British Columbia sues OpenAI over the Tumbler Ridge shooting
British Columbia sued OpenAI and Sam Altman, alleging the company never warned police about the Tumbler Ridge shooter.
Objective Facts
The government of British Columbia filed suit against OpenAI and Sam Altman on September 21, 2026, in federal court in San Francisco, alleging the company failed to alert police to violent ChatGPT activity by the person who carried out the February 10 mass shooting in Tumbler Ridge, B.C., in which eight people were killed, including five students and an education assistant at the town's secondary school. Citing whistleblowers who spoke to The Wall Street Journal, the complaint says OpenAI's safety team flagged the account in June 2025 and recommended contacting the RCMP, that leadership overruled them, and that the shooter kept using ChatGPT through a second account after the first was deactivated, Reuters reported. The province and the local school district seek damages for a replacement school, counselling and other recovery costs, along with an injunction requiring new ChatGPT safeguards. OpenAI spokesperson Drew Pusateri said the company remains committed to working with government and law enforcement, and OpenAI has said the account did not meet its internal criteria for a police referral. Canadian coverage stressed Sharma's call for national AI rules and Criminal Code changes, while overseas outlets such as Al Jazeera and Gulf News carried wire reports focused on the U.S. court fight.
Deep Dive
The provincial suit is the newest of several over the Tumbler Ridge shooting. Seven private claims were filed in the spring and 30 more in early September on behalf of victims and witnesses, and OpenAI moved on September 17 to dismiss the earlier cases, arguing they belong in a different court, with a hearing set for November 5, Black Press reported. Sharma said in July that the province had retained California counsel, and she told Black Press that California gives the province different rules and the best chance of forcing change. The province's main factual allegation comes from Wall Street Journal reporting on whistleblowers, which said safety staff wanted to contact police in June 2025 and were overruled. According to Tom's Hardware, the complaint also argues that OpenAI's Model Spec told ChatGPT to "assume best intentions" and that an anti-violence red line was added only in December 2025. On the core dispute, both sides agree the account was flagged and that police were not called before the attack. OpenAI's position, reported by Reuters and IBTimes UK, is that the activity did not show an imminent and credible threat meeting its referral threshold; the company has said that under guidelines updated after June 2025 such an account would now be reported, according to AFP. Altman said in April he was "deeply sorry" the company did not alert police, Al Jazeera reported, and the province argues the reforms he promised never came. The coverage leaves some details unsettled, including whether the first account was banned or merely deactivated, which The Canadian Press noted. No court has yet decided whether an AI company owes a legal duty to warn police about a user's threats. The next steps run through two tracks. In court, the November 5 hearing on OpenAI's motions to dismiss the private suits could shape where the province's case is heard. In policy, Sharma has written to federal ministers Evan Solomon and Marc Miller asking for Criminal Code amendments so AI companies can be held criminally accountable, saying the federal Bill C-34 does not go far enough, Black Press reported. Sharma has also said she wants the shooter's chat logs, which OpenAI has declined to give the province, CTV News reported.
Regional Perspective
In Canada, The Canadian Press's Brenna Owen led with Sharma's statement that "One telephone call to the RCMP could have prevented the tragedy," and reported that the suit seeks the cost of a new secondary school and more than 900 counselling sessions delivered by youth mental health teams. Black Press reporter Lauren Collins detailed the filing in the Northern District of California and Sharma's letters to federal ministers Evan Solomon and Marc Miller. CTV News's Andrew Weichel highlighted Sharma's account that OpenAI refused to share the shooter's chat history with the province. The Logic, a Canadian business and tech outlet, quoted Sharma saying the case "raises serious questions about the responsibilities of technology companies." The provincial government's own statement urged "the urgent need for strong national safeguards for artificial intelligence technologies" and compared the case to B.C.'s earlier suits against tobacco, opioid and vaping companies. Outside Canada, coverage relied mostly on wire copy. AFP, as carried by Gulf News, explained the California venue, quoted Sharma saying the province wants "accountability and change," and noted that OpenAI has argued the families' suits belong in British Columbia. Al Jazeera summarized the Reuters account and Sharma's call for national safeguards. These outlets gave more space to OpenAI's April apology and its account of the referral threshold, and less to Canadian legislative proposals. For British Columbia, the suit is a way to recover the cost of rebuilding in a town of about 2,400 people, where the federal and provincial governments have each committed $100 million to new construction, according to Tom's Hardware. For the United States, where OpenAI is based, the case adds a government plaintiff to a growing list of suits over whether AI companies must report users' violent threats; Reuters noted that Florida became the first state to sue OpenAI over safety risks in June.