Ninth Circuit rejects DOJ bid to set aside disputed California mail ballots

A 2-1 Ninth Circuit panel refused to let DOJ wall off ballots tied to 20,000 alleged noncitizens in California.

Objective Facts

A Ninth Circuit panel ruled 2-1 on October 30, 2026, that California does not have to segregate mail ballots tied to roughly 20,000 voters the Justice Department flagged as likely noncitizens, according to the Associated Press. The majority, Judges Mark J. Bennett and Gabriel P. Sanchez, said there was no workable way to pull specific voters' ballots without serious effects on the whole system, and Democracy Docket reported they also found the demand likely violates the National Voter Registration Act's 90-day rule on voter purges. Judge Patrick J. Bumatay dissented. The order came two days after U.S. District Judge David O. Carter denied the same request and four days after an earlier Ninth Circuit order on jurisdictional grounds. The Justice Department has said it plans to appeal to the Supreme Court, and Election Day is November 3.

Left-Leaning Perspective

NPR and NBC's California stations framed the ballot case as one piece of a broader federal pressure campaign on local election offices. NPR's Jude Joffe-Block reported that Los Angeles County election workers received grand jury subpoenas and quoted Registrar-Recorder Dean Logan criticizing the department. States Newsroom's Jonathan Shorman, writing about the earlier October 26 hearing, highlighted judges' doubts about the federal list and a Los Angeles County lawyer's dismissal of the DOJ's timing argument. NBC Bay Area's Jocelyn Moran focused on county letters, including one listing 902 Santa Clara County voters.

Right-Leaning Perspective

RedState managing editor Jennifer Van Laar wrote that the dispute appears headed to the Supreme Court and built her piece around Judge Bumatay's dissent. She presented California's citizenship checks as weak and the rulings as a failure to protect the vote, giving little room to the majority's reasoning. Searches for coverage of the October 30 order from The Wall Street Journal, National Review, Fox News national and the Washington Examiner did not return articles on this angle.

Deep Dive

The Justice Department sued California on October 15 after state officials ignored a 48-hour deadline to review and set aside ballots tied to a federal list of about 20,000 people it says are likely noncitizens. Judge David O. Carter denied the request on October 28, and on October 30 a Ninth Circuit panel refused emergency relief for the second time that week. The majority said separating the ballots was not feasible this late, and Democracy Docket reported it found the demand likely runs afoul of the National Voter Registration Act's 90-day limit on systematic purges. The same day, Judge Trina L. Thompson barred DOJ threats against election workers and another judge ordered the list shared with the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights and the UCLA Voting Rights Project, AP reported. Critics of the DOJ have a strong procedural record on their side: three courts, including a panel with two Trump appointees, rejected the request, and the majority found the timing problem was largely the government's own. The coverage that backs the DOJ also has a point that the opposing side tends to skip: federal law does bar noncitizen voting, the DOJ has charged 28 people from the broader list, and Bumatay argued that counting suspect ballots dilutes eligible votes. What no outlet has shown is an independent check of how many of the 20,000 names are actually noncitizens. Los Angeles County's sample, cited by AP, suggested most flagged voters looked U.S.-born. The next step is a possible emergency application to the Supreme Court, which the DOJ has said it plans to file. At least three Los Angeles County election officials have been asked to appear before a grand jury the day after the election, AP reported, so the criminal side of the dispute will continue after the votes are counted. Parallel DOJ demands in Washington state and a certification challenge in Alaska may test the same legal theory in other courts.

OBJ SPEAKING

Create StoryTimelinesVoter ToolsRegional AnalysisPolicy GuideAll StoriesCommunity PicksUSWorldPoliticsBusinessHealthEntertainmentTechnologyAbout

Ninth Circuit rejects DOJ bid to set aside disputed California mail ballots

A 2-1 Ninth Circuit panel refused to let DOJ wall off ballots tied to 20,000 alleged noncitizens in California.

