ANC falls to its worst-ever result in South Africa's local elections
The ANC fell to about 31% in South Africa's November 4 municipal vote, its lowest share since 1994.
Objective Facts
South Africans voted in municipal elections on November 4, and with 99% of votes counted the ANC had 30.8% nationally against 24% for the Democratic Alliance, according to Business Day's live blog. Reuters reported that the ANC's share was about 14 points below its 2021 municipal result of 45.6%, which had itself been its worst ever. The DA led the three Gauteng metros and kept Cape Town, Jacob Zuma's MK Party took third place nationally and led in eThekwini, and the EFF fell from 10.3% to about 6.2%. Most metros and dozens of smaller councils are hung, so coalition talks will decide who governs; the IEC planned to announce final results on Sunday, November 9. South African outlets gave more weight than Reuters and AP to the coalition arithmetic and to the ANC's internal fallout, including a Sunday Times report that Cyril Ramaphosa discussed resigning party posts.
Left-Leaning Perspective
The left-leaning coverage we found treats the result as a verdict on failing local services. Al Jazeera's preview called the vote a referendum on the ANC, citing Ramaphosa's own admission in his newsletter that municipal failures had eroded trust in democratic governance, and it flagged anti-migrant campaigning by MK in Durban. Daily Maverick's Paul Berkowitz wrote on November 5 that the ANC was losing ground in rural councils it once held comfortably and in township wards in Soweto, Tembisa and Soshanguve. No mainstream US left outlet such as The New York Times, NPR or CNN surfaced with coverage of this result.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Searches for The Wall Street Journal, Fox News, National Review and other mainstream US right outlets found no coverage of this result. The market-focused South African press was the nearest match. BusinessTech's running coverage said the ANC was getting hammered and stressed how closely the count tracked CSIR projections, and it reported the DA sweeping Gauteng's metros. Business Day's Thando Maeko quoted Oxford Economics analyst Louw Nel saying the DA was projected first in at least five of eight metros, with ActionSA a possible kingmaker in Gauteng.
Deep Dive
The ANC first dropped below 50% in local elections in 2021, with 45.6%, and lost its parliamentary majority in 2024, when it took just over 40% and formed a Government of National Unity with the DA and others. This year's vote, held on November 4 for 257 councils, pushed it to about 31% nationally. Turnout rose to roughly 54.5% from 46% in 2021, according to AFP, and Oxford Economics' Louw Nel said the turnout suggested ANC voters did not simply stay home. The losses ran beyond the cities: Daily Maverick reported slippage in rural Mpumalanga and Eastern Cape councils, and MK beat the ANC across much of KwaZulu-Natal. The ANC's own camp is divided on what this means. Mantashe's democratic-maturity argument has some support in the numbers, since 806 parties registered and council fragmentation has grown since 2016, as The Citizen's April analysis showed. It leaves out that the DA, not a scatter of small parties, took the largest share of the ANC's lost metro vote. Opposition claims of terminal decline also overreach on some evidence: the ANC still won Limpopo comfortably, led in Buffalo City and edged Mangaung, and remains the largest party nationally. Reuters and AP gave little room to ActionSA and MK as kingmakers, which local outlets treated as the main story for the next fortnight. Parties have about two weeks after the IEC's declaration to form councils, so Johannesburg, Tshwane, Ekurhuleni and eThekwini are the places to watch. MK has challenged parts of the eThekwini count, and the IEC ordered recounts in five wards. Inside the ANC, the Sunday Times report that Ramaphosa and other leaders discussed quitting party posts adds pressure ahead of the December 2027 conference that will pick his successor, and the result will shape both parties' positioning before the 2029 general election.
Regional Perspective
South African outlets reported the result council by council. Business Day's Thando Maeko detailed ANC losses in every metro, including Buffalo City, where the CSIR projected the party at about 40% after 59.3% in 2021, and Mangaung, where the count finished with the ANC on 33.9% and the DA on 33.5%, according to BusinessTech. EWN quoted Mantashe calling the decline a sign of democratic maturity and analyst Richard Calland saying the next two weeks of negotiations would matter more than the count. Briefly News reported that 69 of the first 100 decided councils were hung, and that 17 of 26 Northern Cape municipalities had no majority. Wire coverage from Reuters, AP and AFP framed the vote as a referendum on the ANC's three decades in power and on failing services, and it carried little about the ANC's internal response. Local outlets went further into the party's turmoil. Business Day's live blog carried Mbalula's admission that the party "knew this outcome was coming" and summarized a Sunday Times report that Ramaphosa and other leaders discussed resigning party posts. Local reporting also split on emphasis: EWN described a country moving into a permanent multiparty era, while analyst Carmen Murray, in The Citizen's April preview by Hein Kaiser, had projected the ANC to stay the largest party in most metros, a forecast the DA's metro gains overturned. For South Africans, the stakes are practical. The new councils control water, electricity distribution, refuse and roads, the failures voters cited to AP and EWN. Johannesburg has had five mayors in four years, according to Al Jazeera, and Business Day noted that coalition deals in Johannesburg and Tshwane have repeatedly broken down. The outcome in KwaZulu-Natal, where MK led the provincial vote, also sets up Jacob Zuma's party as a power broker ahead of the 2029 national election.