Federal appeals panel sides with Missouri Republicans on new congressional map
The 8th Circuit ordered Missouri to use its 2025 GOP map in November, then paused the order for Supreme Court review.
Objective Facts
A three-judge panel of the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled on September 21, 2026, that Missouri must hold its November 3 congressional elections under the Republican-drawn 2025 map that it used in the August primary, finding that a mid-cycle switch back to the 2022 lines would violate the Constitution, according to the Associated Press, Reuters and Roll Call. The panel of Judges James Loken, a George H.W. Bush appointee, and David Stras and Justin Smith, both Trump appointees, told Chief U.S. District Judge Stephen Clark to enter a permanent injunction barring Secretary of State Denny Hoskins from using any other map; Newsweek reported that Stras dissented in part, arguing the map's opponents lacked standing. The order is on hold until September 28, so the 2022 map required by the Missouri Supreme Court's September 3 ruling and a September 10 U.S. Supreme Court order stays in force for now, while military and overseas ballots printed with the 2022 lines have already been mailed. The map's opponents, People Not Politicians Missouri, took the fight to the Supreme Court for a third time, and Justice Brett Kavanaugh set a September 23 deadline for responses, Fox News reported. The 2025 map targets the Kansas City seat of Democratic Rep. Emanuel Cleaver and could shift the state's delegation from 6-2 to 7-1 Republican.
Left-Leaning Perspective
OBJ Speaking could not read The New York Times, Politico or other national left-leaning reports on the ruling, so this band relies on the Missouri Independent, a nonprofit newsroom whose headline called the plan "Missouri's gerrymandered map." Rudi Keller's report focused on the practical burden for county clerks and on the stay, noting that the order would mark the fourth change in direction on the map since September 3. Keller also reported that the panel blamed the confusion on the Missouri Supreme Court's late ruling and rejected claims that it was improperly overriding state courts.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Fox News Digital's Anders Hagstrom covered the ruling mainly as the trigger for a third Supreme Court round, describing a back-and-forth fight over a divisive map that could give Republicans an extra House seat. Hagstrom reported Kavanaugh's call for responses and noted that the county clerks' association said it would not use the 2025 map in November. The Republican plaintiffs made their own case in local outlets: Rep. Bob Onder told St. Louis Public Radio the ruling was a win for democracy, and state Sen. Rick Brattin told AP that switching districts after the primary makes no sense. OBJ Speaking did not find Wall Street Journal or National Review commentary on the ruling in the coverage window.
Deep Dive
Missouri Republicans passed the 2025 map in a special session as part of a Trump-backed push for mid-decade redistricting, splitting Cleaver's Kansas City-based 5th District. People Not Politicians gathered more than 300,000 signatures for a referendum, Hoskins rejected the petition on primary day, and the Missouri Supreme Court ruled on September 3 that the pending referendum keeps the map from taking effect. Onder, Brattin and two voters then won a federal order from Judge Stephen Clark requiring the 2025 map, which the U.S. Supreme Court paused on September 10 while the 8th Circuit heard the case on September 17. The Republican plaintiffs have a real point that the August primary was run under the 2025 lines, so Brattin and others won nominations in districts that would vanish in November, and the panel's equal protection reasoning rests on that mismatch. The opponents are right that the U.S. Supreme Court has twice kept the 2025 map out of the general election and that ballots built on the 2022 lines are already in voters' hands, which local clerks say makes reversal costly and partly irreversible. Partisan coverage on each side gave less attention to Judge Stras' partial dissent on standing, reported by Newsweek, and to the stay, which means nothing changed on the ground when the ruling came down. The immediate question is whether the Supreme Court extends its earlier pause or lets the 8th Circuit order take effect after September 28. Kavanaugh's September 23 deadline for responses puts a decision close to the start of general absentee voting. The answer will decide whether Republicans can contest a 7-1 delegation in November and whether voters in about a quarter of the state cast ballots in districts that differ from the ones on their primary ballot.