Peltola denies role in recruiting a second Dan Sullivan as Alaska orders investigation

Mary Peltola denies recruiting Petersburg's Dan J. Sullivan as probes into his Senate run move from Alaska to the Justice Department.

Objective Facts

Republicans led by Sen. Dan S. Sullivan and the National Republican Senatorial Committee have accused Democrat Mary Peltola of recruiting a Petersburg man, Dan J. Sullivan, to split the incumbent's vote, and Peltola's campaign has denied any involvement from the start. Lt. Gov. Nancy Dahlstrom opened a state investigation on June 8, and elections director Carol Beecher removed the challenger from the ballot on June 15 without citing evidence of coordination with Peltola, according to the Associated Press. State courts put him back on the ballot without a party label, and he took about 2% in the August primary. On Oct. 22 the Justice Department sued to block certification of a Peltola win pending an investigation, a move Peltola called "just flagrant, flagrant corruption in my opinion," according to the AP. Reporting by Alaska's News Source has found no evidence of direct coordination between Democrats and Dan J. Sullivan.

Left-Leaning Perspective

Mainstream left-leaning coverage has shifted the focus from Peltola's alleged role to the federal response. TheGrio's Odafe Oghen reported the Justice Department's case alongside the objections of Alaska officials and noted that the suit does not attribute any recruitment to Peltola. The Boston Globe's version of the AP story framed the suit as a possible opening in a long federal fight over certifying races Trump's party is losing. Alaska Public Media's coverage of the June investigation stressed that Peltola's campaign and the Alaska Democratic Party had publicly denied any affiliation with the challenger.

Right-Leaning Perspective

Fox News broke the story on May 29 with a report built on the NRSC's case that Dan J. Sullivan is a sham candidate. Fox reporters Adam Pack, Leo Briceno and Alex Miller highlighted metadata showing that consultant Amber Lee, a past Peltola backer, wrote the challenger's launch release, while also printing a Peltola spokesperson's denial. The Washington Examiner's Ramsey Touchberry reported in August that both Sullivans had advanced to November, without adding new evidence about Peltola.

Deep Dive

The dispute began in late May, when Dan J. Sullivan, a retired Petersburg teacher, filed for the Senate seat held by Republican Dan S. Sullivan. Fox News and the NRSC tied him to Peltola through consultant Amber Lee, and Alaska's News Source later found two small donations from a Petersburg Dan Sullivan to Peltola's past campaigns. Peltola's campaign denied any role. Lt. Gov. Nancy Dahlstrom opened an inquiry on June 8, elections director Carol Beecher removed him a week later, and the state courts put him back on the ballot without a party label, according to the AP. Republicans have documented real links between the challenger and people who have backed Peltola, including Lee and, per National Review reporting relayed by Legal Insurrection, a pro-Peltola super PAC treasurer. What they have not shown is that Peltola or her campaign directed the run. Beecher's own removal letter did not cite such evidence, the AP reported, and Alaska's News Source has found none. Democratic critics, for their part, tend to skip past the challenger's name change, party switch and website, which Beecher cited as signs of intent to confuse voters, according to Townhall's account of her letter. His 2.47% primary share is small, though Trump has argued a few points could decide the race. The next test is the Justice Department suit filed Oct. 22 in federal court in Alaska, which asks the court to block certification of a Peltola win while votes for Dan J. Sullivan are investigated. Peltola's campaign and the DSCC have asked to intervene and seek dismissal, and Notre Dame law professor Derek Muller told the AP the statute does not allow the department to enjoin certification. NBC News has reported grand jury subpoenas in a separate federal probe, but as of August Peltola's campaign said no staff had received one, according to the Alaska Beacon. The general election is Nov. 3.

OBJ SPEAKING

Create StoryTimelinesVoter ToolsRegional AnalysisPolicy GuideAll StoriesCommunity PicksUSWorldPoliticsBusinessHealthEntertainmentTechnologyAbout

Peltola denies role in recruiting a second Dan Sullivan as Alaska orders investigation

Mary Peltola denies recruiting Petersburg's Dan J. Sullivan as probes into his Senate run move from Alaska to the Justice Department.

