Supreme Court declines to let Missouri use GOP congressional map, then a federal judge orders it used

Kavanaugh refused to revive Missouri's GOP map, but a federal judge ordered it used, leaving November's districts in limbo.

Objective Facts

Justice Brett Kavanaugh on September 8 turned down Missouri's emergency bid to set aside a September 3 Missouri Supreme Court ruling that the 2025 Republican congressional map never took effect because a referendum petition against it was valid. Within minutes, Chief U.S. District Judge Stephen Clark issued a temporary restraining order in a separate federal suit requiring Missouri to use that same map for the November 3 election, citing the risk of voter confusion after an August primary held under the new lines, Roll Call and the AP reported. On September 9 the 8th Circuit declined to pause Clark's order, and People Not Politicians said it would ask the U.S. Supreme Court to step in, according to KCTV5 and St. Louis Public Radio. Attorney General Catherine Hanaway said the state would comply with Clark's order, while the Missouri Supreme Court scheduled a September 10 contempt hearing for Secretary of State Denny Hoskins.

Left-Leaning Perspective

St. Louis Public Radio's Jason Rosenbaum, writing for the NPR member station, centered the story on the confusion facing county election clerks who must print ballots under conflicting orders. Above the Law senior editor Kathryn Rubino went further, calling the situation a live constitutional crisis and portraying Clark as a Trump appointee who acted after the Supreme Court declined to.

Right-Leaning Perspective

Mainstream right-leaning outlets gave this specific turn limited attention before the next Supreme Court step. The National News Desk, the Sinclair-syndicated service, ran a straight report by Natalia Mittelstadt that gave space to Attorney General Catherine Hanaway's argument that changing maps between the primary and general election is not feasible, alongside the challengers' lawyers.

Deep Dive

Missouri Republicans passed the map in 2025 at Donald Trump's urging to target Emanuel Cleaver's Kansas City district. Opponents gathered signatures for a referendum, Hoskins rejected the petition in August, and the primary went ahead under the new lines. On September 3 the Missouri Supreme Court ruled the petition valid, meaning the 2022 map applies unless voters approve the new one. Kavanaugh's September 8 denial left that ruling standing, but Clark's restraining order, issued minutes later in a separate suit, required the opposite result, and the 8th Circuit declined to pause it on September 9. Each side has a real point. Clark and state officials are right that candidates were nominated in an August primary under the 2025 lines, and the AP found that about 59% of 5th District voters are new under the revised map, so switching now changes the electorate in a race already under way. The challengers are right that the state's top court has ruled the map was never law, and that federal courts usually defer to a state supreme court on state law. Coverage on both sides said less about how Clark's order binds local election authorities; St. Louis County's Eric Fey told St. Louis Public Radio the order is unclear on that point. The next steps are the Missouri Supreme Court's contempt hearing for Hoskins on September 10, People Not Politicians' request to the U.S. Supreme Court, and the federal deadline of September 19 for mailing ballots to military and overseas voters. Clark's order runs 14 days pending a hearing on a longer injunction, and Proposition A, the referendum on the map, is set for the November ballot.

OBJ SPEAKING

Create StoryTimelinesVoter ToolsRegional AnalysisPolicy GuideAll StoriesCommunity PicksUSWorldPoliticsBusinessHealthEntertainmentTechnologyAbout

Supreme Court declines to let Missouri use GOP congressional map, then a federal judge orders it used

Kavanaugh refused to revive Missouri's GOP map, but a federal judge ordered it used, leaving November's districts in limbo.

