Ex-IDF chief Halevi says October 7 attack was preventable
Former IDF chief Herzi Halevi said October 7 was preventable and rejected claims of insider betrayal.
Objective Facts
Herzi Halevi, who resigned as chief of the Israel Defense Forces over the October 7 failures and left the post in March 2025, told a Shurat HaDin conference in New York on November 1, 2026 that the 2023 Hamas attack could have been prevented. He said there was no betrayal from within Israel's security establishment and argued that no network of collaborators has surfaced in three years. He said Israel's intelligence and political leadership believed Hamas did not want war and placed Iran and Hezbollah ahead of it as threats. He also said Israeli strikes unintentionally killed hostages and that ground pressure in Gaza was needed to bring hostages home. Coverage so far comes almost entirely from Israeli and Jewish outlets, which reported his remarks without published responses from the government or opposition.
Deep Dive
Halevi announced his resignation in January 2025 and stepped down that March after accepting responsibility for the military's failures on October 7, 2023. His New York speech was his first extended public account since then. According to The Media Line, the question of how Israel investigates the attack is still open: Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has resisted a conventional state commission of inquiry, and Israel's High Court has given the government until January 15, 2027 to explain its plans. The core of Halevi's message had two parts. He admitted fault, saying Israel misread Hamas and that "Hamas invested significant effort into leading us to this assessment," as Ynet's Itamar Eichner reported. He also defended the security services against the theory that insiders helped Hamas, arguing such a plot would require many participants. None of the articles reviewed named who has promoted that theory or carried a response from Netanyahu's office, so readers have Halevi's side of the argument only. His admission that Israeli bombs killed hostages, reported by Israel National News and Matzav, went further than most past official statements, though he paired it with a defense of the ground offensive. The next test is the inquiry fight. Reports diverge on Halevi's position: The Jerusalem Post and The Media Line said he called for a state commission, while Ynet said he spoke of completing an investigation without explicitly endorsing one. Any reply from the government, from opposition leaders or from bereaved families, and the government's answer to the High Court in January, will show whether his remarks change that debate.
Regional Perspective
Israeli coverage appeared within hours of the speech. Ynet's Itamar Eichner reported Halevi's account of how Israel misjudged Hamas and ranked it third among threats. i24NEWS built its story around his rejection of the claim that October 7 was an inside job. Israel National News quoted his statement that Israeli bombs killed hostages and his description of convincing the political leadership to send ground forces into Gaza. Itón Gadol, a Latin American Jewish site, carried a Spanish account credited to Agencia AJN. The Israeli outlets differ on the inquiry question. i24NEWS wrote that Halevi supported a state commission of inquiry, while Ynet said he called for finishing an investigation without explicitly endorsing a state commission. Ynet also reported that he did not directly answer a question on whether Israel can achieve absolute victory. None of the Israeli reports reviewed included a reply from Netanyahu's office or from opposition figures. In Israel the remarks land on an open dispute over who answers for October 7. A former chief of staff saying the attack was preventable, while defending the security services against betrayal claims, puts the military's version on record as the government faces a High Court deadline on its investigation plans.