Hollywood unions warn US film and TV production is on the brink

A union-backed EY study says the US share of studio film and TV spending has collapsed, boosting a federal tax credit bill.

Objective Facts

On October 5, 2026, a coalition of Hollywood unions released a study by EY showing that the US share of major studio film production spending fell from 74% to 42% between 1999 and 2024, and the television share fell from 94% to 64%, TheWrap reported. The share of cast and crew working on US-shot studio films dropped from 72% to 43%, and EURweb noted that the report measures where productions filmed, not why they left. The unions are pressing Congress to pass the Motion Picture, Television, and Entertainment Revitalization Act, introduced September 24 by Sens. Tim Scott and Adam Schiff with Reps. Nathaniel Moran, Linda Sánchez, Brian Jack and Laura Friedman. The bill would give productions over $1 million a 20% credit on US labor, up to 30% with bonuses, and The Washington Post reported on October 17 that it sits with the House Ways and Means Committee with Trump's backing. Coverage outside the US, from C21Media in the UK and CBC News in Canada, focused on which countries gained the work and whether a US credit would pull it back.

Left-Leaning Perspective

Mainstream left-leaning outlets framed the EY numbers as evidence of real hardship for workers and gave union and Democratic voices most of the space. The Los Angeles Times quoted DGA executive Rebecca Rhine saying the decline threatens careers nationwide, along with Schiff's call for urgent passage. Gene Maddaus at Variety covered a Glendale rally where Schiff said supporters were close to a deal. Elijah Wolfson, writing for The Washington Post on October 17, profiled set decorators and producers who described lost homes and health coverage, and he also included critics who say the benefits flow mostly to big companies.

Right-Leaning Perspective

Right-leaning coverage split between Republican sponsors who back the credit and editorial boards that oppose it. Fox News reporter Elizabeth Elkind gave Rep. Nathaniel Moran of Texas room to argue that American stories should not be made overseas and that conservative and faith-based productions in Texas also need the work. The Washington Examiner's David Zimmermann covered the bill's introduction as a bipartisan response to foreign incentives. The National Review editors called the plan a Hollywood bailout, and The Wall Street Journal editorial board, as summarized by Jon Fleischman, said California should cut its own costs instead.

Deep Dive

The EY study, released October 5 by six unions including SAG-AFTRA, the DGA and IATSE, is the newest piece of a lobbying campaign for the Motion Picture, Television, and Entertainment Revitalization Act. Its central figures are large: the US share of qualifying studio film spending fell from 74% to 42% from 1999 to 2024, and the TV share fell from 94% to 64%, while total qualifying spending grew. The bill, introduced September 24, would give a 20% credit on US labor that can rise to 30%, stack on state credits and carry no cap, according to Schiff's office and The Washington Post. Trump endorsed a federal incentive on September 1 after earlier floating a 100% tariff on foreign films. Supporters are right that the share of work done in the US has fallen sharply and that rival countries, especially the UK, offer generous incentives. They say less about cost: no official score appears in the coverage reviewed here, and The Washington Post cited a 2023 New York review that found film incentives created fewer jobs than other uses of the money. Critics at the WSJ and National Review make a fair point that California's doubled credit has not reversed job losses, but they spend little time on how a single state competes with national programs abroad. The EY report itself does not establish causes, as EURweb and C21Media both noted. The next test is the lame-duck session after the November midterms. Friedman told Variety she wants the bill on Trump's desk by mid-December, likely inside a larger tax package, and Fox News reported that Moran expects some version to survive. Open questions include whether House Ways and Means will move the bill, what the Joint Committee on Taxation says it would cost, and whether fiscal conservatives in the Republican conference accept a credit for an industry many of them see as hostile.

Regional Perspective

In the UK, C21Media's Jordan Pinto reported the EY findings in detail and noted that the UK's share of US studio film spending rose 14 percentage points over the period, with Australia up three points. Canada was excluded from that film comparison because its share fell. In Canada, CBC News, as summarized by Newsy Today, examined how a US credit might affect Canadian production and cited data showing the UK passed Canadian provinces as a filming location for streaming and theatrical movies in 2024. The framing differs from US coverage. American outlets centered on lost US jobs and the bill's odds in Congress. C21Media called the alliance between unions and studios on the credit unsurprising and pointed to Netflix's growing local-language commissions as another reason work leaves the US. Canadian sources were more defensive: Reynolds Mastin of the Canadian Media Producers Association said Canada should increase funding for homegrown projects, and Wilfrid Laurier University's Jade Miller said Canada's early incentive edge has long since been copied around the world. The stakes are concrete for both countries. According to the CBC figures cited by Newsy Today, Canada's sector supports about 180,000 full-time jobs, and foreign production volume there rose 9.5% to $5.3 billion in 2024/25. A stackable, uncapped US credit would compete directly with the UK and Canadian programs that drew the work.

OBJ SPEAKING

Create StoryTimelinesVoter ToolsRegional AnalysisPolicy GuideAll StoriesCommunity PicksUSWorldPoliticsBusinessHealthEntertainmentTechnologyAbout

Hollywood unions warn US film and TV production is on the brink

A union-backed EY study says the US share of studio film and TV spending has collapsed, boosting a federal tax credit bill.

