France deploys 70,000 police for third weekend of protests
France kept 70,000 police on duty for a third weekend of protests; Halloween marches ended with 565 arrests.
Objective Facts
France deployed about 70,000 police and gendarmes on Saturday, October 31, for the third consecutive weekend of protests over living costs, schools and public services. The government counted roughly 320,000 marchers, including 70,000 in Paris, and the interior ministry reported 565 arrests, according to AFP. Clashes broke out in Paris, Lyon, Toulouse, Bordeaux and Marseille, and Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez called a Molotov cocktail attack on a Paris riot officer an attempted murder. Turnout fell from more than 500,000 on October 17 and about 410,000 on October 24, and arrests were lower than in previous weeks, OPB reported. Unions have called a national strike and marches for November 5, and students plan new school blockades. French coverage centers on the domestic quarrel over police tactics and protest bans, while some foreign right-wing voices, including Donald Trump, have tied the unrest to immigration, a link Emmanuel Macron rejected.
Left-Leaning Perspective
OPB's October 31 report put protesters' grievances first, quoting 21 year old student Corentin Cabreux on rats and damp walls in his state residence, and said police tear gas, grenades and water cannon had caused severe injuries. The French weekly Politis described the October 17 marches as a convergence of anger against Macron's spending cuts and highlighted a 17 year old in Mulhouse who lost sight in one eye after a tear gas grenade. Both outlets treat the policing itself as part of the story.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Ron MacCammon wrote in the Washington Examiner that France faces a loose alignment of unions, black bloc militants, looters and suburban youths whose aims conflict but whose actions feed each other. Fox News interviewed New York Post reporter Gabrielle Fahmy, who said a peaceful march of more than 100,000 turned violent after masked people arrived by metro at nightfall. The Wall Street Journal's Nick Kostov called the protests a fresh test for a government attacked from left and right, and reported officials admitted underestimating the October 17 unrest.
Deep Dive
The protests began in late September as high school blockades over crumbling buildings, missing teachers and university admissions, then drew in unions, Yellow Vest veterans, farmers and climate activists angry about living costs. On October 17, more than 500,000 people marched and the fringes rioted: shops were looted in Paris, Marseille, Lyon and Bordeaux, Limoges city hall burned, and nearly 1,000 officers were hurt, according to AP and AFP. Nuñez offered to resign and Macron refused, ordering new tactics. The government raised its deployment to 70,000 for October 24 and held it there for Halloween, when turnout dropped to about 320,000 and arrests to 565. The government's account, that ultra-left cells and looters hijacked peaceful marches, fits the evidence of masked groups arriving after dark that both Fox News and AFP described. It says little about the grievances that keep hundreds of thousands in the streets, or about serious injuries from police weapons, which Politis reported and Human Rights Watch raised alarm about. Claims tying the unrest to immigration, voiced by Trump and Zemmour, have not been supported by French authorities, according to the AP. Left-wing critics, for their part, give less attention to the burned officers and looted shops that most French voters saw on television. The next test is the union strike and marches on November 5, followed by student blockades. Police unions warn the 70,000 deployment cannot last, and courts have already struck down a minors' curfew and a protest ban. With the presidential election less than six months away and Marine Le Pen leading polls, according to AFP, every party is reading the unrest through 2027, while bond markets watch whether a government without a majority can spend its way to calm.
Regional Perspective
In France, Sud Radio reported that France Unbowed deputies Manuel Bompard and Thomas Portes accused police of protecting far-right militants who attacked left-wing marches in Nice, Nancy and about ten other cities on October 24; Nuñez denied it and ordered prosecutions. AFP, carried by Le Petit Journal, reported that Nuñez offered to resign after admitting a loss of control on October 17, that Macron refused, and that Justice Minister Gérald Darmanin said authorities had clearly failed. Qatar's Al Jazeera reported the Halloween deployment alongside warnings from Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch. These outlets diverge from much U.S. right-leaning coverage on the question of who is rioting. French reporting centers on the ultra-left, the ultra-right and the police, and the AP reported Macron dismissing foreign claims about migrant hordes as false. Greek outlet Proto Thema, by contrast, described protesters as immigrants and leftists without citing evidence. The stakes in France are political and fiscal. Le Pen leads polls ahead of the 2027 election, Bardella says the state has deserted its post, and bond yields have climbed as the government, which lacks a majority, weighs how much it can offer protesters.