Federal appeals court blocks IRS from sharing taxpayer data with ICE
A federal appeals court upheld an order barring the IRS from handing taxpayer addresses to ICE, finding the process likely unlawful.
Objective Facts
The D.C. Circuit on September 8 upheld an injunction issued by U.S. District Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly that stops the IRS from disclosing taxpayer information to Immigration and Customs Enforcement under a 2025 data-sharing agreement, Reuters reported. Writing for a unanimous panel, Judge Cornelia Pillard found the IRS procedure likely violated Section 6103 of the tax code because it let ICE obtain records by entering any five- or nine-digit number in the address field, even if it was not a real ZIP code. The IRS had disclosed 47,289 records out of ICE requests covering up to 1.28 million people before the policy was halted. The Trump administration argued the order hindered law enforcement, and DHS said after the ruling that it disagreed and would keep using other lawful tools to find and deport people with final removal orders, according to Fox News.
Left-Leaning Perspective
All Rise News reporter Adam Klasfeld framed the decision as another setback for the administration's mass deportation agenda and focused on the court's view that the IRS swapped individual review for bulk, automated processing. He noted the panel also kept a requirement that the IRS give a court advance notice, which may be filed under seal, before further disclosures. Mainstream left outlets such as The New York Times or CNN did not surface with dedicated coverage of this ruling in searches.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Fox News' Landon Mion, with Reuters contributing, reported the ruling as a legal loss for the Trump administration, referred to the affected taxpayers as suspected illegal migrants, and gave space to the administration's argument that the order hampers enforcement. The report carried DHS's response that it will keep pursuing people with final removal orders. Other mainstream right outlets gave the ruling little separate attention in this window.
Deep Dive
The dispute stems from an April 2025 agreement signed by Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem, under which the IRS agreed to check ICE requests for the addresses of people suspected of living in the U.S. unlawfully. Section 6103 of the tax code allows such disclosures only under strict conditions, including that the requesting agency supply the taxpayer's address. Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly halted the procedure in November 2025, and the D.C. Circuit's September 8 ruling keeps that block in place while the case proceeds. The opinion rests on procedure. Reuters and CPA Practice Advisor reported that the court objected to a system that accepted any five- or nine-digit number as an address and processed requests in bulk, without individual review. Critics who focused on the judges' wording, as in the Fox News Digital piece, said little about these statutory findings. Because the ruling turns on how the IRS processed requests, coverage on both sides said less about whether a narrower procedure with individual review could pass muster, a question the separate Public Citizen suit noted by Accounting Today may also raise. Next steps include the government's options for further review and the continuing district court case over the 47,289 records already disclosed. The court's warning that IRS officials face civil and criminal exposure for willful violations, reported by FedScoop, puts pressure on the agency to change its procedure before resuming any transfers to ICE.