Immigration judge rules Milwaukee mosque leader Salah Sarsour can be deported
An immigration judge ruled the U.S. can deport Islamic Society of Milwaukee president Salah Sarsour on foreign policy grounds.
Objective Facts
Immigration Judge Jayme Salinardi of the Chicago Immigration Court ruled that the U.S. government can deport Salah Sarsour, who has led Wisconsin's largest mosque for five years and has lived in the U.S. since 1993. The judge accepted the government's argument under a Cold War era law that Sarsour's presence poses a foreign policy and security threat, relying partly on a memo from Secretary of State Marco Rubio, but rejected the claim that he lied on his green card application. ICE detained Sarsour in Milwaukee in March, and a federal judge ordered him released in June after finding he had raised a substantial free speech retaliation claim; the administration has appealed that order. Sarsour's lawyers plan to appeal and to argue he would face torture if returned, and the case will move to Judge Craig Defoe because Salinardi is retiring. Arab regional outlets cast the ruling as retaliation for Palestinian advocacy, while Reuters copy in The Jerusalem Post emphasized the security grounds.
Left-Leaning Perspective
Mainstream left coverage we could read relied mostly on wire copy. Spectrum News Milwaukee reporter Phillip Boudreaux, working with the AP, led with the free speech dispute and the Jordan destination question, and gave space to attorney Patrick Taurel's warning that Sarsour's past treatment in Israeli custody shows what he may face. Al Jazeera's Tamara Khandaker, writing with the AP, quoted Taurel calling Rubio's memo decisive in the case and noted the State Department and DHS did not respond to requests for comment.
Right-Leaning Perspective
We found no coverage of this ruling from The Wall Street Journal, Fox News, National Review or the New York Post dated September 30 to October 4, 2026. The administration's position reached readers mainly through DHS's statement welcoming the ruling, reported by Reuters, and through the government's argument that Sarsour's Israeli convictions make him a national security threat.
Deep Dive
Sarsour, born in the West Bank, came to the U.S. in 1993 and became president of the Islamic Society of Milwaukee about five years ago. ICE arrested him in March, and U.S. District Judge James Patrick Hanlon freed him in June after 81 days, finding a substantial free speech claim. The government's removal case relied on a memo from Marco Rubio invoking the same foreign policy provision used against Mahmoud Khalil and Mohsen Mahdawi, plus convictions in Israeli military courts. The government won on the provision that gives the Secretary of State broad say, and lost on the fact-based fraud claims. That split supports both readings: DHS can say the judge upheld removal, and Sarsour's lawyers can say the only surviving ground is one the judge had little room to test. Al Jazeera reported the lawyers believe an earlier ruling in Khalil's case limited how far the judge could examine the evidence. The Daily Wire repeated allegations of Hamas fundraising without naming a source, and the supportive coverage we read said little about what the Rubio memo actually alleges. Next come a notice of appeal to the Board of Immigration Appeals and a torture claim under the Convention Against Torture, which Taurel called a high bar he believes Sarsour can meet. A new judge, Craig Defoe, takes the case. Separately, the administration's appeal of Hanlon's release order remains pending, and the question of whether Jordan can accept him is unresolved.
Regional Perspective
Al Jazeera, writing with the AP, focused on the free speech argument and on the lawyers' complaint that the judge deferred heavily to Rubio's memo and to Israeli records. The New Arab, a London-based Arab outlet, placed the case alongside other Trump administration actions against pro-Palestinian protesters and quoted the Islamic Society of Milwaukee's view that Sarsour was targeted for his background. The Jerusalem Post published Reuters' report, headlined around the court upholding deportation grounds. The Arab outlets gave more weight to Sarsour's claim that he was tortured into confessing and to B'Tselem's data on West Bank military court conviction rates. The New Arab also described Israel's war in Gaza as genocide, a framing absent from the wire copy. The Jerusalem Post's version kept Reuters' balance but its headline put the security finding first, and its subheadline described the administration as cracking down on pro-Palestinian voices. For Palestinians, the case is about whether an Israeli military court record, from a system rights groups criticize, can drive a U.S. deportation. The listing of Jordan as a destination, a country Sarsour's lawyers say he has no tie to, adds a practical question that no Jordanian outlet we found addressed.