Israeli military ends 11-day operation in Hebron that displaced thousands
Israel pulled troops out of Hebron after an 11-day raid that displaced over 3,000 Palestinians following a deadly attack.
Objective Facts
The Israeli military withdrew from the Jaladah and Ein Deir Baha areas of Hebron on November 2, ending a raid that The Times of Israel counted at 11 days and Reuters at 10. Netanyahu ordered the operation after two gunmen from the city killed two soldiers and wounded three at a checkpoint on October 23; both attackers were shot dead. The army said it searched hundreds of buildings, detained dozens of suspects, seized four firearms and razed the attackers' homes, while Hebron officials said about 3,200 people were displaced and other homes, shops and roads were demolished. Hebron Mayor Yousef al-Jabari said schools and universities reopened Monday, though checkpoints at the city's entrances stayed in place. Regional outlets such as Al Jazeera emphasized the displacement and economic losses, while Israeli outlets focused on the attack and an internal dispute between the army and the government over how long to stay.
Left-Leaning Perspective
The New York Times, in a report carried by The Boston Globe, led with evictions and demolitions in Hebron's Deir Baha and Farsh al-Hawa areas and noted analysts tying the timing to the election. NPR's Ruth Sherlock and Nuha Musleh quoted Danny Citrinowicz of Israel's Institute for National Security Studies, who called Netanyahu's response collective punishment and said hope, not punishment, prevents attacks. Both outlets reported the soldiers' deaths and Netanyahu's vows to act forcefully.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Searches of Fox News, The Wall Street Journal and National Review turned up no coverage of this specific operation, so this band relies on right-leaning Israeli and Jewish outlets. JNS called the October 23 shooting a terrorist attack, said Hamas claimed it, and described the response as a limited counterterrorism operation. Jfeed relayed Katz's position that evacuated residents would stay out until the army finished dealing with Hamas in Hebron. The Jerusalem Post's Amir Bohbot reported security officials arguing the presence was justified by an uncovered local Hamas network.
Deep Dive
The operation began hours after two Hebron men killed two Israeli soldiers at a temporary checkpoint on October 23, four days before a national election that polls showed as close between Benjamin Netanyahu and Gadi Eisenkot. Netanyahu vowed, as quoted by NPR, to change the area completely, and Katz said it would follow the model of the 2025 Jenin and Tulkarem camp raids. In practice, The Times of Israel's Emanuel Fabian reported, the raid was far narrower than those promises: troops cleared two neighborhoods, searched hundreds of buildings, found four firearms and an underground excavation, and left on November 2 after Katz signed off the night before. The Israeli government's case rests on the deadliness of the attack and on a Hamas network that The Jerusalem Post said investigators uncovered, which supporters say justified extended searches. That account says less about the cost: Hebron Municipality figures cited by Arab News show more than 3,000 people displaced, about 80,000 students kept from school and daily losses near $3.8 million. Critics, including Mayor al-Jabari and the UN's Volker Türk, frame the raid as collective punishment, but their accounts give little attention to the soldiers killed or to the intelligence claims about Hamas. The most telling detail comes from inside Israel's own security system: Ynetnews and The Times of Israel reported that the army chief saw no operational or legal reason to keep residents out, yet was overruled until after the vote. Several questions remain open. A petition filed with Israel's Supreme Court on October 29 by the municipality and residents, backed by Adalah, challenges the evacuations and demolitions and could test the legal basis for similar raids. Al Jazeera reported that the election ended in deadlock, so the next government's West Bank policy is unsettled. Checkpoints at Hebron's entrances stayed in place after the withdrawal, and the final tally of demolished civilian buildings has not been independently verified.
Regional Perspective
Arab News reporter Sherouk Zakaria led with displaced families going home to damaged houses and quoted Mayor Yousef al-Jaabari saying life had returned to normal. Al Jazeera's data unit, in a piece by Mohamed Alzanin, mapped 10 closed entrances and counted 4,969 people affected by October 30, including 336 infants. Al Jazeera's November 3 weekly roundup put the raid alongside the Israeli election result and settler attacks. In Israel, The Times of Israel called the raid controversial and said it was far smaller than Netanyahu's vows, and Ynetnews's Elisha Ben Kimon reported that Zamir wanted it ended. The two sets of outlets split on emphasis more than on core facts. Arab coverage relied on municipal figures, the UN and residents, and rarely named the two soldiers. Israeli coverage named the soldiers, quoted army statements about suspects and weapons, and treated the displacement mainly as a legal and strategic problem for the army. Al Jazeera disputed an army claim about an underground pit, quoting the owner who said it was a sewage cesspit, while The Times of Israel reported the excavation as found. For Palestinians, Hebron is the largest West Bank city and, per Al Jazeera, about 40 percent of Palestinian industrial output, so a 10 or 11 day closure hits the wider economy. For Israelis, the episode feeds a fight over who controls military decisions, with the army chief overruled by the government during an election week.