Iowa judge dismisses Trump lawsuit against pollster Ann Selzer and the Des Moines Register
An Iowa judge threw out Donald Trump's consumer fraud suit over the 2024 Iowa Poll, calling the poll protected speech.
Objective Facts
On Sept. 23, 2026, Polk County District Judge Scott Beattie granted motions to dismiss the lawsuit Donald Trump, Rep. Mariannette Miller-Meeks and former state Sen. Brad Zaun filed over the Des Moines Register's final 2024 Iowa Poll. The plaintiffs argued the poll, which showed Kamala Harris leading Trump 47% to 44% in a state Trump carried with 56%, violated Iowa's consumer fraud law and amounted to fraud and negligent misrepresentation. Beattie found the poll and its reporting were constitutionally protected political speech, wrote that "fraud is not the same as lying," and dismissed all three counts with prejudice. Selzer, represented by the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, and USA Today Co., which owns the Register, called the ruling a win for the press, while a spokesman for Trump's legal team told the Associated Press the president would take the case to the Iowa Supreme Court.
Left-Leaning Perspective
Laura Belin of Bleeding Heartland, a progressive Iowa politics site, called the ruling "a comprehensive defeat for Trump" and walked through each ground Beattie used. She stressed that the judge decided the case twice over: once on the First Amendment and again on Iowa law, finding the Consumer Fraud Act "does not forbid deception at large" and that a poll commissioned by a newspaper is not merchandise sold to a household. Belin said she doubts Trump will "have better luck" at the Iowa Supreme Court, and she pointed out that Iowa's anti-SLAPP law took effect a day after the amended suit was filed, so the defendants cannot recover their legal fees from Trump.
Right-Leaning Perspective
We searched Fox News, the New York Post, National Review, Reason and the Washington Examiner for coverage of the dismissal published Sept. 25 to 28 and found none we could read. The plaintiffs' position appears in the record through the AP: Trump, Rep. Mariannette Miller-Meeks and Brad Zaun alleged the poll was published to damage Trump and help Democrats, argued that poll coverage is not protected speech, and said it cost them time and money in the campaign's final days. A spokesman for Trump's legal team said the case will go to the Iowa Supreme Court.
Deep Dive
The Register published the final 2024 Iowa Poll days before the election, showing Kamala Harris ahead 47% to 44%. Trump won Iowa with 56%. He sued in December 2024, moved the case between state and federal court, and refiled in state court with Rep. Mariannette Miller-Meeks and former state Sen. Brad Zaun as co-plaintiffs. On Sept. 23, 2026, Judge Scott Beattie granted the defendants' motions in a long written ruling, dismissed all three counts with prejudice, denied a request to bar future polls and assessed costs to the plaintiffs. The ruling is broader than a First Amendment holding alone. Beattie found the poll was protected political speech outside the narrow fraud exception, and he separately found that the claims failed under Iowa's Consumer Fraud Act, common law fraud and negligent misrepresentation even on the assumption that the poll was skewed. Coverage sympathetic to Selzer, such as Bleeding Heartland, captures that double basis well. What it spends less time on is that the ruling itself says no Iowa decision had squarely answered whether newspaper content can be consumer merchandise or whether a pollster owes a duty to the candidates it measures. That gap is the opening Trump's lawyers will press on appeal. The plaintiffs' framing, in turn, rests on intent, but the judge's point was that even proven bad intent does not turn a published poll into a sales transaction. The next step is an appeal to the Iowa Supreme Court, which Trump's legal team announced. Because Iowa's anti-SLAPP law took effect a day after the amended suit was filed, Selzer and the Register cannot use it to recover legal fees, according to Bleeding Heartland. Watch whether the high court takes up the open state law questions directly, and whether the ruling affects how pollsters and newspapers handle election surveys heading into the 2026 midterms.