Judge declines to immediately approve Paramount-Warner Bros. Discovery consent decree
A federal judge held off approving Paramount's settlement with 12 states, delaying the $110 billion Warner Bros. Discovery merger.
Objective Facts
U.S. District Judge Araceli Martínez-Olguín, who is overseeing the 12-state antitrust lawsuit against Paramount Skydance's $110 billion purchase of Warner Bros. Discovery, declined at a September 24 hearing to immediately sign the consent decree the parties filed on September 21. She said a ruling would come "in due course" and asked the parties to respond by September 28 to a letter from Sen. Cory Booker urging an independent public-interest review. Media and film groups in the Block the Merger coalition, plus LULAC, filed amicus briefs urging rejection. Paramount and the states filed defenses of the deal on September 28, and as of that date the judge had not ruled.
Deep Dive
California and 11 other states sued in July to block Paramount Skydance's takeover of Warner Bros. Discovery, and on September 21 they filed a proposed consent decree instead of going to trial. Under its terms, as reported by Variety and TheWrap, Paramount would commit $300 million a year for five years to U.S. film and TV production, release at least 30 films a year in theaters, keep a 45-day theatrical window, create an editorial independence board for CNN and CBS News, and face divestiture of Miramax or several cable networks if it breaks the terms. The deal needed a judge's signature, and at the September 24 hearing Judge Araceli Martínez-Olguín told the parties to show the agreement was an arm's-length bargain and not the product of collusion. The states' case for the settlement rests on trial risk. Paula Blizzard of the California attorney general's antitrust section told the court that blocking the merger "would be forever," Variety reported, and in the September 28 filing the parties argued the decree should be judged against "the risk of continued litigation," not a permanent injunction the states never won. Critics focus on process and enforceability. Sen. Cory Booker, according to The Desk, said the decree was filed without a competitive impact statement or public comment period, and he questioned the five-year term and the CNN and CBS News board. The Block the Merger brief, as described by TheWrap, notes that California Attorney General Rob Bonta had earlier criticized the same kind of behavioral remedies he now asks the court to approve. Neither side's filings settle whether behavioral promises can hold a combined studio to its output pledges after five years. The immediate question is timing. Paramount CEO David Ellison has said the deal could close about two weeks after approval, and a roughly $7 million daily ticking fee owed to Warner Bros. Discovery begins October 1, Variety reported. With the September 28 responses filed, the decision on whether to enter the decree as written, ask for changes, or order further review rests with Judge Martínez-Olguín.