Google, Meta and TikTok sue to block California law restricting addictive feeds for minors
Google, Meta and TikTok filed federal suits to stop California's under-16 feed and autoplay law before January.
Objective Facts
Google, Meta and TikTok each sued California Attorney General Rob Bonta in federal court this week to stop AB 1709, a law that bars personalized feeds and video autoplay for users under 16 starting Jan. 1, 2027. The New York Post and MediaNama reported the suits were filed Wednesday, Nov. 4, with Meta and Google in the Northern District of California and TikTok in the Central District in Los Angeles. All three argue the law violates the First Amendment by overriding how platforms select and arrange content, and that Section 230 preempts it. The law, signed by Gov. Gavin Newsom on Sept. 10, requires age verification, calls for deleting under-16 accounts that keep the restricted features, and carries penalties of up to $50,000 per affected minor. Bonta's office said it is reviewing the complaints and is committed to defending the state's child safety laws.
Left-Leaning Perspective
Politico's Tyler Katzenberger and Aaron Mak framed the suits as a test of Gavin Newsom's signature youth online safety push as he weighs a 2028 presidential run, and gave bill author Josh Lowenthal the last word: he called the suits "straight out of the big tech playbook." The San Francisco Chronicle's Kathryn Palmer cast the filings as a challenge to one of Newsom's most sweeping regulations, noting that early drafts would have banned under-16 social media use outright before lawmakers pared the bill back. KQED's Rachael Myrow gave space to both sides, pairing Lowenthal's rebuttal with Santa Clara University law professor Eric Goldman's objection that forced account deletion strips teens of the ability to publish their own content.
Right-Leaning Perspective
The New York Post's Zain Khan gave the most detailed account of the complaints, emphasizing that AB 1709 drops the parental consent option that the 2024 law SB 976 allowed and that local prosecutors as well as the attorney general can seek penalties. The Post quoted TikTok's complaint describing teen users' options as "a choice between the rock and the whirlpool" and gave prominent space to the companies' argument that the state is overriding parents. Searches of The Wall Street Journal, Fox News, National Review and Reason found no separate commentary on these suits.
Deep Dive
AB 1709 is California's second attempt to rein in feed design for minors. Its predecessor, SB 976 from 2024, barred personalized feeds for users under 18 without parental consent, and all three companies are already challenging that law at the Ninth Circuit, the New York Post reported. The new law goes further by covering users under 16 with no parental opt-in, adding autoplay to the restricted list, requiring age verification and threatening account deletion and penalties of up to $50,000 per affected minor. It passed the Legislature without a recorded no vote, KQED reported, and early drafts that would have banned under-16 accounts outright were narrowed before passage, according to the San Francisco Chronicle. The state's backers have a factual point that legal and political pressure on these companies is rising: AP and KQED noted Meta's August agreement to pay up to $18 billion to settle claims from nearly all U.S. states over teen harms. But the record so far also gives the companies a basis for their constitutional claim. Google's complaint, as reported by Breitbart, says the state could not identify a peer-reviewed study showing personalization causes harm to minors, and Meta argues the law's carve-outs for streaming services and review sites undercut California's stated purpose. The privacy objection from EFF and Eric Goldman cuts across the usual lines, since verifying who is under 16 means checking everyone, and neither the companies nor the state has said publicly how that would work at scale. The immediate question is whether federal judges in San Francisco, San Jose and Los Angeles grant preliminary injunctions before the Jan. 1, 2027 start date. Their rulings will likely draw on the Ninth Circuit's handling of SB 976, where, according to Bloomberg Law's 2025 coverage, the court let the feed restrictions take effect after finding NetChoice had not shown algorithmic feeds are protected expression. Three parallel cases in three courts also raise the chance of conflicting rulings that would push the dispute back to the Ninth Circuit, with Newsom's political standing and Bonta's defense of the state's broader online safety agenda on the line.