Fifth Circuit rules ICE detainees in Texas have no right to seek release on bond
The full Fifth Circuit ruled 10-7 that ICE detainees who entered without inspection have no constitutional right to bond hearings.
Objective Facts
The full 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 10-7 on October 23, 2026, that immigrants detained by ICE after entering the country without inspection have no constitutional right to a bond hearing, no matter how long they are held, according to Reuters and JURIST. Judge Cory Wilson wrote for the majority, while Judges Leslie Southwick and Dana Douglas dissented. The decision reverses a July panel ruling that had required bond hearings after 90 days and covers Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi, which Mississippi Today said together hold more than 40% of ICE detainees. The three plaintiffs, two Mexican citizens and one Honduran citizen, are represented by the National Immigration Project and the American Immigration Council, which are weighing next steps while the Supreme Court prepares to hear a related statutory challenge.
Left-Leaning Perspective
We found no New York Times, Washington Post, CNN or NPR article on the ruling that we could read. The coverage that framed the decision most sharply as a loss of rights came from Mississippi Today, whose headline said immigrants in ICE detention lack due process rights under the Constitution and whose reporters, Bobbi-Jeanne Misick and Mukta Joshi, described detainees being held indefinitely. Mississippi Today centered Rebecca Cassler of the American Immigration Council and a detainee's account of crowding at the Adams County Correctional Center. Law&Crime's Colin Kalmbacher had framed the July panel ruling, now reversed, as a major blow to ICE's indefinite detention policy.
Right-Leaning Perspective
The Daily Signal's Emily Medeiros framed the decision as a win for the Trump administration and stressed the rights Congress already provides, including a removal hearing, counsel and an appeal. Her piece leaned on Wilson's view that due process requires nothing beyond what Congress has enacted and quoted DHS general counsel James Percival's claim that the 1996 detention mandate had long been ignored by entrenched officials. VOZ, crediting Just the News, called the ruling 'a legal victory for the Trump administration' while noting that other legal challenges remain open. Earlier, the Washington Examiner's Jack Birle reported that the February panel win was only one round in a longer fight likely headed to the Supreme Court.
Deep Dive
The October 23 decision is the third major 5th Circuit ruling of 2026 on ICE's July 2025 policy of denying bond to anyone who entered without inspection. In February a 2-1 panel led by Judge Edith Jones upheld the policy as a reading of the statute, Fox News and the Washington Examiner reported. In July a separate panel, in an opinion by Judge Leslie Southwick, held that the Constitution still required a bond hearing after 90 days, Law&Crime reported. The full court then reheard the case and, by 10-7, ruled that the Fifth Amendment provides no such right, according to Reuters. Supporters of the ruling are correct that the majority rests on a statute Congress passed and on precedent treating people who were never admitted as applicants for admission, a point The Daily Signal and PJ Media emphasized. Their coverage spends little time on the practical effect, which Mississippi Today put at more than 20,000 people held in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi, or on the fact that the plaintiffs had each lived in the U.S. for at least 14 years. Critics quoted by Reuters and The Texas Tribune stress the open-ended length of detention, but they give less attention to the majority's point that Congress already provides removal hearings and appeals. The 5th Circuit also now stands apart from nine other circuits, JURIST reported, and the administration has been moving detainees from other states into Texas, which widens the ruling's reach in practice. The Supreme Court is set to hear a related challenge, which The Daily Signal identified as Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha, but Reuters reported that the justices will consider only whether the statute requires detention, not the constitutional question the 5th Circuit answered. The National Immigration Project told The Texas Tribune it is weighing whether to seek Supreme Court review of this case. Watch how district judges in the three states handle pending habeas petitions, and whether the government transfers more detainees into the circuit.