Justice Department sues California to block counting of mail ballots from alleged noncitizens
The Justice Department sued California to set aside about 20,000 mail ballots it says went to likely noncitizens.
Objective Facts
The Justice Department sued California on Thursday, October 15, asking a federal judge in Los Angeles to stop the state and Los Angeles County from counting mail ballots from roughly 20,000 registrants that the Department of Homeland Security flagged as likely noncitizens, until their citizenship is confirmed. The suit names Secretary of State Shirley Weber and Registrar-Recorder Dean Logan and follows October 13 letters from acting Deputy Attorney General Trent McCotter giving officials 48 hours to review a list delivered on a thumb drive. Attorney General Todd Blanche said in a statement quoted by the Daily Wire and the Los Angeles Times that state-facilitated voter fraud is unacceptable. Weber, Attorney General Rob Bonta and Gov. Gavin Newsom rejected the demand, citing the lack of supporting data and a federal estimate that fell from about 190,000 in July to 20,000. Straight Arrow News reported on October 16 that no court had yet ordered any ballots withheld.
Left-Leaning Perspective
Mainstream left-of-center coverage came mostly from California outlets. The Los Angeles Times called the move highly unusual because mail voting had already begun, and noted that the lawsuit does not explain why the federal estimate fell from 190,000 to 20,000. CalMatters reporters Jeanne Kuang and Ana B. Ibarra built their story around Democratic officials and county registrars, citing Newsom's argument that the demand would push officials to break the National Voter Registration Act's 90-day limit on systematic roll changes. National outlets such as CNN, The New York Times and Politico did not turn up in searches for original reporting within the October 15 to 18 window.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Mainstream conservative coverage within the first three days was thin in searches. Just the News, through chief political correspondent Ben Whedon, put Blanche's phrase about state-facilitated voter fraud in its headline and described a Homeland Security Investigations review of California registration data that produced the 20,000 names. It reported Weber's reply that the emergency was of the Justice Department's own making, though it gave less space to the state's evidentiary objections. No original coverage from Fox News, The Wall Street Journal, National Review or the New York Post dated October 15 to 18 surfaced in searches.
Deep Dive
The suit is the sharpest step yet in a months-long federal push on California's voter rolls. DHS said in July that roughly 190,000 noncitizens might be registered in the state, but California officials told CalMatters they never received the underlying names or method. On October 13, acting Deputy Attorney General Trent McCotter gave Weber and Logan 48 hours to review a list of about 20,000 names and to set aside the matching ballots. When the deadline passed, the department filed in federal court in Los Angeles, invoking the federal ban on noncitizen voting and the Supremacy Clause, according to Democracy Docket. Ballots had already gone out to about 23 million voters. The administration's side rests on a real legal principle: noncitizens may not vote in federal elections, and the AP reported that the department has charged about 50 people this year with doing so. Conservative outlets correctly note that the request is to segregate ballots, not to cancel registrations. What that coverage tends to leave out is the record of the underlying data. Reuters reported the department has lost 26 voter-roll data cases without a win, and Nevada's review of 185 flagged names found only citizens. The department's own complaint concedes it cannot investigate every name before the election. Critics on the left are on firm ground about the data and the timing, but some of their coverage gives little weight to the administration's stated goal of verifying eligibility and offers few details on how California itself confirms citizenship beyond the voter's sworn attestation. The next questions are procedural. A federal judge in Los Angeles must decide whether to grant emergency relief while counting is underway, and the Los Angeles Times reported a related case in Washington, D.C., brought by the UCLA Voting Rights Project for CHIRLA, in which a judge has ordered a status report. Also unresolved: whether the department will hand over the methodology California requested, whether county registrars can even separate ballots once envelopes are opened, and how a ruling here would shape similar federal demands in other states before November 3.