Minnesota Supreme Court rejects Mike Lindell's bid for recount of GOP governor primary
Minnesota's top court upheld the state's limited recount plan, rejecting Mike Lindell's demand to hand count every primary ballot.
Objective Facts
The Minnesota Supreme Court on Saturday, Aug. 29, rejected Mike Lindell's request to force a full hand recount of every ballot in the Aug. 11 Republican primary for governor, which he lost to House Speaker Lisa Demuth by 45,401 votes. Chief Justice Natalie E. Hudson wrote that the secretary of state's office and the State Canvassing Board did not act wrongly by adopting a recount plan that sorts ballots into piles for Lindell, Demuth and all other candidates. Hudson said Lindell's focus on alleged anomalies "confuses the purpose of a manual recount with an election contest," and noted that his separate election contest in Ramsey County court remains a distinct matter. Lindell, who withheld an estimated $825,000 recount payment over the plan's scope, said he will take the case to the U.S. Supreme Court. Demuth faces DFL nominee Amy Klobuchar in November.
Left-Leaning Perspective
NBC News reporter Kyla Guilfoil led with the court's reasoning and placed the ruling within Lindell's record, calling him a longtime 2020 election denier now refusing to accept his own primary loss and listing his defamation verdict and unpaid sanctions in the Smartmatic case. MPR News reporters Brian Bakst and Seth Richardson focused on procedure: Lindell missed the Monday deadline to request and pay for a recount, and state officials had warned a late recount could delay general election ballots. Political Wire, aggregating NBC News and NOTUS, kept its posts short and stressed that Lindell "has long denied" Donald Trump's 2020 loss.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Right-of-center coverage did not defend Lindell's demand. The Washington Examiner's Brady Knox called the 11-point loss a landslide, quoted the ruling's finding that the claim "fails on the merits," and said Lindell is known for consistently denying the legitimacy of election results. The Center Square's Elyse Apel gave the campaign more space, reporting that the state announced its narrower plan on the same day as the Aug. 24 recount deadline and quoting Lindell's view that every one of the 1.1 million ballots should be counted.
Deep Dive
Lindell finished second to Lisa Demuth on Aug. 11 and, a week later, said he would pay roughly $825,000 for a hand recount. The secretary of state's office then set out a contingency plan that would sort ballots by party and stack Republican ballots for Lindell, Demuth and everyone else, which Lindell rejected because it would not retally the other five candidates. He withheld payment and asked the Minnesota Supreme Court to order a broader count. On Aug. 29 the court, in an order by Chief Justice Natalie E. Hudson, found the case was not moot but ruled against him on the merits. The same day it dismissed a separate equipment challenge from running mate Phillip Parrish as filed too late, according to MPR News. Coverage critical of Lindell, from NBC News to the Washington Examiner, accurately reports the margin, the absence of official fraud findings and the court's reasoning, but spends more space on his 2020 history than on the statutory question he raised. The Center Square and WCCO did more to explain the campaign's reading of state law and the timing complaint about the plan arriving on deadline day. The legal distinction Hudson drew is the key point: a recount checks whether votes were counted correctly between the contenders, while claims of irregularities go to an election contest, which Lindell has filed separately in Ramsey County. Three threads remain open. Lindell has said he will seek U.S. Supreme Court review, though MPR News noted federal courts usually avoid state election disputes. His Ramsey County election contest is still pending, and his team's records requests to all 87 counties could feed that case. Meanwhile, MPR reported that early voting begins Sept. 18, with Demuth set to face DFL nominee Amy Klobuchar and Green Party candidate Steven Young.