Federal judge rules Bill Essayli is unlawfully serving as de facto US attorney in Los Angeles

A federal judge ruled for the second time that Bill Essayli is unlawfully running the Los Angeles federal prosecutor's office.

Objective Facts

Senior U.S. District Judge J. Michael Seabright ruled on Tuesday, October 27, 2026, that Bill Essayli is unlawfully serving as the de facto top federal prosecutor for the Central District of California, which covers Los Angeles and six other counties. Seabright disqualified Essayli from participating in or supervising two criminal prosecutions, those of Tu Anh Tran and Jaime Hector Ramirez, but refused to dismiss their indictments. The judge relied on an August 9th Circuit decision that found Sigal Chattah could not run the Nevada U.S. attorney's office as first assistant, and he said a revised designation issued by Attorney General Todd Blanche on September 23 was functionally the same as Essayli's earlier one, according to MyNewsLA and the Associated Press. The order is stayed while the government seeks a stay pending appeal, and Essayli said in a statement that the Supreme Court will decide the matter. Seabright had disqualified Essayli as acting U.S. attorney in a similar ruling in October 2025, after which Essayli continued leading the office under the first assistant title.

Left-Leaning Perspective

Democracy Docket's Zachary Roth tied the ruling to the Justice Department's California voting lawsuit, describing Essayli as a former Republican state lawmaker, a Trump ally and a public face of the case seeking to segregate about 20,000 ballots. Roth wrote that numerous legal scholars consider that lawsuit very weak and said it was unclear how Seabright's order would affect Essayli's role in it. Law&Crime's Matt Naham focused on Essayli's response, noting he had said after his first disqualification that he was not planning to go anywhere and has stayed in the job.

Right-Leaning Perspective

Coverage from mainstream right outlets such as Fox News, The Wall Street Journal and National Review did not turn up in searches. Just The News reporter Kevin Killough wrote a short news account that put "unlawfully serving" in quotation marks in the headline and closed with Essayli's argument that the president and attorney general can choose Justice Department supervisors.

Deep Dive

Essayli became interim U.S. attorney for the Central District of California in April 2025. As his 120-day interim term neared its end, he resigned on July 29, 2025, and was named a special attorney and first assistant, a post that let him run the office without Senate confirmation, FOX 11 reported. Seabright ruled in October 2025 that he was not lawfully serving as acting U.S. attorney but allowed him to remain as first assistant. The picture changed in August 2026, when the 9th Circuit ruled that Sigal Chattah could not effectively run the Nevada office in the same way. Defense attorney Dean Steward then asked Seabright to reconsider, and on October 27 the judge concluded that Blanche's revised September 23 designation was functionally the same as the one the appeals court rejected. The defense and outlets such as Democracy Docket are right that the decision follows directly from binding 9th Circuit precedent, which limits how much the ruling can be cast as one judge's preference. The ruling is also narrower than some headlines suggest: it covers two cases, leaves both indictments intact, and is stayed, so Essayli remains in charge of the office for now. Right-leaning writers such as RedState's Jennifer Van Laar correctly point out that the appeal is pending and nothing changes immediately, but their coverage gives little attention to the 9th Circuit reasoning Seabright applied. The next step is the government's motion for a stay pending appeal, which CBS Los Angeles said must be filed within five business days. The larger question sits with the Supreme Court, where the administration has sought review of the Sarcone ruling; Democracy Docket said that outcome would likely shape the Essayli and Chattah disputes. Whether other defendants in the Central District file similar motions, and whether the order touches Essayli's role in the ballot lawsuit before Judge David O. Carter, are open questions.

OBJ SPEAKING

Create StoryTimelinesVoter ToolsRegional AnalysisPolicy GuideAll StoriesCommunity PicksUSWorldPoliticsBusinessHealthEntertainmentTechnologyAbout

Federal judge rules Bill Essayli is unlawfully serving as de facto US attorney in Los Angeles

A federal judge ruled for the second time that Bill Essayli is unlawfully running the Los Angeles federal prosecutor's office.

