Justice Department sues Alaska to delay certifying results if Sen. Dan Sullivan loses
Trump's Justice Department asked a federal judge to hold up Alaska's Senate certification if Sen. Dan Sullivan loses.
Objective Facts
The Justice Department sued Alaska's Division of Elections on Oct. 22 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Alaska, asking that the state not certify its U.S. Senate result if Republican Sen. Dan S. Sullivan loses by a margin smaller than the vote for Daniel J. Sullivan, a namesake candidate listed with no party. The complaint, signed by Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward, cites the National Voter Registration Act and says the second Sullivan is running to help Democrat Mary Peltola, who led the August primary with 49.5% to the senator's 41.4%. Donald Trump said on Oct. 23 that he directed the filing, while Attorney General Todd Blanche said earlier that the department never intends to improperly interfere with elections. By Oct. 24, Peltola's campaign, the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee and a group of voters represented by the ACLU had asked Judge Sharon Gleason to let them intervene and dismiss the case. Al Jazeera, the main non-US outlet that covered it, framed the case as an explainer on Alaska's ranked choice system.
Left-Leaning Perspective
ABC News centered its report on Trump's personal role, quoting him saying he told the department to file and noting he labeled Daniel J. Sullivan a fake. It paired that with Blanche's assurance that the department does not aim to interfere with certification, leaving readers to weigh the two. Alaska Public Media, the NPR member station, framed the case as an effort to block a possible Peltola win and gave space to Notre Dame law professor Derek Muller, who expects dismissal, and to Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee executive director Devan Barber, who called it a sham.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Right of center coverage of the lawsuit itself was thin in what we found. FOX 2 Detroit's Jason Gunn, writing from Associated Press material, presented the case largely in the department's own terms, as a federal duty to protect election integrity, while describing Republican claims about Daniel J. Sullivan as accusations. Earlier commentary in Legal Insurrection by Elizabeth Stauffer, published in August, laid the groundwork for the Republican view that the namesake is a planted spoiler. We did not find a Wall Street Journal, National Review or Fox News opinion piece on the suit itself.
Deep Dive
The fight started in June, when Alaska's Division of Elections removed Daniel J. Sullivan from the ballot on the ground that he was running to confuse voters. A state judge reversed that, and the Alaska Supreme Court affirmed on June 29, so he appears as "Sullivan, Daniel J. Jr." with no party listed, while the senator appears as a registered Republican and incumbent. He took 2.5% in the August primary, which Peltola led by about eight points. The Justice Department suit, filed Oct. 22, does not ask to remove him. It asks the court to bar certification if the senator loses by less than the namesake's vote, pending an inquiry into voter intent. The administration has a real factual hook: state election officials themselves first concluded the candidacy was meant to mislead, and Trump has argued that even a few points could swing a close race. Coverage critical of the suit tends to skip that finding. The defenders leave out a lot as well. The state's own Supreme Court overruled that finding, Alaska's ranked choice ballot lets a voter rank both Sullivans so a mistaken first choice can still transfer, as University of Alaska Southeast's Glenn Wright told Al Jazeera, and the NVRA deals mainly with voter registration, which is why Muller, Becker and Ginsberg all doubted its use here. Trump's statement that he ordered the filing also makes the department's claim of neutrality harder to sustain. Judge Sharon Gleason must first rule on the intervention motions from Peltola's campaign, the DSCC and the ACLU backed voters, then on dismissal and any sanctions request. The Alaska Department of Law has said only that it is reviewing the complaint, and Democrats argued the state may not fight hard. If the race is not close, the case may become moot. If the margin falls inside the namesake's total, the court will face a question no federal judge has ruled on: whether Washington can freeze a state's certification over ballot name confusion.