Data center opposition becomes a midterm issue in Ohio and Arizona
Voter anger over data centers is shaping a toss-up Senate race in Ohio and a swing House seat in Arizona.
Objective Facts
KFF Health News, in a story republished by CBS News on Oct. 29, reported that data center fights have become campaign issues in Ohio and Arizona. In Ohio, former Sen. Sherrod Brown is attacking Republican Sen. Jon Husted over the tax breaks Husted backed as lieutenant governor, and an early October Ohio Northern University and SurveyUSA poll found 55% of adults opposed data center construction. In Arizona, an August Noble Predictive Insights poll found 57% of registered voters opposed new large data centers, and the issue has split the candidates in the competitive 1st Congressional District. Attorney General Kris Mayes wants a statewide pause, but Gov. Katie Hobbs and Republican nominee Andy Biggs oppose one and instead favor statewide water and power standards.
Left-Leaning Perspective
Mainstream left coverage that could be fully read was thin. The Daily Beast framed the Ohio race around Republican alarm, with a headline describing the GOP as panicking over a threat that could sink a MAGA senator. NPR aired and published several Ohio pieces in October, but this analysis could not open them, so they are not cited here.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Right-leaning coverage questioned Brown's consistency and treated the issue as a GOP vulnerability that candidates can manage. Fox News reporters Kiera McDonald and Andrew Mark Miller reported that Google's corporate PAC gave Brown $20,000 over his career and that Brown praised an Amazon data center in 2015. Republican strategist Mehek Cooke told Fox News the contrast amounted to "Jekyll-and-Hyde politics." The Washington Examiner's Naomi Lim reported that GOP officials are giving candidates room to tailor their positions to local concerns about power bills and water.
Deep Dive
Ohio and Arizona arrived at this fight from different directions. Ohio spent roughly $2.5 billion in state and local tax breaks over a decade attracting Meta, Amazon and Google, according to KFF Health News, and Signal Cleveland reported the state's sales tax break cost $1.6 billion in one year against a $135 million estimate. Arizona's debate is driven more by water, with shrinking Colorado River supplies and a three year pause on data center tax incentives that Hobbs negotiated with Republican lawmakers. In both states, polling cited by KFF Health News shows majorities opposed to new construction. Democrats are right that the polling favors skepticism, and Republicans themselves have conceded the point: the NRSC memo, as quoted by News 5 Cleveland, called data centers "the anchor hanging around Husted's neck." Democratic messaging tends to leave out the jobs side of the ledger. Building trades groups in Ohio back the industry, and the Cleveland Building Trades Council endorsed Husted, Signal Cleveland reported. Republican coverage points to Brown's and Shah's past support, which is documented, but it says less about why GOP leaders' own polling shows the issue hurting them. Positions in both parties have moved toward the same middle ground of local approval and requiring companies to pay for power, which makes the remaining differences more about past records than future policy. The Nov. 3 results will offer a direct test. Ohio's toss-up Senate race, rated that way by Cook Political Report and Sabato's Crystal Ball according to Newsweek, could help decide control of the Senate, and Arizona's 1st District could help decide the House. Ohio's 18 local ballot measures, counted by Yahoo Tech, will show whether opposition holds up at the precinct level. In Arizona, watch whether Mayes's proposed community vote and siting commission gains traction after the election, given that both governor candidates reject her moratorium.