Archdiocese of New York agrees to pay more than $800 million to settle abuse claims

New York's Catholic archdiocese agreed to pay over $800 million to about 1,300 abuse survivors, avoiding bankruptcy.

Objective Facts

The Roman Catholic Archdiocese of New York agreed to pay more than $800 million to settle sexual abuse claims from about 1,300 people, The New York Times first reported on Oct. 23. Archbishop Ronald Hicks confirmed the deal in an Oct. 24 email to priests, and attorney Jeff Anderson said on Oct. 25 that all claimants had signed on, according to OSV News. Survivors can choose a $250,000 quick payment or an individual review that could pay more, and the archdiocese must publish and update a list of credibly accused clergy. The agreement is not final until it is signed, which OSV News and Al Jazeera said is set for the week of Nov. 6.

Deep Dive

The agreement closes a fight that began after New York's Child Victims Act of 2019 and Adult Survivors Act of 2022 reopened old abuse claims. CBS News New York reported in May that the archdiocese first offered $800 million on May 1, with $615 million to be paid up front and $185 million within about 15 months. Before that, Cardinal Timothy Dolan had sold the Manhattan headquarters to Vanbarton Group for $100 million and announced in December 2025 a plan to raise more than $300 million, America Magazine reported. Hicks, who succeeded Dolan in February, inherited the talks. Retired Judge Daniel J. Buckley mediated, the same role he played in the Los Angeles settlement. The last weeks turned on holdouts. The New York Times, in a story republished by The Boston Globe, said the archdiocese worked out a $20 million insurer fund to split among holdouts. Lawyers had warned clients that rejecting the deal would likely push the church into bankruptcy, which would cut payouts and drag out the case. On Oct. 23, Trusha Goffe of Jeff Anderson & Associates told clients that "All of the survivors agreed to the revised deal." Archdiocese spokesperson Joseph Zwilling said that evening the deal was not yet complete. La Voce di New York noted that some claimants had felt the terms fell short and that several claimants had died during the process. Survivors' lawyers describe the deal as accountability won by persistence, and the archdiocese describes it as a way to move forward. Neither framing settles how individual awards will compare once the allocator weighs each case. Three things are next. The formal signing is set for the week of Nov. 6, and ABC7 New York said the deal is not final until every party signs. Plaintiffs' attorneys told ABC7 the list of accused clergy will come out soon but gave no date. The archdiocese's lawsuit against insurer Chubb continues, and Anderson said survivors will share in any recovery. OSV News estimated that the deal brings total U.S. diocesan abuse payouts since 2004 close to, and possibly past, $6 billion.

OBJ SPEAKING

Create StoryTimelinesVoter ToolsRegional AnalysisPolicy GuideAll StoriesCommunity PicksUSWorldPoliticsBusinessHealthEntertainmentTechnologyAbout

Archdiocese of New York agrees to pay more than $800 million to settle abuse claims

New York's Catholic archdiocese agreed to pay over $800 million to about 1,300 abuse survivors, avoiding bankruptcy.

Oct 26, 2026· Updated Oct 27, 2026
What's Going On
  • Archbishop Ronald Hicks told priests in an Oct. 24 email that the deal would resolve all outstanding abuse claims against the archdiocese, its parishes and affiliated agencies, according to America Magazine.
  • Each of the roughly 1,300 claimants can take a flat $250,000 payment or seek a larger award through a neutral allocator, according to OSV News and ABC7 New York.
  • Attorney Jeff Anderson said on Oct. 25 that every survivor with a claim had agreed to the plan, which the parties expect to sign the week of Nov. 6, OSV News reported.
  • The archdiocese must publish a list of credibly accused clergy and release offenders' files, and survivors gain an interest in its insurance lawsuit against Chubb, Anderson said.
  • Al Jazeera called it the second largest Catholic abuse settlement of its kind, behind the Archdiocese of Los Angeles deal in 2024.
◆ All Sources (9)
The Boston Globe (The New York Times) - Archdiocese of New York close to settling sexual abuse claims for over $800 millionAmerica Magazine - Archdiocese of New York reaches $800 million abuse settlementAngelus News - Archdiocese of New York reaches $800 million abuse settlementAl Jazeera - New York Archdiocese agrees to pay $800m to 1,300 sexual abuse survivorsABC7 New York - New York Archdiocese settlement: Survivor Joseph Caramanno on $800 million payoutGeo News (AFP) - NY Catholic Church body to pay over $800m to compensate hundreds of clergy abuse survivorsLa Voce di New York - Archdiocese of New York nears $800M abuse deal, but agreement is not finalLifeSiteNews - Archdiocese of New York to pay $800+ million to settle 1.3k abuse allegationsCBS News New York - Archdiocese of New York offers $800 million sex abuse settlement
Objective Deep Dive

The agreement closes a fight that began after New York's Child Victims Act of 2019 and Adult Survivors Act of 2022 reopened old abuse claims. CBS News New York reported in May that the archdiocese first offered $800 million on May 1, with $615 million to be paid up front and $185 million within about 15 months. Before that, Cardinal Timothy Dolan had sold the Manhattan headquarters to Vanbarton Group for $100 million and announced in December 2025 a plan to raise more than $300 million, America Magazine reported. Hicks, who succeeded Dolan in February, inherited the talks. Retired Judge Daniel J. Buckley mediated, the same role he played in the Los Angeles settlement.

The last weeks turned on holdouts. The New York Times, in a story republished by The Boston Globe, said the archdiocese worked out a $20 million insurer fund to split among holdouts. Lawyers had warned clients that rejecting the deal would likely push the church into bankruptcy, which would cut payouts and drag out the case. On Oct. 23, Trusha Goffe of Jeff Anderson & Associates told clients that "All of the survivors agreed to the revised deal." Archdiocese spokesperson Joseph Zwilling said that evening the deal was not yet complete. La Voce di New York noted that some claimants had felt the terms fell short and that several claimants had died during the process. Survivors' lawyers describe the deal as accountability won by persistence, and the archdiocese describes it as a way to move forward. Neither framing settles how individual awards will compare once the allocator weighs each case.

Three things are next. The formal signing is set for the week of Nov. 6, and ABC7 New York said the deal is not final until every party signs. Plaintiffs' attorneys told ABC7 the list of accused clergy will come out soon but gave no date. The archdiocese's lawsuit against insurer Chubb continues, and Anderson said survivors will share in any recovery. OSV News estimated that the deal brings total U.S. diocesan abuse payouts since 2004 close to, and possibly past, $6 billion.

◈ Tone Comparison

Coverage of the deal did not split along partisan lines. Church outlets such as America Magazine and Angelus News, which both ran an OSV News report by Gina Christian, led with Hicks's hope for "healing and reconciliation," while ABC7 New York led with survivor Joseph Caramanno saying the deal "still doesn't seem real." LifeSiteNews, a traditionalist Catholic site, wrote that the scandal had "threatened to bankrupt" the archdiocese.