Rubio defends US-Saudi civil nuclear deal as nonproliferation experts warn of weapons risk
Rubio said a new US-Saudi nuclear pact carries no proliferation risk, while arms control experts warned it opens a weapons path.
Objective Facts
The United States and Saudi Arabia signed a 30-year civil nuclear cooperation agreement on July 22, 2026, with Energy Secretary Chris Wright and Prince Abdulaziz bin Salman putting their names to a 123 agreement and a separate bilateral safeguards accord, Reuters reported. Reuters and The Washington Post said the text allows a possible enrichment facility in the kingdom after a joint feasibility study and does not require the IAEA Additional Protocol, which permits snap inspections. Marco Rubio, traveling in the Philippines for ASEAN meetings, declined to confirm details but told reporters the US would not sign any deal that risks proliferation and that American companies and technology are themselves a safeguard, according to the AP and Democracy Now. On July 23, Donald Trump wrote on Truth Social that "There will be no enrichment of material!" and that the deal is subject to Saudi Arabia joining the Abraham Accords, Axios reported, leaving its status unclear as it heads to a 90-day congressional review. Israeli outlets and commentators focused on the threat to Israel's security edge, while Saudi outlets presented the pact as an economic partnership.
Left-Leaning Perspective
The Washington Post's Evan Halper reported that the deal waives international inspections in favor of American inspection teams and that Trump signed a national security waiver, and he quoted Rep. Brad Sherman reminding readers that Rubio as a senator had co-sponsored a bill requiring congressional approval of such deals. NPR's Emily Feng focused on Trump's July 23 Abraham Accords condition and on Israeli alarm, quoting former ministers who called it a failure for Benjamin Netanyahu. The Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists' François Diaz-Maurin collected expert warnings that the pact could spark a regional enrichment race.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Fox News Digital's Jasmine Baehr framed Trump's July 23 remarks as clarifying a condition that was always part of the deal, quoting him saying the pact is limited to civilian energy and that Saudi Arabia must join the Abraham Accords. Right-leaning foreign policy writers were more skeptical: Alissa Pavia argued in the Washington Examiner that letting Riyadh enrich on its own soil without the usual safeguards could destabilize the region and weaken Israel. Andrea Stricker of the hawkish Foundation for Defense of Democracies urged Trump to keep enrichment off Saudi soil and asked Congress to use its review to block the accord.
Deep Dive
The agreement turns a joint declaration from Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman's November 2025 White House visit into a binding 123 agreement, the legal vehicle for US nuclear exports. Talks stalled under both Trump and Joe Biden over the same issue: whether Riyadh would renounce enrichment and reprocessing, as the UAE did in 2009, and accept the Additional Protocol. According to Reuters, The Washington Post and Ynet, this version accepts neither, substituting a two-year joint study on enrichment, US-controlled "black box" technology if a plant is built, American inspection teams and a separate bilateral safeguards accord. The timing, during the US and Israeli war with Iran over its enrichment, gave critics their sharpest line of attack. Rubio's defense rests on a real argument: a US supplier brings American oversight, and the AP and Reuters both note that any Saudi enrichment would be years away. Critics are right that the text has not been published and that the bilateral safeguards, as FDD's Stricker wrote, probably cannot reach undeclared sites. The crown prince's past statement that Saudi Arabia would match an Iranian bomb gives the warnings weight. Administration defenders leave out why the Additional Protocol, which Washington has demanded of Iran, was dropped. Some critics in turn treat enrichment as settled when Trump publicly denied it on July 23, and Carnegie's Menton described the situation as uncertain. The next steps are formal transmission to Congress and the 90-session-day review, where blocking the deal would require a veto-proof majority. Watch whether the administration publishes the text, whether Trump's no-enrichment pledge appears in writing, how Riyadh answers the Abraham Accords demand after a Saudi official told FDD there was nothing to renegotiate, and whether the UAE seeks to revisit its own terms.
Regional Perspective
In Saudi Arabia, Asharq Al-Awsat reported the July 22 signing using statements from the Saudi Energy Ministry and the US Department of Energy, describing a multi-decade partnership worth billions of dollars and quoting Chris Wright on nonproliferation standards. EnterpriseAM's Saudi edition was more detailed, reporting that the pact does not bind Riyadh to forgo enrichment or reprocessing and opens the stalled Khor Duwaiheen reactor tender to Westinghouse. Rubio's comments came in Manila, where AFP and the AP reported them on the sidelines of ASEAN meetings; regional coverage there was limited to those wire reports. Israeli coverage diverged sharply. Ynet ran the deal under a headline stressing "no normalization" and no gold standard, and quoted Henry Sokolski warning of a regional domino effect. NPR's Emily Feng reported that Avigdor Lieberman warned of an arms race and Yair Lapid blamed Netanyahu, while Economy Minister Nir Barkat played down the risk. The Washington Post quoted Naftali Bennett calling it a severe strategic failure. Saudi outlets, by contrast, said little about weapons risk. For Riyadh, the deal is mostly about replacing oil and gas in power generation and securing US industrial partners; EnterpriseAM cited a 17 GW nuclear target by 2040. For Israel, the stakes are its regional nuclear monopoly and the leverage it hoped to keep over Saudi normalization, which Trump's July 23 condition partly restored.