Oct 30, 2026· Updated Nov 2, 2026
What's Going On
  • On October 30, 2026, a 2-1 panel of the Ninth Circuit denied the Justice Department's emergency request to make California set aside mail ballots linked to about 20,000 registered voters the department calls likely noncitizens, the Associated Press reported.
  • Judges Mark J. Bennett, a Trump appointee, and Gabriel P. Sanchez, a Biden appointee, formed the majority, while Trump appointee Patrick J. Bumatay dissented.
  • The ruling followed a denial by U.S. District Judge David O. Carter earlier that week and an October 26 Ninth Circuit order that sent the case back to him for lack of jurisdiction.
  • Democracy Docket reported the majority found the request likely conflicts with the National Voter Registration Act's ban on systematic voter purges within 90 days of an election.
  • The Justice Department has said it will take the fight to the U.S. Supreme Court, but no filing had been reported as of October 30.
Far Left: Democracy Docket's Alexandra Hutzler framed the ruling as a third consecutive defeat for the Justice Department in this case.
Left: NPR's Jude Joffe-Block linked the court fight to grand jury subpoenas served on Los Angeles County election staff.
Moderate: AP reported the majority included one Trump appointee and one Biden appointee, while the dissenter was a Trump appointee.
Right: Jennifer Van Laar argued in RedState that the DOJ's request to hold the ballots until citizenship is verified was reasonable.
Far Right: The Epoch Times reported the DOJ charged 28 noncitizens on the broader suspected list with election-related crimes.
✓ Common Ground
Voices on each side, from Judge Bumatay to California Attorney General Rob Bonta, accept that noncitizens are barred from voting in federal elections; the fight is over whether this list and this remedy fit that rule.
Judges across the panel, including Trump appointees Bennett and Bumatay, treated the case as urgent enough to rule within days of Election Day.
Outlets as far apart as RedState and Democracy Docket expect the case to reach the Supreme Court.
◆ All Sources (12)
AP (via KSAT) - Federal appeals court rejects Justice Department demand for California to set aside disputed ballotsAP (via News4Jax) - Judge orders the US Justice Department to hand over list of alleged noncitizen voters in CaliforniaReuters (via GV Wire) - Trump Admin Again Loses Bid to Block California From Counting Alleged Noncitizen VotesStraight Arrow News - Appeals court rejects Trump administration push to set aside 20,000 California mail ballotsNBC Bay Area - 9th Circuit denies Trump administration request on California ballotsDemocracy Docket - Appeals court again rejects DOJ's bid to block some California ballots, setting up Supreme Court showdownNPR (via KUNC) - Justice Department issues subpoenas to California election workersStates Newsroom (via Daily Montanan) - Trump DOJ's suit over California vote counting meets a doubtful appeals court panelFOX 11 Los Angeles - Ninth Circuit dismisses Trump administration's appeal over 20,000 California mail ballotsRedState - It Looks Like the Dispute Over 20,000 'Likely Noncitizens' on CA's Voter Rolls Is Going to SCOTUSThe Epoch Times (via ZeroHedge) - Appeals court rejects DOJ's challenge to suspected noncitizen ballots in CaliforniaBreitbart (AP) - Appeals court declines to rule on federal bid to set aside California ballots of alleged noncitizens
Objective Deep Dive

The Justice Department sued California on October 15 after state officials ignored a 48-hour deadline to review and set aside ballots tied to a federal list of about 20,000 people it says are likely noncitizens. Judge David O. Carter denied the request on October 28, and on October 30 a Ninth Circuit panel refused emergency relief for the second time that week. The majority said separating the ballots was not feasible this late, and Democracy Docket reported it found the demand likely runs afoul of the National Voter Registration Act's 90-day limit on systematic purges. The same day, Judge Trina L. Thompson barred DOJ threats against election workers and another judge ordered the list shared with the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights and the UCLA Voting Rights Project, AP reported.

Critics of the DOJ have a strong procedural record on their side: three courts, including a panel with two Trump appointees, rejected the request, and the majority found the timing problem was largely the government's own. The coverage that backs the DOJ also has a point that the opposing side tends to skip: federal law does bar noncitizen voting, the DOJ has charged 28 people from the broader list, and Bumatay argued that counting suspect ballots dilutes eligible votes. What no outlet has shown is an independent check of how many of the 20,000 names are actually noncitizens. Los Angeles County's sample, cited by AP, suggested most flagged voters looked U.S.-born.

The next step is a possible emergency application to the Supreme Court, which the DOJ has said it plans to file. At least three Los Angeles County election officials have been asked to appear before a grand jury the day after the election, AP reported, so the criminal side of the dispute will continue after the votes are counted. Parallel DOJ demands in Washington state and a certification challenge in Alaska may test the same legal theory in other courts.

◈ Tone Comparison

Democracy Docket framed the next round as a "Supreme Court showdown," and States Newsroom described the DOJ push as a rushed, last-minute campaign. RedState repeated the DOJ's likely noncitizens label and Bumatay's language about lax checks, framing the courts as the problem. AP and Reuters stuck to procedural wording about an emergency request and a 2-1 ruling.