JD Vance declines to endorse Netanyahu despite Trump's backing
Vice President JD Vance refused to endorse Benjamin Netanyahu a day after Donald Trump fully backed him.
Objective Facts
Donald Trump endorsed Benjamin Netanyahu on Truth Social on October 18, calling him a "Great Warrior Prime Minister" and warning that if Israel picked someone else, America would have to handle Iran itself, according to the AP and The Jerusalem Post. The next day, JD Vance told Mark Halperin that Trump has the most effective endorsement in political history but that he himself endorses only American candidates and is focused on the midterms. He told Halperin he was neither endorsing nor opposing Netanyahu, Fox News Digital reported, and the White House did not respond to Fox's request for comment. Several outlets, including the Jewish Telegraphic Agency and The Times of Israel, pointed out that Vance campaigned for Hungary's Viktor Orban in April before Orban lost. Israeli outlets such as Walla and Ynet treated the remark as a calculated gap between Vance and Trump, and Al Jazeera tied it to wider Republican doubts about U.S. backing for Israel.
Left-Leaning Perspective
The Daily Beast's Farrah Tomazin presented the answer as Vance publicly opening a split with Trump while Trump's approval sinks. She tied the move to Vance's standing in the anti-interventionist wing of MAGA and cited a Reuters/Ipsos poll putting Trump's approval at 31 percent amid anger over gas prices and the Iran war. Tomazin wrote that Vance laughed before answering and dodged picking a side. The Jewish Telegraphic Agency's Sharon Udasin reported that J Street, a liberal Middle East policy group, criticized Trump's endorsement itself as working against U.S. taxpayers, so on the left the main target remained Trump's support for Netanyahu.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Fox News Digital's Sophia Compton reported the refusal as neutrality, not opposition, and set it beside Trump's full endorsement. On Fox & Friends the next morning, the hosts took a harder line. Brian Kilmeade said Vance went out of his way to separate himself from Trump and that the rap on Vance is that he seems a bit anti-Israel, while Lawrence Jones called the answer disappointing, according to The Western Journal's Randy DeSoto. The Daily Caller's John Loftus headlined the story "I'll Pass" and, like Kilmeade, pointed to Vance's campaigning for Viktor Orban as a contradiction of his stated rule.
Deep Dive
The remark came during a campaign stop for North Carolina Senate nominee Michael Whatley, a day after Trump broke months of silence to endorse Netanyahu and tied the endorsement to Iran policy. Vance's relationship with Netanyahu has been strained for months. In June he publicly criticized members of Israel's government for resisting Trump's efforts to end the Iran war, and in July he told Joe Rogan that factions in Israel were manipulating American opinion, according to the AP. Walla and The Jerusalem Post both called a July meeting between the two "particularly tense." The Fox & Friends critics have a point that Vance has made foreign endorsements before, and the Orban campaign is on the record. What they leave out is that Vance praised Trump's endorsement power in the same breath and said nothing against Netanyahu. The Daily Beast's split framing fits the 2028 context but goes further than Vance's words, which were hedged. The Jerusalem Post's read, a sidestep without a rebuke, sticks closest to what he actually said. The White House did not respond to Fox's request for comment, so no official explanation exists beyond Vance's own words. Israel votes October 27. JTA reported polls show Netanyahu trailing Gadi Eisenkot, and the AP said it is unclear whether Trump's backing helps Likud. If Netanyahu loses, Vance's distance could look prescient. If he wins, pro-Israel Republicans skeptical of Vance may cite the answer heading into 2028. Vance also told Halperin he expects Trump to endorse him if he runs, according to MEAWW.
Regional Perspective
Israeli coverage arrived overnight. Idan Kweller, writing for both Walla and The Jerusalem Post, framed the answer as a deliberate sidestep and wrote that Vance is not part of Netanyahu's support base around Trump. He described a July meeting between the two in Washington as particularly tense. Ynet published a Reuters report in Hebrew headlined around the contrast with Trump, and The Times of Israel emphasized that Vance has weighed in on foreign politics before, including backing Viktor Orban and meeting a leader of Germany's AfD. Outside Israel, Al Jazeera went further than any Israeli outlet, describing Vance as a symbol of growing Republican discontent with unconditional U.S. support for Israel and recalling his June line that Israel cannot kill its way out of every security problem. Turkey's state broadcaster TRT World kept its own text brief and factual under a subheading saying Vance diverged from the White House. Israeli outlets largely treated the remark as a personal rift between Vance and Netanyahu. Al Jazeera presented it as part of a broader shift in U.S. politics. For Israelis, the timing matters. The vote is October 27, JTA reported polls showing Netanyahu behind Gadi Eisenkot, and the AP said many Israelis are disappointed with the inconclusive Iran war. Trump made U.S. help on Iran a reason to keep Netanyahu. His own vice president's refusal to echo that leaves Israeli voters with a mixed message from Washington.