Federal judge in Colorado opens contempt inquiry after ICE re-arrests detainees freed by court order
Judge Charlotte Sweeney said ICE defied her release order by re-arresting a detainee and summoned its Denver field director.
Objective Facts
U.S. District Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney, a Joe Biden appointee in Denver, opened an inquiry on Nov. 4 into ICE's practice of releasing detainees under court order and re-arresting them on the spot. The case before her involved Ramon Quintero Alvarez, a Wyoming man held at the privately run detention center in Aurora, who was released after Sweeney's 24-hour deadline passed and was immediately re-detained, according to Michael Karlik of Colorado Politics. ICE official Nichole Black testified the re-detention order came from Field Office Director Nathan Rasper, and Sweeney ordered Alvarez freed that afternoon, summoned Rasper to a Monday hearing and demanded a list of every Colorado detainee re-arrested after a court-ordered release. Judge Nina Y. Wang scheduled a separate hearing on similar conduct, and Judge S. Kato Crews issued a release order on Nov. 3 in another re-arrest case, Newsweek reported.
Left-Leaning Perspective
We found no Colorado coverage of the Sweeney inquiry from The New York Times, NPR, CNN or other national outlets in this band. The nearest mainstream-left reporting is MPR News, where Cait Kelley and Regina Medina reported on Oct. 13 that ICE officials in Minnesota acknowledged re-arresting people right after judges ordered them freed. Their story centers on judges who called the practice an end run around habeas, including U.S. District Judge Jeffrey Bryan.
Right-Leaning Perspective
We found no Fox News, Wall Street Journal or National Review coverage of Sweeney's inquiry. The closest mainstream-right reporting is a Feb. 4 Fox News Digital story by Michael Dorgan on ICE re-arresting two Venezuelan men in Minnesota right after a judge ordered them released. Dorgan's piece leaned on DHS's account of the underlying incident, in which the men were accused of attacking an ICE officer, and also included the defense's rebuttal.
Deep Dive
Colorado's federal trial court has been swamped with habeas petitions from immigration detainees, and Colorado Politics reported that the 10th Circuit recently issued a binding ruling against the government's detention position. Alvarez's case shows how the conflict now plays out on the ground. The government let Sweeney's deadline pass, ICE complied with the release order on paper, and then agents re-detained him under what Nichole Black described as a chain of command running from Field Office Director Nathan Rasper. Similar re-arrests have surfaced in Minnesota and Louisiana, where MPR News and IBTimes Singapore reported judges threatening or imposing contempt. The judges' critics have a point that the volume of cases is enormous and that U.S. attorney offices are stretched thin, a strain Soler described in court and Courchaine described to The Daily Wire. That argument does not answer the question in Sweeney's courtroom, where the government declined to defend Alvarez's detention at all. ICE's claim that a release order does not bar future enforcement has some footing when there is new cause for arrest, but Black's testimony pointed to a standing directive to re-detain some releases on the spot, which is the conduct Sweeney called contempt. The right-leaning coverage we found mostly addressed the habeas surge in general and did not engage with the specific facts of the Colorado case. The next step is the Monday hearing at which Rasper must answer for the agency's conduct, along with the list of re-detained people Sweeney ordered the government to produce. Judge Nina Y. Wang's separate hearing on similar conduct and Crews's three-day status report deadline in the Garcia Vargas case could add more findings. Whether any Colorado judge moves from warnings to formal contempt sanctions against named ICE officials is the open question.