Los Angeles officials say DOJ list of suspected noncitizen voters includes US-born citizens
Los Angeles County says a sample of DOJ's 'likely noncitizen' voter list includes many people reporting U.S. birthplaces.
Objective Facts
In a court filing on October 20, Los Angeles County election officials said a preliminary review of 200 records from a Justice Department list of roughly 20,000 suspected noncitizen voters found a large share who reported being born in the United States. NPR reported that 38.9% of sampled records with a meaningful birthplace entry listed a U.S. birthplace, and that only 7,035 people on the statewide list had Los Angeles County addresses. Assistant Registrar-Recorder Monica Flores wrote in a sworn declaration that the DOJ's request to segregate ballots would risk disenfranchising validly registered voters. The Justice Department, which built the list with the Department of Homeland Security, sued California last week and is seeking a court order to set those ballots aside before the November 3 election. Acting Deputy Attorney General Trent McCotter acknowledged at an October 19 press conference that some people on the list may turn out to be citizens.
Left-Leaning Perspective
Mainstream outlets led with the county's numbers while noting the review is preliminary. NPR's Miles Parks and Jude Joffe-Block reported the 38.9% figure, the 7,035 Los Angeles addresses and the 112 canceled or inactive registrations, and noted that California's registration form treats birthplace as optional. ABC News reporters Alexander Mallin and Lucien Bruggeman paired the county's analysis with McCotter's concession that the list may include citizens and the DOJ's response that California is ignoring federal law.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Right-leaning coverage centered on the federal demand and California's refusal rather than on the county's sample. Fox News reporters Brittany Miller and Max Gorden led with McCotter's 48-hour deadline and the request to segregate ballots, while noting DOJ had not shown that anyone on the list voted illegally. The Daily Signal's Angelina Delfin framed the lawsuit as a defense of citizens' votes, though she also quoted Cato Institute fellow Stephen Richer calling the request highly irregular. Searches found no right-leaning piece directly addressing the U.S.-born findings.
Deep Dive
The Justice Department sent Secretary of State Shirley Weber and Los Angeles County Registrar Dean Logan a list of about 20,000 voters on October 13 and gave them 48 hours to act, then sued when they did not. DOJ says DHS started with the public voter roll, removed people with citizenship records and manually verified the rest. On October 20 Los Angeles County answered in court with a 200-record sample, reporting that 38.9% of records with usable birthplace data listed a U.S. birthplace, that 112 records were canceled or inactive registrations, and that about 71% showed no voting history. The county's filing is a preliminary sample, and the county itself says a U.S. birthplace is strong evidence of citizenship rather than proof. NPR noted that birthplace is optional on California's registration form, so the true share of U.S.-born people on the list is unknown. The administration's side can point to McCotter's candor that errors exist and to 28 criminal cases, but its coverage, from Fox News to RedState, has not engaged with the county's numbers, and DOJ has not publicly detailed how DHS matched records. Coverage critical of DOJ, such as Talking Points Memo's, tends to treat the sample as conclusive about the whole list, which a 200-record review cannot establish. The next step is a ruling on DOJ's emergency request to set ballots aside before the November 3 election. States Newsroom reported that Judge Sparkle Sooknanan is separately weighing whether DOJ's sharing of voter data violates her earlier order. McCotter has said the list will likely grow, and any court order on segregation would determine whether thousands of Los Angeles ballots are counted on schedule.