Federal judge blocks Trump's new birthright citizenship order targeting 'birth tourism'
A Maryland federal judge blocked Donald Trump's narrower August birthright citizenship order, citing the Supreme Court's June ruling.
Objective Facts
US District Judge Deborah Boardman of Maryland on September 2 preliminarily blocked the executive order Donald Trump signed in August to narrow birthright citizenship, the Associated Press and Bloomberg News reported. The order would have denied citizenship to children of parents with ties to foreign governments or international organizations, people designated alien enemies or terrorists, and parents who entered on a visa to give birth or paid for access to citizenship. Boardman, ruling in the class action Casa Inc. v. Trump, said the Supreme Court's June decision against Trump's first order already settled that the children in the class are citizens, and she rejected the Justice Department's argument that the challenge was premature. The injunction stays in place while the case continues, and Bloomberg reported the government could ask an appeals court to lift it.
Left-Leaning Perspective
Direct coverage from The New York Times, The Washington Post, NPR or CNN could not be retrieved, though a FOX 5 New York report by Daniel Miller relied on The Washington Post for the point that the order would reach babies the Supreme Court already recognized as citizens. JURIST, the legal news service, framed the order as harsh and disproportionate and noted that experts consider birth tourism relatively rare.
Right-Leaning Perspective
The Washington Examiner's David Zimmermann framed the ruling around birth tourism, the part of the order with the broadest public appeal, and identified Boardman as a Biden appointee. The White House, through spokesperson Lauren Bis, dismissed the decision as judicial activism in a statement reported by Bloomberg News.
Deep Dive
The Supreme Court struck down Donald Trump's first birthright citizenship order in June 2026, holding that children born to parents here unlawfully or on temporary visas are citizens under the 14th Amendment. The administration answered in August with a narrower order aimed at birth tourism, families linked to foreign governments or international bodies, people deemed alien enemies or terrorists, and those who paid for access to citizenship. Boardman, who had blocked the first order in 2025, ruled on September 2 that the children in her certified class remain citizens and enjoined the agencies that issue passports, immigration documents and Social Security numbers. The plaintiffs' side, as reported by the AP, has the advantage of the June precedent and of concrete fears, including families worried that buying airfare or a distant relative's gang ties could cost a child citizenship. The administration's side, voiced by Lauren Bis and The Federalist, has a narrower but real argument: some categories in the August order, such as children of foreign diplomats, were not squarely before the Supreme Court in June. Coverage reviewed did not give a full picture of how many births the new categories would touch, and JURIST cited experts who consider birth tourism relatively rare. The next step is whether the Justice Department asks a federal appeals court to lift the injunction, which Bloomberg said it could do. A separate challenge in New Hampshire is pending, and the class certification itself, criticized by The Federalist, may become a target on appeal.