ICE officer shoots man in Marble Hill, sparking New York protests and clash between Mamdani and DHS
An ICE officer shot Oscar Belgal during a Marble Hill arrest, setting off protests and a fight between New York leaders and DHS.
Objective Facts
An Immigration and Customs Enforcement officer shot Oscar Belgal, a 28-year-old Dominican man, on October 8 during an attempted arrest in Marble Hill, a Manhattan neighborhood attached to the Bronx. Police said at least one plainclothes officer fired seven rounds into Belgal's car, where his 5-year-old son was sitting; Belgal was wounded below the ear, and federal agents later removed him from the hospital. At a Washington press conference on October 9, ICE's Marcos Charles said Belgal accelerated toward officers, and DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin called him a thug and blamed sanctuary policies. Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Gov. Kathy Hochul said they pressed Donald Trump and Mullin for his release without success, and protests continued in Marble Hill and lower Manhattan through the weekend.
Left-Leaning Perspective
The New York Times led with the political response, quoting Mamdani calling it an "unconscionable and incredibly serious situation" and Hochul demanding immediate answers about shots fired into a car with a child inside. The Times noted that this appeared to be the first ICE shooting in the city since 2020 and that at least two dozen people had been shot at by immigration agents since January 2025. amNewYork's Rebecca Raghunath followed protesters back to 225th Street on October 9 and reported that more than 1,000 marched on Foley Square the next day.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Just the News reporter Misty Severi built her story around DHS's account: that Belgal refused orders, accelerated into two government vehicles and moved toward officers before they fired. She reported DHS's claims of Trinitarios gang ties and a drug-sale conviction. The National News Desk's Natalia Mittelstadt, in a story carried by Fox45 Baltimore, gave equal weight to Mamdani's call to abolish ICE and Mullin's reply that ICE agents enforce the laws Mamdani refuses to enforce.
Deep Dive
The Marble Hill shooting appears to be the first ICE shooting in New York City since 2020, according to the Times, and it lands in a city whose mayor has made opposition to ICE a signature issue. AP reported that ICE agents have fired during more than a dozen vehicle stops since last year and that the agency told officers in late September to limit vehicle stops to those with specific training. That backdrop explains why the case moved within hours from a street arrest to phone calls between Mamdani, Hochul, Trump and Mullin. Critics are on firm ground in noting that police video shows a plainclothes officer with a drawn gun approaching a parked car, that seven rounds were fired, and that a child was inside. They have less to say about DHS's claim that Belgal drove into government vehicles, which the released video does not settle either way. Supporters of the officers lean on Belgal's record, but the details differ by outlet: AP describes his drug-sale charge as unresolved, while Just the News reports DHS saying he was convicted, and the gang and CBP shooting claims come from DHS without public evidence so far. The body camera footage Mullin confirmed exists is the most important open item, and neither DHS nor ICE has given a release date. The FBI and Homeland Security Investigations are investigating, according to Documented. Belgal remains in ICE custody outside the city, amNewYork reported, with Make the Road New York seeking to block his deportation.