Ireland's data regulator fines Google 403 million euros over location data
Ireland's Data Protection Commission fined Google 403 million euros for mishandling users' location data from 2018 to 2020.
Objective Facts
Ireland's Data Protection Commission on September 21, 2026, fined Google 403 million euros (about $463 million) for breaking EU privacy law in how it handled users' location data between May 2018 and February 2020, AP and Reuters reported. The commission found infringements tied to three features, Web & App Activity, Location History and Android's Location Accuracy, covering lawfulness, fairness, transparency, accountability and data retention, and ordered Google to comply within six months. Google said the case concerns historical policies and that it has significantly changed its practices since 2019. The fine is the fourth largest the DPC has issued under the GDPR, behind penalties against Meta and TikTok, and the regulator said three other Google inquiries are at an advanced stage. Irish outlets and European consumer groups focused on how long the case took, with BEUC calling the delay disproportionate.
Deep Dive
The case began with a November 2018 report from the Norwegian Consumer Council and coordinated complaints from consumer groups in Norway, the Netherlands, Greece, the Czech Republic, Slovenia, Poland, Sweden and Denmark, PPC Land and Lovguiden reported. In January 2019 Google Ireland Limited became the data controller for European users, which sent the cross-border complaints to Dublin, and the DPC opened its own inquiry on February 4, 2020. The decision was made by Commissioners Des Hogan, Dale Sunderland and Niamh Sweeney, the Irish Examiner reported. Deputy Commissioner Graham Doyle said users could have been unaware their location was being used to target ads or infer interests, and that keeping the data too long aggravated their loss of control. The regulator's case and Google's defense address different time periods. The DPC ruled on conduct from 2018 to early 2020, while Google, according to The Irish Times and the Irish Examiner, pointed to changes since then: auto-delete options of three to 36 months, Timeline data stored on the device, simpler ad controls and no precise location saved when a user searches. Those changes may answer part of the six-month compliance order but do not touch the finding about past conduct. BEUC, quoted by AFP, said Google made some global changes after the original complaint, yet consumer groups filed a second complaint in 2022 over deceptive design, PPC Land reported. Coverage gave limited detail on how the fine amount was calculated, and the full decision had not been published, Lovguiden noted. The next questions are whether Google appeals, which The Irish Times said it may do for parts of the decision, and how it meets the six-month deadline. IBTimes UK reported that under Irish procedure a court must confirm a fine before it can be collected. The DPC also has three more Google inquiries at an advanced stage, including one opened in September 2024 on whether Google assessed the risks of using Europeans' personal data to train AI models, AFP reported.
Regional Perspective
In Ireland, The Irish Times' Ian Curran and Ciara O'Brien reported that the DPC found Google processed location data "unlawfully and unfairly" through three features, and that Google may appeal parts of the decision. The Irish Examiner's Martin Claffey listed each infringement, from transparency failures across all three features to excessive retention in Web & App Activity and Location History, and named Commissioners Des Hogan, Dale Sunderland and Niamh Sweeney as the decision makers. In Denmark, the legal site Lovguiden reported the decision on September 23, noting that one of the eight 2018 complainants was Danish and that the research came from BEUC's Norwegian member. US wire coverage from AP framed the story around the dollar figure and Google's statement, while the Irish papers placed it within the DPC's record as Google's lead EU regulator, with The Irish Times noting three other large Google inquiries at an advanced stage. The Irish Times also carried BEUC director general Agustín Reyna's criticism of the slow process, which puts the Irish regulator itself under scrutiny alongside Google. The case matters in Ireland because Google's European headquarters in Dublin makes the DPC its main EU privacy enforcer, and the pace of Irish enforcement has drawn criticism from consumer groups elsewhere in Europe. For the complainant countries, including Denmark and Norway, the decision closes a case their consumer bodies started in 2018.