Maduro and wife ask Manhattan federal judge to dismiss drug-trafficking case, citing immunity
Nicolás Maduro and Cilia Flores asked a Manhattan judge to toss their drug case, claiming immunity as Venezuela's leaders.
Objective Facts
Nicolás Maduro, the ousted Venezuelan president seized by US forces in a January 3 raid on Caracas, asked a federal judge in Manhattan on September 2 to dismiss the drug-trafficking charges against him, Reuters reporter Luc Cohen wrote. His lawyer, Barry Pollack, argued that a sitting head of state cannot be prosecuted in a foreign court and that the acts alleged were official duties, and he filed a second motion to strike the narco-terrorism count. Cilia Flores, Maduro's wife, made a separate immunity claim, and both have pleaded not guilty and remain in a Brooklyn jail, the Associated Press reported. Reuters noted that Washington has not recognized Maduro as president since 2019 and that courts usually defer to the executive branch on recognition, which legal experts said makes the bid an uphill fight. Venezuelan outlet El Diario and Colombia's El Universal covered the filing in procedural terms and recalled the 1990 Noriega precedent, with no on-record reaction from Caracas.
Left-Leaning Perspective
ABC News reporter Luke Barr treated the immunity claim as the main news and added background from earlier stages of the case, including a failed March bid to dismiss over Treasury blocking Venezuela from paying Maduro's lawyers. NPR member stations carried the AP account. No opinion or analysis from The New York Times, The Washington Post or MSNBC turned up in the reporting window.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Fox News reporter Robert McGreevy headlined the story as Maduro claiming immunity and listed the narco-terrorism, cocaine importation and weapons counts from the January superseding indictment. McGreevy also noted the due process and statutory arguments in the motion and reminded readers that the US declared Maduro illegitimate in 2019.
Deep Dive
US forces captured Nicolás Maduro and Cilia Flores in Caracas on January 3 and brought them to New York to face charges first filed years earlier in the Southern District of New York. Judge Alvin Hellerstein set a September 2 deadline for pretrial motions, and Barry Pollack used it to argue that the court has no jurisdiction because Maduro was a sitting head of state and the alleged acts were official. Flores' lawyers made a parallel claim, and the defense also asked the court to strike the narco-terrorism count as an overreach of US law to foreign conduct. The defense has a historical point: Pollack wrote that no American court has tried a foreign leader, and Noriega's case is the only close parallel. But Reuters reported that courts usually defer to the president on recognition, and Washington has not recognized Maduro since 2019. Pollack's best argument is the inconsistency he identified: the Trump administration now works with Delcy Rodríguez, whose government at first treated Maduro as the legitimate president. Coverage that framed the raid as an abduction, such as Democracy Now's, spoke to the legitimacy of the capture but not to the immunity doctrine the judge must apply. Prosecutors must respond by October 2, Hellerstein will hear arguments on November 17, and trial is scheduled for June 1, 2027. Whether Rodríguez's government takes any position on Maduro's status, after going quiet on it according to Reuters, could matter to the court.
Regional Perspective
Venezuela's El Diario, drawing on EFE, reported on September 2 that Pollack sought dismissal with prejudice, which would bar the charges from being refiled, and quoted the filing's claim that Maduro is entitled to both head-of-state and conduct-based immunity. Colombia's El Universal, published in Cartagena, laid out the same two motions and added that Flores' lawyer, Mark Donnelly, argues she shares her husband's immunity as first lady. The Latin American coverage was more skeptical of the defense than the US wire reports. El Universal's headline called the filing "la nueva jugada," or new move, by Maduro to avoid US justice. El Diario noted that Maduro was still in office when captured, despite US non-recognition and disputes over the 2024 vote, a point US outlets mentioned less directly. Neither outlet reported any statement from Caracas, where Delcy Rodríguez's government has been cooperating with Washington. For Venezuela, the case touches the question of who legitimately held power before January, which remains politically sensitive as Rodríguez governs. For Colombia and the wider region, the prosecution of a captured head of state is a test of how far US courts will go in trying foreign leaders taken by force.