Missouri Supreme Court unanimously blocks GOP's mid-decade congressional map for November midterms
Missouri's top court unanimously kept the Trump-backed House map off November ballots until voters approve it in a referendum.
Objective Facts
The Missouri Supreme Court ruled unanimously on September 3 that the Republican congressional map passed in a 2025 special session cannot be used in the November 3 midterms unless voters first approve it in a referendum. The court found that People Not Politicians Missouri filed a valid and timely petition in December, and that Secretary of State Denny Hoskins was wrong to reject it on August 4, primary day, the Associated Press reported. Judge Ginger Gooch wrote that the map "will not go into effect unless and until approved by the voters," according to Newsweek. The ruling restores the 2022 map, which elected six Republicans and two Democrats, even though the August primaries were run on the new lines. Attorney General Catherine Hanaway said she would appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court, and by September 7 the state had asked Justice Brett Kavanaugh to pause the order, St. Louis Public Radio reported. Al Jazeera, writing for an international audience, framed the case as one front in Donald Trump's national push for mid-decade redistricting.
Left-Leaning Perspective
Democracy Docket's Jen Rice and Yunior Rivas presented the ruling as a win for voters over a map drawn at Trump's request, and they cast Hoskins' handling of the petition as obstruction. They quoted plaintiffs' attorney Chuck Hatfield calling the state's planned appeal "a fool's errand," and House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries saying the people are now empowered to decide the map. Peter Weber of The Week called the map a GOP gerrymander and cited Politico's description of an unprecedented set of electoral circumstances.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Fox News reporter Landon Mion led with Republican objections, putting Trump's attack on the ruling in the headline and quoting Hanaway that no court had ever overturned a congressional map between a primary and a general election. Gov. Mike Kehoe told Fox he was disappointed in the judges and still backs the Missouri First Map. The Washington Examiner's Claire Carter treated the ruling as a straight setback, writing that the court had "squashed" Republican plans.
Deep Dive
Gov. Mike Kehoe called a special session in 2025, following Donald Trump's push for mid-decade redistricting, to redraw Missouri's districts and break up Rep. Emanuel Cleaver's Kansas City seat, aiming to move the delegation from 6-2 to 7-1. People Not Politicians gathered roughly 300,000 signatures for a referendum in December. Hoskins did not rule on the petition until August 4, the day the primaries were held on the new lines. Earlier this year the same court had rejected other challenges and let the map stand for the primary, so this ruling turned only on the referendum. The court's core point is narrow and textual: the Missouri Constitution allows referendums on any act of the Legislature, and a timely petition suspends that act. Republicans have a fair complaint that primary voters such as those who nominated Rick Brattin cast ballots in districts that will not exist in November, and Hanaway is right that the timing is unusual. Their account tends to leave out that the timing traces to Hoskins' eight months of inaction, a point the court and KCUR's Jason Rosenbaum both stressed. Supporters of the ruling say less about the practical cost to candidates and county clerks who must now rebuild ballots. The immediate question is whether Justice Brett Kavanaugh or the full U.S. Supreme Court acts before the September 8 ballot deadline. Rosenbaum noted that because the court held the map never took effect, it is unclear how a federal court could order its use. A separate federal suit filed by Republicans Bob Onder and Rick Brattin seeks the same result. Voters will also decide the map itself in November, and St. Louis Public Radio reported the ruling may complicate Hoskins' push to split St. Louis' 1st District.