Oct 17, 2026· Updated Oct 20, 2026
What's Going On
  • Six Hollywood unions, including SAG-AFTRA, the DGA, the WGA, IATSE and the Teamsters, released an EY study on October 5, 2026 covering major studio production from 1999 to 2024.
  • The study found the US share of qualifying studio film spending fell from 74% to 42%, and the TV share fell from 94% to 64%, according to TheWrap and EURweb.
  • Unions are using the data to push the Motion Picture, Television, and Entertainment Revitalization Act, a bipartisan bill offering a 20% federal credit on US labor costs that can rise to 30%.
  • Donald Trump has endorsed a federal incentive, and supporters such as Rep. Laura Friedman want the bill passed in the lame-duck session by mid-December, Variety reported.
  • UK trade outlet C21Media reported the UK gained 14 percentage points of film share over the period, while Canadian voices quoted by CBC News played down the US focus on Canada.
Far Left: Jacobin's Alex McCarron said unions treat runaway production as a jobs problem while ignoring the quality of the work.
Left: The Los Angeles Times led with the 25-year slide and union worries about family income and health insurance.
Moderate: TheWrap reported US share of cast and crew on studio TV episodes fell from 86% to 58%.
Right: Moran told Fox News he expects some version of the credit to land in a year-end tax package.
Far Right: Breitbart presented Schiff's support as Democrats joining a Trump push.
Region: British trade press treated the union report as a sign the UK has won much of the work, while Canadian voices quoted by CBC News argued Canada's advantages will survive a US credit.
✓ Common Ground
Republican sponsors such as Nathaniel Moran and Tim Scott and Democrats such as Adam Schiff and Laura Friedman share the view that losing production to other countries hurts US workers, and they co-wrote one bill to address it.
Some voices on the far left and the free-market right, including WSWS's Marc Wells and The Wall Street Journal editorial board, are both skeptical that state film subsidies have saved jobs.
Union leaders and Trump-aligned outlets such as Breitbart and The Patriot Journal largely agree that Trump's endorsement gave the federal credit momentum.
Several reporters across outlets, including EURweb's Ny MaGee and C21Media's Jordan Pinto, note that the EY study documents the shift but does not prove why it happened.
◆ All Sources (16)
TheWrap - Hollywood Spends More Than Half of Its Film Budgets Outside the US, Union Study ShowsEURweb - Hollywood's U.S. Production Share Plunges as Billions in Spending Move AbroadOffice of Sen. Adam Schiff - Sens. Scott, Schiff, Reps. Moran, Sanchez, Jack, Friedman Introduce Bipartisan Bill to Establish a Federal Film Tax CreditThe Washington Post via Yahoo Finance - This could be the break Hollywood has been waiting forLos Angeles Times (via Rep. Laura Friedman's site) - U.S. share of studio TV spending fell from 94% to 65%, unions sayVariety (via Rep. Laura Friedman's site) - Unions and Democrats Stump for Federal Film Incentives: 'We Are So Close to Getting This Done'Jacobin - Film Workers Should Fight for Good Movies, Not Just JobsFox News - Bipartisan film tax credit bill aims to stop TV production from going overseasNational Review - Federal Film Tax Credit Would Push Industry's Labor Costs on All AmericansWashington Examiner - Congress introduces bipartisan legislation creating national film tax creditBreitbart - Senator Adam Schiff Backs Trump's Push to 'Save' Hollywood With Federal Tax SubsidiesC21Media - US unions sound alarm on production exodus amid federal tax credit pushNewsy Today (citing CBC News) - US Film Tax Credit: Impact on Canada's Film IndustryWorld Socialist Web Site - Why the Hollywood unions actually didn't put up a fight this yearSo Does It Matter (Jon Fleischman) - The Wall Street Journal Takes On Hollywood WelfareThe Patriot Journal - Hollywood Unions and Democrats Rally Behind Trump's Federal Film Tax Incentive Proposal
Objective Deep Dive

The EY study, released October 5 by six unions including SAG-AFTRA, the DGA and IATSE, is the newest piece of a lobbying campaign for the Motion Picture, Television, and Entertainment Revitalization Act. Its central figures are large: the US share of qualifying studio film spending fell from 74% to 42% from 1999 to 2024, and the TV share fell from 94% to 64%, while total qualifying spending grew. The bill, introduced September 24, would give a 20% credit on US labor that can rise to 30%, stack on state credits and carry no cap, according to Schiff's office and The Washington Post. Trump endorsed a federal incentive on September 1 after earlier floating a 100% tariff on foreign films.

Supporters are right that the share of work done in the US has fallen sharply and that rival countries, especially the UK, offer generous incentives. They say less about cost: no official score appears in the coverage reviewed here, and The Washington Post cited a 2023 New York review that found film incentives created fewer jobs than other uses of the money. Critics at the WSJ and National Review make a fair point that California's doubled credit has not reversed job losses, but they spend little time on how a single state competes with national programs abroad. The EY report itself does not establish causes, as EURweb and C21Media both noted.

The next test is the lame-duck session after the November midterms. Friedman told Variety she wants the bill on Trump's desk by mid-December, likely inside a larger tax package, and Fox News reported that Moran expects some version to survive. Open questions include whether House Ways and Means will move the bill, what the Joint Committee on Taxation says it would cost, and whether fiscal conservatives in the Republican conference accept a credit for an industry many of them see as hostile.

◈ Tone Comparison

Supporters on the left and among Republican sponsors use loss language: Crabtree-Ireland's "eating not only our lunch" in Variety and Moran's warning about storytelling going overseas on Fox News. Opponents on the right use money language, with National Review calling it a "bailout" and the WSJ editorial board calling it a handout. Far-right outlets such as The Patriot Journal frame the story around Trump's leadership rather than the workers.