Far-right AfD wins Saxony-Anhalt state election in Germany but falls short of majority
The AfD won 43.8% in Saxony-Anhalt, its best result ever, but fell three seats short of a majority.
Objective Facts
The AfD won 43.8% of the vote in Saxony-Anhalt's state election on September 6, its strongest result in any German election, while the CDU of Chancellor Friedrich Merz dropped to 17.2%, NPR, CBS News and Al Jazeera reported. The AfD took 39 of 83 seats, three short of a majority, so 35-year-old lead candidate Ulrich Siegmund cannot become state premier without help from another party or individual defectors. Incumbent CDU premier Sven Schulze said he does not intend to work with the AfD, and Thorsten Frei, who leads the CDU/CSU group in the Bundestag, said his party does not talk to right-wing extremists, according to CBS News. On September 7, BSW lead candidate Thomas Schulze said the left-populist BSW, which won five seats, was willing to help an AfD governor take office, the Associated Press reported. German regional outlets including Nordkurier and the dpa report carried by Volksstimme emphasized record turnout and calls inside the CDU for leadership changes, while Polish Radio led with Donald Tusk's statement that only idiots or traitors could celebrate the AfD win.
Left-Leaning Perspective
NPR's Esme Nicholson called the result an electoral breakthrough for the far right and stressed the alarm it caused abroad, reporting that Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk condemned it and French Europe minister Benjamin Haddad called it a grave moment for Europe. NPR also noted that Donald Trump shared a screenshot of the results and that Russian envoy Kirill Dmitriev praised the win. CBS News correspondent Anna Noryskiewicz centered the pressure on Friedrich Merz, reporting that CDU youth figure Tim Brand became the first party voice to call for Merz to step down.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Fox News reporter Landon Mion framed the result as a major blow to Merz's CDU and a historic moment for the AfD, quoting CDU general secretary Franziska Hoppermann's pledge not to work with the party and noting its extremism classification. The Washington Examiner ran the AP story under a headline stressing the pressure the landslide puts on Merz. In UnHerd, historian Katja Hoyer argued the AfD can no longer be dismissed as a fringe party and that the firewall has been breached in practice.
Deep Dive
Saxony-Anhalt had been governed by a CDU, SPD and FDP coalition under Sven Schulze, and the AfD more than doubled its 2021 share to 43.8% on record turnout of about 78%, according to Nordkurier and Volksstimme. The state's domestic intelligence service classifies the regional AfD as a confirmed right-wing extremist group, and the party campaigned on remigration, including deportations, Fox News and NPR reported. The new parliament must meet by October 6, Volksstimme reported, and outgoing ministers stay in office until a successor is elected. Coverage that dwells on alarm, such as NPR and Novara Media, captures how unusual this result is in postwar Germany but spends less time on the arithmetic: the AfD still needs three more votes. Right-leaning commentary from Luke Nicastro and Katja Hoyer correctly identifies the scale of the AfD's appeal, but gives less weight to the extremism classification and to the fact that the AfD has never sat in any state or federal government. The AP's account of the three possible paths (a BSW deal, a five-party coalition, or defections) is the clearest guide to what can actually happen. The next steps are the BSW's final position, which shifted within a day according to Axios and the AP, and whether any CDU lawmakers break ranks. CBS News reported that in a third round of voting a simple majority could be enough, so abstentions by BSW members could decide the outcome. Pressure on Merz is also building, with CBS News reporting the first call from inside the CDU for him to step down and Volksstimme reporting that state lawmaker Eva Feußner called for Schulze to resign.
Regional Perspective
In Saxony-Anhalt's own press, the dpa report carried by Magdeburg's Volksstimme called the CDU result a debacle and listed the state party's worst-ever share alongside the Greens' best-ever showing in the state. It quoted CDU deputy Bundestag leader Sepp Müller saying the mandate to form a government now lies with the AfD, and reported that CDU state lawmaker Eva Feußner called for Schulze to resign. Nordkurier headlined Siegmund's refusal to rule out a new election and quoted BSW candidate Thomas Schulze saying the firewall did not interest his party. In Poland, Polish Radio reported Donald Tusk's post that only idiots or traitors could rejoice at the AfD win, and quoted Centre group leader Ryszard Petru calling for less ideology and more practical answers. German regional outlets spent more time on the mechanics of forming a government than US outlets did, including the October 6 deadline for the new parliament's first session and the record turnout of about 78%. Polish coverage, by contrast, read the result through security and Russia, with Tusk linking AfD sympathizers to Poland's own Confederation and PiS parties. Al Jazeera's report highlighted Thuringia interior minister Georg Maier's claim that the Kremlin views the AfD as a key tool for destabilizing Germany, a theme that featured less in US right-leaning coverage. For Germans in the east, the question is whether a party under extremism classification will control a state's police and intelligence apparatus, and Axios reported the AfD platform includes overhauling the intelligence service's mandate. For Poland, the concern is a pro-Russian shift in a neighboring German state, which Tusk used to attack his domestic rivals.