EEOC votes to end requirement that employers report workforce demographic data
The EEOC voted 2-1 to propose scrapping the 60-year-old EEO-1 race and sex reporting rule for employers.
Objective Facts
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission's Republican majority voted 2-1 on Tuesday, July 21, 2026, to publish a notice of proposed rulemaking that would rescind the EEO-1 workforce demographic report and the related reports filed by unions, schools and state and local governments. Chair Andrea Lucas led the effort and argued the reports are at odds with Title VII and impose about $275 million in annual costs on employers, according to the EEOC's announcement. Commissioner Kalpana Kotagal, the lone Democrat, voted against it. The proposal now faces a 30-day public comment period and an August 11 hearing; the EEOC said it keeps its power to request specific records during individual discrimination investigations.
Left-Leaning Perspective
Al Jazeera's July 22 explainer by Andy Hirschfeld leaned on the rule's critics. Harvard's Sharon Block said the reports compel no hiring or firing decisions, and former EEOC commissioner Chai Feldblum warned that employers who stop keeping the data may struggle to produce it when investigators ask. Black Enterprise's Selena Hill, writing July 23, presented the vote as a Trump administration rollback and gave most of her space to Kotagal and civil rights groups, who said the data has long been a main tool for spotting bias. The Boston Globe's July 21 report carried Kotagal's description of the data as an enforcement tool the agency relies on.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Searches of The Wall Street Journal, Fox News, National Review, the Washington Examiner and the New York Post turned up no original commentary or reporting on the vote within three days of it. The case for the rule comes mainly from Lucas herself: the EEOC's July 21 announcement said the reports conflict with Title VII and Supreme Court precedent, may raise constitutional concerns and gather data that is not narrowly tailored. AP noted the change was recommended by Project 2025, the Heritage Foundation blueprint. SHRM, the large HR trade group, said it backs rescinding the current reports only if a more modern and useful framework replaces them.
Deep Dive
The EEO-1 dates to 1966 and is the federal government's main annual census of who holds which jobs at large private employers. AP reported that it covers more than 50 million workers at about 73,000 employers and has tracked trends such as women's share of senior management rising from 29.2% to 34.5% between 2013 and 2023. The EEOC first submitted its rescission plan in May, according to Axios, and Project 2025 had recommended the change. The July 21 vote does not end the reports; it starts a rulemaking that the EEOC said will include a 30-day comment period and an August 11 hearing. Lucas has a point that the reports impose real paperwork costs and that the EEOC can still subpoena records in individual cases, which her critics acknowledge. Her legal theory, that aggregate counting itself conflicts with a colorblind Title VII, is untested and was not engaged in depth in the coverage found. Critics are on firm ground that the data has fed pattern investigations and public research, but coverage gave little detail on how often the agency's cases actually began from EEO-1 numbers. Neither side's coverage resolved how much monitoring would continue voluntarily: AP found 60 large companies still publishing their data in 2025, while 24 had stopped. The next steps are publication in the Federal Register, the comment window and the August 11 hearing. Reports are usually due September 30, Reuters noted, and employers face current obligations until a final rule is issued. Kotagal's prediction that a later administration would restore the reports points to how the reports' fate is tied to who controls the commission, and some states keep their own demographic reporting rules, as Jennifer Robins of Saul Ewing told Axios.