not say when it happened. The next day the State Department said US law bars arms sales to China and that no offer or plan exists, and Trump told reporters he "never heard of that one" while also saying a sale "maybe" was a good idea. Taiwanese outlets, led by a Sept. 30 Taipei Times column, read the episode as evidence that Taiwan's $14 billion arms package is being used as leverage, while Chinese-language coverage from Sputnik China reported the claim and denial without comment from Beijing.
Left-Leaning Perspective
Mainstream left-leaning outlets treated Perdue's account as a sign that Trump sees China in commercial rather than security terms. The New York Times' Edward Wong reported the remark alongside the stalled $14 billion Taiwan package and quoted Brookings' Ryan Hass saying the offer "will be unsettling to American partners." Fortune's Sasha Rogelberg built a full piece around experts who said the offer shows Trump does not take China's military threat seriously, and The Daily Beast's Annabella Rosciglione called it a "stunning departure" from decades of policy.
Right-Leaning Perspective
The remark originated on Fox News Sunday, where Perdue offered it while arguing that Trump is firm on Taiwan despite the paused package. Fox-owned LiveNOW from FOX, in a piece by Nick Viviani, led with Trump's denial and his comment that US weaponry is superior to China's, presenting the exchange largely in Trump's own words. We found no editorial or opinion column from The Wall Street Journal, National Review or the New York Post on the remark in the Sept. 27 to 30 window.
Deep Dive
Perdue's comment came on Sept. 27, days after Xi Jinping's state visit to Washington, in answer to a question about why a record $14 billion arms package for Taiwan has been paused since Donald Trump's May summit in Beijing. Trump has called Taiwan arms sales a "very good negotiating chip" with China, and Bream cited complaints from Republican and Democratic lawmakers about the delay. Perdue's answer, that Trump frames Taiwan sales as routine and once asked Xi if he wanted to buy some too, was meant to reassure. It instead drew a State Department statement the next day that US law bars arms sales to China, and a denial from Trump that included his comment that such a deal might be "a good idea." Critics quoted by the Times, Fortune and the AP have a solid factual point: the US has not sold weapons to Beijing since the 1980s, and an offer, even a casual one, sits awkwardly with a Taiwan package held up for months. What their coverage tends to skip is that no one has said Xi responded, no date was given, and both the White House and State Department ruled out any sale. Perdue's defenders, for their part, lean on his claim of record Taiwan sales but do not explain why the largest package remains paused, and Trump's own answer left the door ajar rather than closing it. The open questions are concrete. One is whether Perdue clarifies or walks back his account, given that Trump publicly said he would "ask him" about it. Another is whether the State Department moves the $14 billion Taiwan package forward, which Taiwan's representative Alexander Yui said Taipei wants "as soon as possible." A third is whether lawmakers who signed the May letter urging completion of the sale press the administration in hearings.
Regional Perspective
In Taiwan, Taiwan News reported Perdue's comment on Sept. 28 by tying it to the stalled NT$439 billion (US$14 billion) arms package and quoting Taiwan's representative in Washington, Alexander Yui, who said the US remains Taiwan's main supplier and that Taipei hopes to get the package "as soon as possible." On Sept. 30 the Taipei Times ran a column by Kaohsiung-based writer Clive Hazell arguing that Trump treats arms sales as "a transaction, available to whoever is in the room." In mainland-facing coverage, Sputnik China, a Russian state outlet publishing in Chinese, reported Perdue's quote and Trump's denial without commentary. China's foreign ministry spokesperson Guo Jiakun, asked about the claim, would not confirm it and said China strengthens its defense based on its own needs, according to the AP. The Taiwanese framing differs from most US coverage in what it treats as the main story. US outlets focused on whether Trump made the offer and on the legal ban; the Taipei Times took the offer as given and asked what it says about Taiwan's place in Washington's priorities, writing that the disclosure "should end any lingering doubt about whether Trump treats China as a genuine security threat." South Korea's Kyunghyang Shinmun, reporting from Washington, emphasized the worry among US partners near China, citing Ryan Hass and former Bush adviser Dennis Wilder. Beijing said little: the foreign ministry neither confirmed the account nor used it to attack US policy on Taiwan. For Taiwan, the stakes are tangible, since the paused package is the largest proposed and the Taiwan Relations Act obliges Washington to help the island defend itself. For China, the remark offered little to act on, given that US law blocks any sale, but it came days after Xi pressed Trump to oppose Taiwan independence during his visit, according to Chinese state media cited by the AP.