Sep 9, 2026
What's Going On
  • On September 8, Justice Brett Kavanaugh denied Missouri's emergency request to set aside a state Supreme Court ruling that blocked the 2025 Republican-drawn congressional map, without referring it to the full court or explaining why, Roll Call and Al Jazeera reported.
  • Minutes later, Chief U.S. District Judge Stephen Clark, a Trump appointee, issued a 14-day temporary restraining order requiring Missouri to use the 2025 map in November, in a suit brought by Rep. Bob Onder and state Sen. Rick Brattin, according to Roll Call and St. Louis Public Radio.
  • On September 9 the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals denied a request by the referendum group People Not Politicians to stay Clark's order, and the group said it was turning to the U.S. Supreme Court, KCTV5 and St. Louis Public Radio reported.
  • The Missouri Supreme Court ordered Secretary of State Denny Hoskins to show cause why he should not be held in contempt for telling local officials to use the 2025 lines, with arguments set for Thursday, September 10, the AP reported.
  • The 2025 map targets the Kansas City seat of Democratic Rep. Emanuel Cleaver and was expected to shift Missouri's delegation from 6-2 to 7-1 Republican, according to The Federalist and The Daily Wire.
Far Left: Democracy Docket emphasized that the Missouri Supreme Court held the map is not and never was law.
Left: St. Louis Public Radio reported Boone County Clerk Brianna Lennon said officials face conflicting orders and voters may hear only part of the story.
Moderate: The AP reported that about 59% of voters in Cleaver's 5th District would be new to him under the revised map.
Right: The National News Desk noted other states had redrawn maps for Republicans while California and Utah redrew for Democrats.
Far Right: The Federalist highlighted that the 2025 map would yield seven Republican seats and one Democratic seat.
✓ Common Ground
Outlets from The Daily Wire to Above the Law agreed the competing orders leave Missouri voters and clerks without a clear answer weeks before ballots go out.
County election officials in Boone, St. Charles and St. Louis counties told St. Louis Public Radio they face conflicting orders, and St. Charles County's Kurt Bahr warned that reprinting ballots would be costly.
Commentators across the spectrum noted that the August primary held under the 2025 map is the central practical problem, whatever they think of the map's legality.
There appears to be wide agreement, from Democracy Docket to The Federalist, that the dispute will be settled by a higher federal court, not by Missouri officials.
◆ All Sources (13)
Associated Press (via PBS NewsHour) - Competing court orders add confusion to Missouri congressional electionsRoll Call - Federal judge orders Missouri to use map targeting Dem House seatKCTV5 - Missouri's redrawn 2025 map heads to the US Supreme Court, againAl Jazeera - US Supreme Court rejects Missouri bid to reactivate GOP-backed voting mapThe Missouri Times - Map wars take a major turnIBTimes UK - Supreme Court Just Handed Republicans a Rare and Massive Defeat Over a Disputed Congressional MapSt. Louis Public Radio - Hoskins faces contempt hearing at Missouri Supreme Court as 'street fight' over map ragesSt. Louis Public Radio (via KBIA) - Missouri's redistricting fight in turmoil as U.S. Supreme Court and federal orders clashAbove the Law - The Supreme Court Wouldn't Save Missouri's Gerrymander, A Trump Judge Did It AnywayDemocracy Docket - Federal judge revives Missouri GOP gerrymander right after Supreme Court rejects state's emergency bidThe Federalist - Federal judge reinstates Missouri's new election map after Kavanaugh declines to get involvedThe Daily Wire - Wild Court Twist Breathes New Life Into GOP Midterm MapThe National News Desk (via FOX 11) - Kavanaugh declines to restore Missouri's congressional map favoring GOP before midterms
Objective Deep Dive

Missouri Republicans passed the map in 2025 at Donald Trump's urging to target Emanuel Cleaver's Kansas City district. Opponents gathered signatures for a referendum, Hoskins rejected the petition in August, and the primary went ahead under the new lines. On September 3 the Missouri Supreme Court ruled the petition valid, meaning the 2022 map applies unless voters approve the new one. Kavanaugh's September 8 denial left that ruling standing, but Clark's restraining order, issued minutes later in a separate suit, required the opposite result, and the 8th Circuit declined to pause it on September 9.

Each side has a real point. Clark and state officials are right that candidates were nominated in an August primary under the 2025 lines, and the AP found that about 59% of 5th District voters are new under the revised map, so switching now changes the electorate in a race already under way. The challengers are right that the state's top court has ruled the map was never law, and that federal courts usually defer to a state supreme court on state law. Coverage on both sides said less about how Clark's order binds local election authorities; St. Louis County's Eric Fey told St. Louis Public Radio the order is unclear on that point.

The next steps are the Missouri Supreme Court's contempt hearing for Hoskins on September 10, People Not Politicians' request to the U.S. Supreme Court, and the federal deadline of September 19 for mailing ballots to military and overseas voters. Clark's order runs 14 days pending a hearing on a longer injunction, and Proposition A, the referendum on the map, is set for the November ballot.

◈ Tone Comparison

Left-leaning outlets such as Democracy Docket and Above the Law used the word "gerrymander" in headlines and stressed Clark's appointment by Donald Trump. Right-leaning outlets such as The Federalist and The Daily Wire called the map "new" or "GOP-friendly," spoke of it being "reinstated" or "revived," and centered the voter confusion argument.