Appeals court rules Trump broke federal law by deploying California National Guard to Los Angeles

A split 9th Circuit panel ruled Donald Trump unlawfully federalized California's National Guard for Los Angeles in 2025.

Objective Facts

A three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 2-1 on October 23, 2026, that Donald Trump acted unlawfully when he federalized about 4,000 California National Guard members and sent them to the Los Angeles area during June 2025 protests over immigration raids, ABC7 Los Angeles and FOX 11 reported. Judge Jennifer Sung wrote for the majority, joined by Judge Eric Miller, and found the administration met neither of the two conditions the federal Guard statute requires: a rebellion, or an inability to execute federal law with regular forces. Judge Mark Bennett dissented, arguing the court should have let the administration drop its appeal. The troops were withdrawn by January 2026, according to Political.org, so the decision mainly sets precedent for future deployments in the 9th Circuit.

Left-Leaning Perspective

We could not find coverage of this ruling from The New York Times, CNN, NPR or Politico in our searches, so the left-leaning case here comes from California Democrats as quoted in local reporting. Gov. Gavin Newsom told reporters, in remarks carried by Military.com and ABC7, that a court had again rejected Donald Trump's takeover of the state's Guard and that California set a precedent protecting all Americans. Attorney General Rob Bonta's office said in a statement that the courts had repeatedly blocked the administration's efforts to get around the law and that his office would keep suing.

Right-Leaning Perspective

We did not find coverage of the October 23 ruling from Fox News national, The Wall Street Journal, National Review, the New York Post or the Washington Examiner in our searches. The main right-of-center argument in the record is Judge Mark Bennett's dissent, as described by MEAWW and Law Commentary: he said the panel should have granted the administration's request to dismiss its appeal and return to the trial court, and he questioned how heavily the majority leaned on Trump v. Illinois, which the parties had briefed only briefly.

Deep Dive

Trump federalized about 4,000 California Guard members on June 7, 2025, citing 10 U.S.C. 12406, after protests over immigration raids in the Los Angeles area, Law Commentary reported. U.S. District Judge Charles Breyer blocked the move, and in June 2025 a 9th Circuit panel of Sung, Miller and Bennett let Trump keep control while rejecting the claim that his decision was beyond court review. The Supreme Court's December 2025 ruling in Trump v. Illinois, which read "regular forces" as likely meaning the regular military, changed the legal footing, MEAWW and Political.org reported. The October 23 decision applies that reading to Los Angeles. California officials are on solid ground in calling this a legal win: the majority found statutory violations and, per Law Commentary, a likely Tenth Amendment problem and an intrusion on Congress's power over the militia. Their framing leaves out that the decision reviews a preliminary injunction and that the troops left months ago, so it changes little on the ground. Bennett's dissent raises a fair procedural question about deciding a case on briefs written before the Supreme Court ruled, but it does not dispute the Illinois standard itself. The administration has not explained its position publicly since the ruling. The administration could seek rehearing by the full 9th Circuit or petition the Supreme Court; Political.org reported no such filing yet. A separate appeal over whether Guard troops may do civilian law enforcement remains on hold, Law Commentary reported. Military.com noted concern about Guard deployments near polling sites before the midterms, which the administration has said it does not plan. The ruling now binds any future Guard federalization in the western states the 9th Circuit covers.

OBJ SPEAKING

Create StoryTimelinesVoter ToolsRegional AnalysisPolicy GuideAll StoriesCommunity PicksUSWorldPoliticsBusinessHealthEntertainmentTechnologyAbout

Appeals court rules Trump broke federal law by deploying California National Guard to Los Angeles

A split 9th Circuit panel ruled Donald Trump unlawfully federalized California's National Guard for Los Angeles in 2025.

Oct 26, 2026· Updated Oct 27, 2026
What's Going On
  • On October 23, 2026, a three-judge 9th Circuit panel ruled 2-1 that Donald Trump's 2025 federalization of about 4,000 California National Guard members for Los Angeles was unlawful, according to ABC7 and FOX 11 Los Angeles.
  • Judge Jennifer Sung, a Biden appointee, wrote the majority opinion, joined by Trump appointee Eric Miller; Trump appointee Mark Bennett dissented, Political.org and MEAWW reported.
  • The panel rejected the administration's claim of a "rebellion" in Los Angeles and found it had not shown it could not enforce federal law with regular forces, relying on the Supreme Court's December 2025 ruling in Trump v. Illinois, according to Law Commentary.
  • The deployment has already ended, so the ruling has no immediate effect on troops, but it binds future 9th Circuit panels, Political.org and MEAWW reported.
  • Gov. Gavin Newsom and Attorney General Rob Bonta praised the decision, while the Justice Department did not respond to requests for comment from ABC7 and Military.com.
Far Left: No far-left outlet coverage of the October 23 ruling was found in our searches.
Left: Gov. Gavin Newsom framed the ruling as a defense of the rule of law and state control of the Guard, as quoted by Military.com.
Moderate: ABC7 and FOX 11 reported the court found the "rebellion" claim fell outside a "range of honest judgment."
Right: Judge Mark Bennett argued the case should have been dismissed at the administration's request, according to MEAWW.
Far Right: No far-right outlet coverage of the October 23 ruling was found in our searches.
✓ Common Ground
Judges appointed by Trump split on the case: Eric Miller joined the majority while Mark Bennett dissented, Political.org and MEAWW reported, so the outcome did not break along appointing-party lines.
The majority and the dissent both treated the Supreme Court's Trump v. Illinois decision as relevant; Bennett's objection, per Law Commentary, was that the parties had briefed it only briefly.
An earlier 9th Circuit panel, including Sung, had rejected the administration's argument that a Guard federalization is immune from court review, and FOX 11 reported that point still stands.
Objective Deep Dive

Trump federalized about 4,000 California Guard members on June 7, 2025, citing 10 U.S.C. 12406, after protests over immigration raids in the Los Angeles area, Law Commentary reported. U.S. District Judge Charles Breyer blocked the move, and in June 2025 a 9th Circuit panel of Sung, Miller and Bennett let Trump keep control while rejecting the claim that his decision was beyond court review. The Supreme Court's December 2025 ruling in Trump v. Illinois, which read "regular forces" as likely meaning the regular military, changed the legal footing, MEAWW and Political.org reported. The October 23 decision applies that reading to Los Angeles.

California officials are on solid ground in calling this a legal win: the majority found statutory violations and, per Law Commentary, a likely Tenth Amendment problem and an intrusion on Congress's power over the militia. Their framing leaves out that the decision reviews a preliminary injunction and that the troops left months ago, so it changes little on the ground. Bennett's dissent raises a fair procedural question about deciding a case on briefs written before the Supreme Court ruled, but it does not dispute the Illinois standard itself. The administration has not explained its position publicly since the ruling.

The administration could seek rehearing by the full 9th Circuit or petition the Supreme Court; Political.org reported no such filing yet. A separate appeal over whether Guard troops may do civilian law enforcement remains on hold, Law Commentary reported. Military.com noted concern about Guard deployments near polling sites before the midterms, which the administration has said it does not plan. The ruling now binds any future Guard federalization in the western states the 9th Circuit covers.

◈ Tone Comparison

Newsom used charged language, calling the deployment an "illegal, authoritarian takeover" in remarks carried by Military.com, and Bonta's office called it "a clear example of federal overreach." The administration's side appears in coverage only through its legal briefs and Judge Bennett's procedural dissent, since the Justice Department did not comment.