Oct 26, 2026· Updated Oct 30, 2026
What's Going On
  • Mary Peltola's campaign has denied any role in the candidacy of Dan J. Sullivan, a retired Petersburg teacher running against Republican Sen. Dan S. Sullivan, since Republicans first accused her of recruiting him in late May and early June 2026.
  • Lt. Gov. Nancy Dahlstrom opened a state investigation on June 8, citing what she called credible allegations that he filed in coordination with another campaign, and the Division of Elections removed him from the ballot on June 15.
  • Alaska's Superior Court and Supreme Court reinstated Dan J. Sullivan, who won 2.47% in the August primary, behind Peltola at 49.54% and Sen. Sullivan at 41.40%, according to Alaska's News Source.
  • On Oct. 22 the Justice Department sued Alaska to block certification of a Peltola win pending an inquiry into votes cast for Dan J. Sullivan, and Donald Trump said he ordered the suit.
  • Peltola called the suit corruption, and her campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee asked to intervene and seek dismissal, TheGrio reported on Oct. 26.
Far Left: The Alaska Current's Matt Acuña Buxton said Dahlstrom's letter offered no evidence for its coordination claim.
Left: TheGrio reported that Peltola's campaign and the DSCC moved to intervene and argued the federal voter registration law does not reach certification.
Moderate: Alaska's News Source found that FEC records show a Petersburg Dan Sullivan gave $100 and $30 to earlier Peltola campaigns.
Right: Fox News quoted Sen. Sullivan saying national Democrats and the Peltola campaign are complicit.
Far Right: Townhall quoted Beecher's finding that the challenger deliberately used his name to confuse voters.
✓ Common Ground
Reporters at Alaska's News Source, the AP and Legal Insurrection each acknowledge that no published evidence shows Peltola directing the candidacy, even as they differ on how much the indirect links matter.
Coverage from Fox News, Townhall and Alaska's News Source agrees that consultant Amber Lee, a Peltola supporter, worked on the challenger's campaign, a point Dan J. Sullivan has confirmed.
Sen. Lisa Murkowski, a Republican, joined Democrats such as the DSCC's Devan Barber in criticizing the Justice Department's certification suit, according to the AP.
Several outlets, including the AP and Alaska's News Source, report that Alaska's courts settled the ballot question in the challenger's favor before ballots were printed.
◆ All Sources (16)
Alaska's News Source - Trump sues to disqualify votes for Petersburg's Dan SullivanWLOX (AP) - Trump says he ordered the Justice Department lawsuit over Alaska's US Senate raceAlaska's News Source - Two Dan Sullivans: Alaska Lt. Gov. launches investigation into involvement of 'another candidate'Alaska's News Source - 'Entirely false': Petersburg Dan Sullivan denies coordination allegationAlaska Public Media (Alaska Beacon) - Is a U.S. Department of Justice investigation about to disrupt Alaska's U.S. Senate race?Alaska's News Source - Trump says he thinks US attorney general has 'a legal case' against Petersburg's Dan SullivanTheGrio - Trump DOJ seeks to block Alaska Senate certification if Republican losesThe Boston Globe - Trump says he ordered the Justice Department lawsuit over Alaska's US Senate raceThe Alaska Current - Alaska Republicans are absolutely losing their minds over the other Dan SullivanFox News - Dan Sullivan vs. Dan Sullivan: GOP blasts 'clone' candidate as lookalike enters Alaska Senate raceTownhall - Sen. Dan Sullivan's battle with a bogus candidate is finally overLegal Insurrection - Dem Operatives Put Copycat Sullivan on Alaska BallotWashington Examiner - Second Dan Sullivan advances to Alaska Senate's general electionAlaska Public Media - State of Alaska opens investigation into second Dan Sullivan's U.S. Senate runAlaska's News Source - Sullivan vs. Sullivan: Senator accuses Peltola of 'rigging' election, but evidence of her involvement is unclearThe Washington Times (AP) - Namesake challenger to Sen. Dan Sullivan sues to stay on ballot
Objective Deep Dive

The dispute began in late May, when Dan J. Sullivan, a retired Petersburg teacher, filed for the Senate seat held by Republican Dan S. Sullivan. Fox News and the NRSC tied him to Peltola through consultant Amber Lee, and Alaska's News Source later found two small donations from a Petersburg Dan Sullivan to Peltola's past campaigns. Peltola's campaign denied any role. Lt. Gov. Nancy Dahlstrom opened an inquiry on June 8, elections director Carol Beecher removed him a week later, and the state courts put him back on the ballot without a party label, according to the AP.

Republicans have documented real links between the challenger and people who have backed Peltola, including Lee and, per National Review reporting relayed by Legal Insurrection, a pro-Peltola super PAC treasurer. What they have not shown is that Peltola or her campaign directed the run. Beecher's own removal letter did not cite such evidence, the AP reported, and Alaska's News Source has found none. Democratic critics, for their part, tend to skip past the challenger's name change, party switch and website, which Beecher cited as signs of intent to confuse voters, according to Townhall's account of her letter. His 2.47% primary share is small, though Trump has argued a few points could decide the race.

The next test is the Justice Department suit filed Oct. 22 in federal court in Alaska, which asks the court to block certification of a Peltola win while votes for Dan J. Sullivan are investigated. Peltola's campaign and the DSCC have asked to intervene and seek dismissal, and Notre Dame law professor Derek Muller told the AP the statute does not allow the department to enjoin certification. NBC News has reported grand jury subpoenas in a separate federal probe, but as of August Peltola's campaign said no staff had received one, according to the Alaska Beacon. The general election is Nov. 3.

◈ Tone Comparison

Republican voices use words of fraud: Sen. Sullivan said his rival was "cheating" in a CNN interview reported by Alaska Public Media, and Townhall called the challenger "bogus." Peltola's side answers with words of abuse of power, with Peltola calling the federal suit "flagrant corruption" to the AP, while straight news outlets such as Alaska's News Source repeat that evidence of her involvement is unclear.