Supreme Court denies Trump's rehearing request in E. Jean Carroll case, leaving $5 million verdict in place
The Supreme Court refused to rehear Trump's appeal, making E. Jean Carroll's $5 million verdict final.
Objective Facts
The Supreme Court on Monday, August 17, denied Donald Trump's request that it reconsider its June 29 decision not to hear his appeal of the $5 million verdict won by writer E. Jean Carroll. The one-sentence order gave no reasons and recorded no dissents, Democracy Now reported. A 2023 jury found Trump sexually abused Carroll in a Manhattan department store dressing room in the mid-1990s and defamed her in 2022 posts; Trump has denied the allegations and already paid the judgment, about $5.6 million with interest. A separate $83.3 million defamation verdict, which Trump is challenging on presidential immunity grounds, remains pending before the justices.
Left-Leaning Perspective
The Week's Rafi Schwartz, summarizing reporting from The New York Times and CNN, presented the order as the end of Trump's effort to claw back the $5 million he paid Carroll the previous month. Schwartz noted the court gave no reasoning and recorded no dissents, and gave space to both Carroll's lawyer Roberta Kaplan and Trump's legal team. The piece also flagged that the justices are on summer recess and are not expected to take up the $83 million appeal until late September at the earliest.
Right-Leaning Perspective
We could not find commentary or original reporting on the rehearing denial from The Wall Street Journal, Fox News, National Review or the New York Post published August 18 to 21. The main voice in coverage defending Trump came from his own legal team: a spokesperson, quoted by The Week, said Americans want an end to what he called witch hunts and described the litigation as Democrat-funded.
Deep Dive
A Manhattan jury in 2023 found Trump liable for sexually abusing her in a Bergdorf Goodman dressing room in the mid-1990s and for defaming her in 2022 posts that called her account a "complete con job," Bloomberg reported. After his appeals failed, the Supreme Court declined to hear Trump's appeal on June 29, and Trump paid about $5.6 million with interest. His rehearing petition was a late attempt to keep the case alive by tying it to his separate immunity argument; the court turned it down on August 17 without comment. Carroll's lawyers are right that this ends direct challenges to the $5 million verdict; there is no further step at the Supreme Court. Trump's team has a narrower point that the coverage mostly skips: his immunity argument in the $83.3 million case has not been rejected on the merits, and the court simply declined to hold this case while it decides whether to hear that one. Coverage that treats the whole Carroll fight as over goes too far, while Trump's description of the cases as hoaxes runs against two jury verdicts and the failed appeals. The next decision point is the $83.3 million appeal. Trump and the Justice Department argue his 2019 statements about Carroll, made while he was president, are protected, and the Justice Department wants to substitute itself as the defendant under the Westfall Act, Breitbart reported. The Week, citing The New York Times, said the justices are not expected to consider that petition until late September at the earliest.