Iran and Oman near a deal to reopen the Strait of Hormuz with split shipping channels as Trump threatens Iran
Iran and Oman neared a split-channel deal to reopen Hormuz while Trump called talks Iran's last chance.
Objective Facts
Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi said on August 2 that talks with Oman on a new route through the Strait of Hormuz were in their final stages, and The New York Times reported on August 3 that the plan would route inbound ships through an Iranian-controlled channel and outbound ships through an Omani one, with a service fee shared by both countries. The same day, Donald Trump said ongoing talks were Iran's last chance to avoid heavier US strikes, called Iran's leaders duplicitous, and said the US blockade of Iranian ports would stay until a deal or what he called total surrender. Iranian officials said their talks were with Oman, not the US, and that reopening depended on Washington lifting the blockade. On August 4, the Associated Press quoted two regional officials confirming progress, while Secretary of State Marco Rubio said there was progress but no finality and Trump said he would not let Iran charge ships. Regional outlets including The New Arab and The National framed the plan as a possible formalization of Iranian control over the waterway, a point US coverage treated mostly as a question of Trump's leverage.
Left-Leaning Perspective
The New York Times broke the outline of the split-channel plan on August 3, citing Iranian and American officials, and framed it as a deal that could lock in Iran's wartime grip on the waterway. The Times quoted Ali Vaez of the International Crisis Group describing Trump's choices in bleak terms and reported skepticism among some Pentagon officials who see the plan as a concession. Political Wire, summarizing the Times report that night, argued that reopening the strait on these terms would look more like recognition of an Iranian win than a compromise.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Washington Examiner reporter Christian Datoc framed the August 3 developments as a presidential ultimatum, reporting that Trump called off planned strikes on Iran's energy sites after Tehran and mediators asked to resume talks. Fox News reporter Morgan Phillips was more skeptical, asking in her August 4 headline whether this was Trump's latest last chance and quoting Jonathan Schanzer of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, who said Iran was denying Trump the win he wants. Jamie McIntyre of the Washington Examiner wrote on August 5 that Trump appeared ready to claim the Iran and Oman arrangement as his own.
Deep Dive
Iran has effectively controlled the Strait of Hormuz since the war began in late February, and a June interim arrangement to reopen it collapsed in July over shipping routes. The new Iran and Oman track, which Iranian officials say has run for about two months, would send inbound ships through Iranian waters and outbound ships near Oman. Iran's Foreign Ministry insisted the Oman talks were separate from reopening the strait, which it tied to the US lifting its naval blockade. Trump, meanwhile, paired a pause in major strikes with an ultimatum on August 3 and said the blockade would stay. Coverage that framed the plan as an Iranian win, led by The New York Times and repeated by Political Wire and Democracy Now, rests largely on Iranian officials' account, which a US official called inaccurate and which Muscat had not confirmed. Coverage centered on Trump's threats, from the Washington Examiner and Fox News, captures the leverage the blockade gives Washington but says less about the fee and inspection details that determine who actually controls traffic. Reuters' reporting that Iran's outbound role and fee levels remained open suggests both framings run ahead of the facts. The points to watch are whether Oman publicly confirms the route, whether any fee is voluntary or mandatory, and whether the US eases the blockade that Iran calls a precondition. Saudi Aramco chief executive Amin Nasser said traffic was at about a tenth of prewar levels, and Kpler data cited by Iran International showed six vessels crossing on August 3, so any reopening would start from a very low base. The June memorandum's deadline was about two weeks away, according to the Associated Press.
Regional Perspective
Al Jazeera reported on August 3 that Abbas Araghchi told Iran's cabinet the Oman talks were close to finished, and that spokesman Esmail Baghaei described a route that would be neither the northern nor the southern corridor while respecting both countries' sovereign rights. bne IntelliNews, citing Fars and Iranian state television, reported Baghaei's view that the Oman understanding was necessary but not enough to reopen the strait. Al Jazeera's report on Trump's threat added Baghaei's statement that Iran was talking with Oman and regional states, not directly with the US. Muscat did not comment, according to Al Jazeera and the Oman Observer's republication of the Times report. Gulf-based and Gulf-focused outlets were more wary than Iranian ones. Matthew Hoare of The New Arab noted that no Omani official had confirmed the Iranian account and quoted Andreas Krieg of King's College London saying Gulf states would reject a deal made only by the two coastal states. David Vujanovic of The National argued on August 5 that Washington could end up accepting a framework that gives Iran real influence over access. Iran International, a London-based Persian-language outlet critical of Tehran, emphasized Iran's widening list of conditions, including fees, sanctions relief and security guarantees. For Oman, the arrangement would place a neutral mediator in a shared role over one of the world's main energy chokepoints, with fee revenue attached. For Iran, a channel along its own coast would turn wartime leverage into a standing role. For Gulf exporters such as Saudi Arabia, the near shutdown of traffic described by Aramco's Amin Nasser makes any reopening urgent, even as their commentators object to the terms.