Justice Department opens antitrust probe of ABC, CBS, CNN, NBC and Fox News over White House press pool boycott
The Justice Department is investigating whether five TV networks broke antitrust law by pausing White House pool coverage.
Objective Facts
The Justice Department's Antitrust Division is investigating whether ABC, CBS, CNN, NBC and Fox News violated the Sherman Act when they jointly suspended White House pool coverage in September, department spokeswoman Emily Covington told reporters over the weekend of Oct. 10. According to The New York Times, officials asked the networks for communications and materials related to the pool, which had stopped supplying footage for several days after Donald Trump barred CNN, MS NOW and Politico from the White House on Sept. 18. The networks resumed pool duties on Sept. 25 and have not commented on the probe. Press freedom groups called the investigation an attempt to intimidate news outlets. On Oct. 13, Judge Timothy Kelly extended his block on the underlying ban, finding it likely amounted to viewpoint discrimination, but he did not rule on the pool rotation itself.
Left-Leaning Perspective
NPR media correspondent David Folkenflik told Morning Edition on Oct. 12 that the networks agreed not to fill in for CNN when it was barred, and that the department is casting that as possible collusion. He placed the probe alongside regulatory and legal pressure on several outlets. Jem Bartholomew of the Columbia Journalism Review described the investigation as retaliation for the pool's refusal to supply footage. The New York Times, which first reported the probe, said officials had demanded internal communications from the networks.
Right-Leaning Perspective
RedState's Teri Christoph wrote on Oct. 12 that the networks, which normally cooperate on the pool, coordinated their pause after the CNN ban and may now face real legal exposure, while acknowledging the department has made no finding. HotAir ran an American Greatness item presenting the move as an antitrust case over a coverage boycott, built on the Times report. Searches did not turn up dedicated commentary from Fox News, The Wall Street Journal or National Review in the Oct. 12 to 15 window.
Deep Dive
The probe grew out of a September clash. Donald Trump barred CNN, MS NOW and Politico from the White House on Sept. 18, and the other members of the five-network TV pool declined to fill CNN's slot, leaving events such as Trump's greeting of Xi Jinping without pool footage for several days. The networks resumed pool duties Sept. 25. In the week of Oct. 10 the Justice Department contacted the networks seeking pool communications and confirmed an Antitrust Division inquiry under the Sherman Act, which bars group boycotts among competitors. The department's theory has a real legal foothold: rival firms agreeing together to withhold a product is a classic antitrust concern, a point David Balto made to Communications Daily. Critics on the left often skip that the networks did coordinate. The department's backers, in turn, tend to leave out that most antitrust lawyers quoted, including George Hay and Seth Bloom, said political boycotts with no price effect are a poor fit for the statute and have long had First Amendment protection. The timing, days before a ruling on the CNN ban, is what press groups point to as evidence of retaliation. Judge Timothy Kelly's Oct. 13 injunction keeps the three outlets' reporters credentialed, finding likely viewpoint discrimination, but it left open whether Trump can exclude them from the rotating pool. The White House said it would appeal. The next markers are whether the networks comply with or contest the document demands, and whether the department moves beyond information requests to any formal action.