Supreme Court denies Trump administration bid to halt counting of disputed California mail ballots
The Supreme Court denied the Trump administration's election eve bid to set aside 20,000 disputed California mail ballots.
Objective Facts
The Trump administration asked the Supreme Court on Nov. 2 to order California to set aside mail ballots from more than 20,000 people on a federal list of suspected noncitizens, after the Ninth Circuit refused on Oct. 30. The court denied the application that evening in an unsigned order, without asking California to respond and with no public dissents. The Justice Department sued California and Los Angeles County registrar Dean Logan on Oct. 15, and Judge David Carter rejected a restraining order on Oct. 28. State and county officials say the list contains many citizens and that ballots cannot be pulled back once separated from their envelopes. Federal prosecutors say they have charged 34 people from the list.
Left-Leaning Perspective
CBS News reporter Melissa Quinn covered both the filing and the denial, putting California's accuracy concerns and the risk of disenfranchising citizens near the top of each story. Her denial story led with Judge David Carter's finding that the identification process was "rife with uncertainty and errors" and added that confirmed noncitizen voting is rare. CBS also cited Washington Secretary of State Steve Hobbs saying a similar federal list in his state contained many citizens. Pages from CNN, NPR, NBC News and MSNBC also reported the denial, but we could not open them to verify their framing.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Fox News coverage before the ruling centered on First Assistant U.S. Attorney Bill Essayli, who said investigators verified all 20,000 people as noncitizens and called that number "the floor," while California disputed the list. Fox reported the Justice Department's Oct. 23 filing to the Ninth Circuit, which opened "This is an emergency." At Legal Insurrection, Mary Chastain cast California as uncooperative, highlighting what she called conflicting statements by Los Angeles County officials about reviewing the list. NTD's Matthew Vadum, writing with The Epoch Times, quoted Newsom calling the claims "bogus" but gave most space to Sauer's argument that commingled ballots cannot be recovered.
Deep Dive
The Justice Department sent California a list of about 20,000 registered voters on Oct. 13, asked the state to review it within 48 hours, and sued on Oct. 15 when the state declined, according to Mother Jones and the AP. The list came from matching a purchased partial voter file against federal immigration records. Judge David Carter denied a restraining order on Oct. 28, two Ninth Circuit panels ruled against the government 2-1, and the Supreme Court denied Sauer's application on Nov. 2 without comment, hours before the final day of voting. The administration's side has a real point that noncitizen voting is illegal and that a ballot, once counted, cannot be clawed back. Prosecutors have charged 34 people from the list, per The Daily Wire. What that side leaves out is the scale of the error problem: Los Angeles County found many flagged voters appeared U.S. born, a Justice Department lawyer conceded a high error rate in court, and UCLA analysts estimated thousands of citizens were mislabeled. California's critics of the request, for their part, say little about the people already charged, and the state's reliance on applicants' own attestation of citizenship, raised by Judge Patrick Bumatay, got little attention in left leaning coverage. The Supreme Court order resolves only the emergency request; the underlying lawsuit continues before Carter and the Ninth Circuit. The criminal prosecutions will test how many people on the list actually voted illegally, and that record will shape any post election challenge. The Justice Department has made a similar demand of Washington state involving more than 400 people, and McCotter said the department will keep pursuing every legal avenue.