Supreme Court hears Boulder climate lawsuit against ExxonMobil and Suncor
An eight-member Supreme Court split in its questions over whether Boulder can sue Exxon and Suncor over climate costs.
Objective Facts
On October 5, 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments over whether federal law bars Boulder, Colorado's state-law suit against Suncor Energy and ExxonMobil seeking compensation for climate-related costs. Boulder says the companies deceived the public about climate risks; the companies, backed by the Trump administration, say federal law and the Constitution keep states from regulating global emissions through tort suits. SCOTUSblog's Amy Howe described the justices as sending mixed signals, with Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Elena Kagan pressing the companies and Justice Brett Kavanaugh most receptive to them. Justice Samuel Alito did not take part, so an even split would leave the Colorado Supreme Court's ruling allowing the case in place.
Left-Leaning Perspective
NPR's Carrie Johnson reported that Justice Kavanaugh appeared to side with the companies while Justice Kagan likened the case to tobacco suits courts had allowed, and quoted William & Mary law professor Jonathan Adler calling the companies' bid to bar all such suits aggressive. Grist's Austin Corona and Inside Climate News' Nicholas Kusnetz, writing for climate-focused outlets, stressed Boulder's argument that the case targets deception rather than emissions and noted that dozens of similar suits are waiting on the outcome. Sierra magazine's Dana Drugmand pointed to what she called a tension in the federal position: claiming federal authority over climate pollution while the Trump EPA rolls that authority back.
Right-Leaning Perspective
The Washington Free Beacon's Thomas Catenacci counted Roberts, Thomas, Gorsuch, Kavanaugh and Barrett as sympathetic to the companies and gave prominent space to Harris's argument and to Utah and Alabama attorneys general who predicted a win for the industry. National Review's Carrie Campbell Severino wrote that the justices appeared skeptical and that the Court seemed ready to stop Boulder's attempt to regulate global emissions. Complete Colorado's Kyle Kohli, writing for the Independence Institute site, argued that a wall of precedent puts interstate pollution under federal law and stressed Russell's concession that his theory could reach fuel retailers.
Deep Dive
Boulder's city and county sued Suncor and ExxonMobil in 2018 under Colorado tort law, claiming nuisance, trespass, unjust enrichment and civil conspiracy tied to alleged concealment of climate risks. The companies failed to move the case to federal court, and the Colorado Supreme Court ruled in May 2025 that federal law does not bar the claims. The U.S. Supreme Court agreed in February to review that ruling, and the October 5 argument was the first of its new term. Inside Climate News reported that more than two dozen similar suits could be affected, and some are paused awaiting this decision. The companies' side gets support from the questions of Justice Kavanaugh, who pointed to precedent placing interstate pollution under federal law, and Justice Barrett, who got Russell to agree Colorado could not cap emissions elsewhere. Boulder's side gets support from Roberts's observation, reported by Bloomberg and Colorado Politics, that suits over out-of-state conduct with in-state effects are common. Advocacy coverage on the left tended to skip Russell's concession, reported by SCOTUSblog, that nothing in his theory stops suits against large fuel retailers. Coverage on the right gave little attention to Kagan's rejection of the broad constitutional argument or to the tobacco and opioid comparison. With Alito recused, the case needs five votes to change the outcome, and a 4-4 tie would leave the Colorado ruling standing without a national precedent. Justice Jackson's interest in waiting until Colorado courts finish offers a path to avoid the merits. Kagan's interest in a narrower Clean Air Act ruling, noted by Bloomberg, could shape which pending suits survive. Bloomberg reported a decision is expected by late June.