Justice Department unseals new charges against James Comey over handling of national defense information
The Justice Department charged James Comey a third time, alleging he leaked classified surveillance details in 2016.
Objective Facts
The Justice Department filed a two-count criminal information against former FBI Director James Comey under seal on October 5, 2026, and Judge Trevor McFadden unsealed the docket on October 26 at Comey's request, CBS News reported. The counts allege that Comey transmitted national defense information to an unauthorized person and conspired to do so in October 2016, when prosecutors say he directed FBI staff to talk with a New York Times reporter about a Reuters story on Yahoo email surveillance. A Justice Department spokesperson said the filing was meant to preserve the 10-year statute of limitations, and no grand jury has indicted Comey. His lawyer Patrick Fitzgerald said Comey maintains his innocence, and the defense has asked McFadden to dismiss the case, which the judge has not yet ruled on. The filing became public hours after a separate federal judge ruled that Comey's daughter, Maurene Comey, was unlawfully fired as a federal prosecutor, according to The Federalist and The New Republic.
Left-Leaning Perspective
CNN's Hannah Rabinowitz and Katelyn Polantz focused on the unusual procedure, quoting CNN legal analyst Elie Honig, a former federal prosecutor, who said an information usually needs a defendant's consent and likely cannot stop the clock. CBS News reporters Sarah N. Lynch and Joe Walsh quoted former prosecutor Greg Rosen and defense lawyer Michael Bromwich, both of whom called the tactic out of the ordinary, and noted that Special Counsel John Durham had reviewed the 2016 leak and recommended no charges. TIME's Miranda Jeyaretnam framed the filing as part of a run of Justice Department actions against Trump critics in the weeks before an election, and quoted a New York Times spokesperson who said cases like this aim to discourage sources from talking to reporters.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Fox News reporters Sophia Compton, David Spunt and Bill Mears covered the filing as a straight legal development, noting McFadden held a closed hearing on October 9 and that it is unclear whether prosecutors will seek an indictment. PJ Media's David Manney wrote that he distrusts Comey but cautioned that a criminal information carries less weight than a grand jury indictment and that another failed prosecution would help Comey. The pseudonymous legal blogger Techno Fog, writing on The Reactionary, argued the defense's statute of limitations challenge is weak while predicting a Washington grand jury will be a hard sell.
Deep Dive
The filing grows out of an October 5, 2016 New York Times story on Yahoo scanning customer email for U.S. intelligence, which cited two unnamed officials. Prosecutors allege Comey directed FBI staff to brief the Times reporter to correct a Reuters story published the day before, according to CBS News and The Daily Wire. The Espionage Act carries a 10-year limitations period, so the government filed a sealed information on the last possible day instead of seeking an indictment. Comey's two earlier cases, a false statements indictment dismissed in November 2025 and a pending threat case over a seashell photo, form the backdrop. Critics of the prosecution correctly point out that the same leak was reviewed by John Durham and others without charges, and that the procedural route is unusual, according to former prosecutors quoted by CBS News and CNN. They say less about the substance of the allegation, which concerns a classified surveillance program. Supporters of the case, such as The Federalist, focus on that substance but largely skip past the earlier declinations and the legal doubts about using an information without consent. The next decision belongs to Judge Trevor McFadden, who has not ruled on the motion to dismiss. CBS News reported that the government agreed to wait 30 days before seeking an indictment, so any grand jury action would come after that window. If McFadden finds the information did not toll the deadline, the case likely ends; if he upholds it, prosecutors would still need a grand jury to return charges. The North Carolina seashell case is set for trial in February 2027, TIME reported.