Federal judge rules Justice Department's firing of prosecutor Maurene Comey was unconstitutional

Judge Jesse Furman ruled the Justice Department's 2025 firing of prosecutor Maurene Comey violated the Constitution and civil service law.

Objective Facts

Judge Jesse Furman of the U.S. District Court in Manhattan ruled on October 26, 2026 that the Justice Department unlawfully fired Maurene Comey, a federal prosecutor who worked on the Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell cases, in July 2025. The termination email cited only Article II of the Constitution, and Furman held the removal violated the separation of powers, the Civil Service Reform Act, the Administrative Procedure Act and her due process rights, according to CBS News, ABC News and the New York Daily News. He ordered retroactive reinstatement and back pay through December 20, 2025, when Comey joined a private law firm. The Justice Department said it will appeal, though Comey's First Amendment retaliation claim, which ties the firing to her father, former FBI Director James Comey, has not yet been decided.

Left-Leaning Perspective

CBS News reporters Jacob Rosen and Melissa Quinn led with Furman's finding that the firing broke separation of powers principles and the Civil Service Reform Act, and quoted Comey's legal team calling the decision a "hard-earned victory" for her and all civil servants. The New York Daily News, in a story by Molly Crane-Newman, stressed that Furman rejected the administration's Article II theory as contrary to long standing Supreme Court precedent. Al Jazeera, drawing on Reuters reporting, placed the case inside broader accusations that Donald Trump pursues retribution against perceived enemies.

Right-Leaning Perspective

The Daily Caller's Ashley Brasfield reported the ruling in mostly straight terms but led with Furman's background, calling him an "Obama judge" in the headline and noting that his brother Jason Furman served on Barack Obama's economic team. Conservative Daily News editor Rich Mitchell ran a largely factual account that focused on Furman's rejection of the administration's Article II theory and on acting Attorney General Todd Blanche's May 2026 memo ratifying the firing, which the judge found did not fix the problem. Searches found no dedicated coverage of the ruling from Fox News, National Review or The Wall Street Journal.

Deep Dive

Maurene Comey, a Manhattan federal prosecutor since 2015, was fired on July 16, 2025 by an email that cited only Article II of the Constitution, according to Al Jazeera and Conservative Daily News. She sued in September 2025, and Judge Jesse Furman later allowed the case to proceed in federal court, as CBS News noted. His October 26 ruling found the firing violated the separation of powers, civil service law, the Administrative Procedure Act and due process, and ordered retroactive reinstatement and back pay through December 20, 2025. The left leaning framing is correct that Furman rejected the administration's Article II theory squarely, and ABC News reported he called it contrary to almost two centuries of Supreme Court decisions. That coverage sometimes implies the court found political retaliation, but Furman has not ruled on the First Amendment claim, and 100PercentFedUp noted he did not need to resolve motive to rule for Comey. Right leaning outlets are correct that the reasoning has not been tested on appeal, yet The Daily Caller's focus on Furman's appointment says little about the legal merits, and its own story reported the judge's reasoning without disputing it. The next step is briefing on the First Amendment claim, which Conservative Daily News said the court has scheduled, and the Justice Department has said it will appeal once it can. Government Executive reported the ruling is the first of several Article II firing cases, including a suit by former pardon attorney Liz Oyer and an immigration judges' case due for December arguments. An appellate ruling on the Comey case would carry weight for other federal employees removed the same way.

OBJ SPEAKING

Create StoryTimelinesVoter ToolsRegional AnalysisPolicy GuideAll StoriesCommunity PicksUSWorldPoliticsBusinessHealthEntertainmentTechnologyAbout

Federal judge rules Justice Department's firing of prosecutor Maurene Comey was unconstitutional

Judge Jesse Furman ruled the Justice Department's 2025 firing of prosecutor Maurene Comey violated the Constitution and civil service law.