Oct 28, 2026· Updated Oct 29, 2026
What's Going On
  • On October 27, 2026, Senior U.S. District Judge J. Michael Seabright ruled that First Assistant U.S. Attorney Bill Essayli is "unlawfully serving as a 'de facto' United States Attorney" for the Central District of California, according to the Associated Press.
  • The order bars Essayli from participating in or supervising two criminal cases, those of Tu Anh Tran and Jaime Hector Ramirez, but Seabright declined to dismiss either indictment, FOX 11 Los Angeles reported.
  • Seabright found that Attorney General Todd Blanche's revised September 23 designation of Essayli did not materially differ from the Nevada designation of Sigal Chattah that the 9th Circuit rejected in August, MyNewsLA reported.
  • The disqualification is stayed and does not take effect until the court rules on a government motion for a stay pending appeal; Essayli said he expects the Supreme Court to decide the question and plans to keep serving until then.
  • The ruling came on the same day Essayli was in court arguing the Justice Department's lawsuit over about 20,000 California mail ballots from voters the administration says are likely noncitizens, Law&Crime and Democracy Docket reported.
Far Left: No far-left outlet coverage of the new Seabright ruling was found in searches.
Left: Democracy Docket linked the disqualification to Essayli's role leading the Justice Department's lawsuit over California ballots.
Moderate: The AP placed the ruling alongside earlier court decisions against interim prosecutors Alina Habba in New Jersey and John Sarcone in northern New York.
Right: Just The News described Essayli as a Trump-appointed prosecutor and gave his rebuttal the final word.
Far Right: RedState argued the ruling has nothing to do with Essayli's qualifications and pointed to the pending appeal.
✓ Common Ground
Outlets as different as Patriot TV and CBS Los Angeles expect the Supreme Court, not Seabright, to settle whether Essayli can lead the office, echoing Essayli's own statement.
Coverage from Democracy Docket, the AP and Townhall treats the Essayli ruling as part of a wider pattern of court fights over Trump administration appointments in Nevada, New Jersey and New York.
Several outlets regardless of leaning, including Law&Crime and RedState, connected the timing of the ruling to Essayli's appearance in the California ballot case.
◆ All Sources (11)
ABC News (AP) - Federal judge rules top US prosecutor in Los Angeles isn't legally servingNBC Los Angeles (AP) - Federal judge rules top US prosecutor in Los Angeles isn't legally servingCBS Los Angeles - Judge rules that Essayli has been "unlawfully" serving as LA's top federal prosecutorFOX 11 Los Angeles - Bill Essayli unlawfully serving as top federal prosecutor in Southern California, judge rulesMyNewsLA - Federal Judge Rules Essayli Cannot Act as 'De Facto' Head Prosecutor in CaliforniaDemocracy Docket - Trump prosecutor leading California voting lawsuit disqualified from post, but order stayedLaw&Crime via Yahoo News - Top prosecutor finds out he was disqualified for 2nd time after arguing DOJ's California election case, says Supreme Court must decideJust The News - Federal judge disqualifies Trump-appointed prosecutor Bill Essayli for 'unlawfully serving' in roleRedState - Essayli Leaves CA Ballot Hearing to Face Ruling That He's 'Unlawfully' Serving As US AttorneyTownhall - Federal Judge Says US Attorney Doesn't Belong in His PositionPatriot TV - Activist Judge Disqualifies Bill Essayli Once More as He Battles Noncitizen Ballots in California
Objective Deep Dive

Essayli became interim U.S. attorney for the Central District of California in April 2025. As his 120-day interim term neared its end, he resigned on July 29, 2025, and was named a special attorney and first assistant, a post that let him run the office without Senate confirmation, FOX 11 reported. Seabright ruled in October 2025 that he was not lawfully serving as acting U.S. attorney but allowed him to remain as first assistant. The picture changed in August 2026, when the 9th Circuit ruled that Sigal Chattah could not effectively run the Nevada office in the same way. Defense attorney Dean Steward then asked Seabright to reconsider, and on October 27 the judge concluded that Blanche's revised September 23 designation was functionally the same as the one the appeals court rejected.

The defense and outlets such as Democracy Docket are right that the decision follows directly from binding 9th Circuit precedent, which limits how much the ruling can be cast as one judge's preference. The ruling is also narrower than some headlines suggest: it covers two cases, leaves both indictments intact, and is stayed, so Essayli remains in charge of the office for now. Right-leaning writers such as RedState's Jennifer Van Laar correctly point out that the appeal is pending and nothing changes immediately, but their coverage gives little attention to the 9th Circuit reasoning Seabright applied.

The next step is the government's motion for a stay pending appeal, which CBS Los Angeles said must be filed within five business days. The larger question sits with the Supreme Court, where the administration has sought review of the Sarcone ruling; Democracy Docket said that outcome would likely shape the Essayli and Chattah disputes. Whether other defendants in the Central District file similar motions, and whether the order touches Essayli's role in the ballot lawsuit before Judge David O. Carter, are open questions.

◈ Tone Comparison

Democracy Docket used "Trump prosecutor" in its headline and Law&Crime noted Essayli was disqualified "for 2nd time," emphasizing a repeated legal defeat. On the right, Patriot TV called Seabright an activist judge and the ruling lawfare, and Just The News put "unlawfully serving" in quotation marks. Wire coverage from the AP stuck to "isn't legally serving" and gave space to Essayli's rebuttal.