Judge bars ICE stops based on ethnicity in Southern California
A federal judge ordered immigration agents in seven Southern California counties to stop detaining people for looking Latino.
Objective Facts
U.S. District Judge Maame Ewusi-Mensah Frimpong of the Central District of California granted a preliminary injunction that bars immigration agents from detaining people based solely on apparent Latino ethnicity or perceived working-class Latino status. The order, issued October 23 and unsealed October 29, covers seven counties and requires individualized reasonable suspicion, except at ports of entry and checkpoints. Frimpong found the plaintiffs, represented by the ACLU of Southern California and other groups, were likely to prove violations of the Fourth and Fifth Amendments, though the Los Angeles Times noted this is not a final ruling. The Trump administration has appealed to the 9th Circuit and asked for a stay. In 2025 the Supreme Court stayed an earlier order from Frimpong; she said the new request rests on evidence the government had not yet produced at that time.
Left-Leaning Perspective
The Los Angeles Times, in a report by Brittny Mejia, led with the judge's finding of an unwritten and officially sanctioned practice of stopping people who appear Latino, and gave detailed space to the body-camera and text-message evidence. ABC News reporter Armando Garcia had first reported in July that court filings showed agents using slurs about Latinos, including the term tonk. The Latin Times focused on Latino U.S. citizens who said agents ignored their citizenship claims.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Searches of Fox News, The Wall Street Journal, National Review and the Washington Examiner found no coverage of the October injunction. The clearest right-leaning case against Frimpong's approach comes from Heather Mac Donald of the Manhattan Institute, who wrote in City Journal in August 2025 that race, language, location and job type are reasonable grounds for a brief stop. American Frontline News, reviewing a separate September 2026 Frimpong order on warrantless arrests, cast the court as overstepping its role.
Deep Dive
The case began in July 2025, when the ACLU of Southern California and Public Counsel sued on behalf of workers and U.S. citizens stopped during the Los Angeles immigration sweeps. Frimpong issued a temporary order that year limiting stops based on race, language, location and job type, and the Supreme Court stayed it, with Justice Brett Kavanaugh writing that apparent ethnicity could be weighed with other factors. During discovery, the plaintiffs obtained body-camera footage, depositions and text messages, which ABC News first reported in July 2026, and used them to seek the new preliminary injunction. The plaintiffs' strongest point is the record: the Los Angeles Times and Newsweek describe recordings and texts with slurs, patrols without specific targets and Latino workers detained while white bystanders were left alone. Their coverage tends to skip over how narrow the order is. It bars stops based solely on apparent ethnicity or class, still allows those factors within a broader set of circumstances, and is not a final ruling. The government's argument that the Supreme Court already weighed the same dispute has some force, though Frimpong said the evidence before her had not been produced then. Right-leaning outlets have largely ignored the new evidence, and the few critiques on record predate it. The next step is the 9th Circuit, where the administration has asked for a stay. If that fails, a second trip to the Supreme Court is likely, and the justices would have to decide whether the new record changes the outcome of their 2025 stay. Meanwhile, the ACLU and CHIRLA say they will track agent compliance, and a separate September 2026 Frimpong order on warrantless arrests in the same district is also on appeal.