Oct 27, 2026· Updated Oct 28, 2026
What's Going On
  • On October 26, 2026, U.S. District Judge Jesse Furman of the Southern District of New York ruled that the Justice Department unlawfully fired Assistant U.S. Attorney Maurene Comey in July 2025, according to CBS News and ABC News.
  • Furman found the firing violated the separation of powers, the Civil Service Reform Act, the Administrative Procedure Act and Comey's Fifth Amendment due process rights, the New York Daily News reported.
  • He ordered Comey retroactively reinstated with back pay from her firing through December 20, 2025, when she took a private sector job, per CBS News and The Daily Caller.
  • A Justice Department spokesperson said the department disagrees with the decision and will appeal, while Comey's First Amendment claim remains pending, which may delay any appeal, the New York Daily News reported.
  • Government Executive reported the 55 page decision is the first ruling in a series of challenges by former Justice Department employees removed under the administration's "Article II" rationale.
Far Left: Democracy Now linked the ruling to the same day's new charges against James Comey, presenting both as part of one family's clash with the Trump administration.
Left: CBS News and the New York Daily News presented the ruling as a defense of civil service protections, quoting Comey's lawyers that the president is not above the law.
Moderate: ABC News reported Furman found the administration's view of removal power unsupported by Supreme Court precedent.
Right: The Daily Caller foregrounded the judge's appointment by Barack Obama and his family ties to the Obama administration.
Far Right: 100PercentFedUp framed the ruling as a setback the administration should contest on appeal as a test of presidential authority.
✓ Common Ground
Outlets from CBS News to The Daily Caller agree the ruling turns on a broad question of presidential removal power, not only on one prosecutor's job.
Coverage in The Daily Caller and on 100PercentFedUp, as well as CBS News, acknowledged Comey's record on the Epstein, Maxwell and Sean Combs prosecutions, with 100PercentFedUp noting the department rated her performance as outstanding.
Reports across outlets, including Conservative Daily News and Government Executive, expect the dispute to reach an appeals court, with both treating the final word on Article II firings as still open.
◆ All Sources (9)
ABC News - Judge rules Trump DOJ 'unlawfully' fired Maurene ComeyGovernment Executive - Judge: 'Article II' firings violate separation of powers, civil service lawAl Jazeera - US court rules daughter of Trump critic James Comey was illegally firedCBS News - Maurene Comey, James Comey's daughter, was unlawfully fired, judge rulesNew York Daily News (via Yahoo News) - NY judge rules prosecutor Maurene Comey's firing by Trump administration was unlawfulDemocracy Now - Federal Judge Rules Firing of Maurene Comey Was UnconstitutionalThe Daily Caller - James Comey's Daughter 'Unlawfully' Fired By Trump Admin, Obama Judge RulesConservative Daily News - Judge Rules DOJ Unlawfully Fired Maurene Comey, Rejects 'Expansive' Article II Theory100PercentFedUp - Obama-Appointed Judge Orders DOJ To Reinstate James Comey's Daughter, Then Takes Aim At Trump's Article II Argument
Objective Deep Dive

Maurene Comey, a Manhattan federal prosecutor since 2015, was fired on July 16, 2025 by an email that cited only Article II of the Constitution, according to Al Jazeera and Conservative Daily News. She sued in September 2025, and Judge Jesse Furman later allowed the case to proceed in federal court, as CBS News noted. His October 26 ruling found the firing violated the separation of powers, civil service law, the Administrative Procedure Act and due process, and ordered retroactive reinstatement and back pay through December 20, 2025.

The left leaning framing is correct that Furman rejected the administration's Article II theory squarely, and ABC News reported he called it contrary to almost two centuries of Supreme Court decisions. That coverage sometimes implies the court found political retaliation, but Furman has not ruled on the First Amendment claim, and 100PercentFedUp noted he did not need to resolve motive to rule for Comey. Right leaning outlets are correct that the reasoning has not been tested on appeal, yet The Daily Caller's focus on Furman's appointment says little about the legal merits, and its own story reported the judge's reasoning without disputing it.

The next step is briefing on the First Amendment claim, which Conservative Daily News said the court has scheduled, and the Justice Department has said it will appeal once it can. Government Executive reported the ruling is the first of several Article II firing cases, including a suit by former pardon attorney Liz Oyer and an immigration judges' case due for December arguments. An appellate ruling on the Comey case would carry weight for other federal employees removed the same way.

◈ Tone Comparison

CBS News, Al Jazeera and the New York Daily News used "unlawfully" or "illegally" in headlines and highlighted the retaliation claim, while Democracy Now went further with "unconstitutional." The Daily Caller and 100PercentFedUp used the same "unlawfully" framing but attached "Obama judge" or "Obama-appointed" to Furman's name, steering attention to the court rather than the firing.