Supreme Court leaves in place block on Postal Service mail ballot rule before midterms
The Supreme Court kept a lower-court block on new Postal Service mail ballot rules in place for the November midterms.
Objective Facts
The Supreme Court on September 14, 2026, refused to let the U.S. Postal Service enforce new mail ballot rules for the midterm elections, leaving in place a preliminary injunction issued by U.S. District Judge Indira Talwani in Boston. The rule, which carried out a March executive order from Donald Trump, would have required states to submit lists of mail voters to a USPS portal and use approved envelopes with unique barcodes, according to Ballotpedia and Fox News. The unsigned order found the government unlikely to win on the merits; Justice Brett Kavanaugh concurred on timing grounds, while Justices Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas dissented. The challengers included 23 states led by California plus the District of Columbia, along with civic groups represented by the ACLU, and NPR reported that mail voting had already begun in Alabama, North Carolina and Wisconsin. The ruling does not settle whether the rule is lawful, and litigation continues before Talwani.
Left-Leaning Perspective
Mainstream left coverage presented the order as a clear loss for Trump and a relief for election officials. NPR's Hansi Lo Wang reported that the Postal Service is expected to keep delivering ballots as usual and that the administration offered no evidence of mail voting fraud in the case. States Newsroom's Jacob Fischler led with the Democratic officials who sued, while The New Republic's Matt Ford praised the result but said the three-sentence order and Kavanaugh's concurrence leave room for the rule in 2028.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Fox News reported the loss plainly but gave the dissent prominent play. Anders Hagstrom's Fox News Digital piece built its account around Alito's argument that the challengers' claim was a long shot, and a separate Fox News report by Stepheny Price, Bill Mears and Shannon Bream highlighted Kavanaugh's view that the Postal Service may ultimately have authority for the rules. Fox also aired election expert Jason Snead accusing the trial judge of trying to run out the clock on the rule.
Deep Dive
The order is the second time the Supreme Court has acted on Trump's March 2026 executive order on mail voting. In August, the Court let the order itself proceed on the ground that a challenge was premature. The Postal Service then issued its implementing rule on August 21, according to Straight Arrow News, and Judge Indira Talwani blocked key parts of it for the 2026 election in early September. After the First Circuit refused to intervene, Solicitor General D. John Sauer asked the justices for a stay, which they denied on September 14 in a brief unsigned order. Critics of the rule have the timing argument firmly on their side: even Kavanaugh, who signaled sympathy for the Postal Service's authority, agreed that election officials could not reasonably adapt with ballots already in the mail. Supporters of the rule, including Alito, raise a serious legal question about whether courts can review the Postal Service's general rulemaking power, a point left-leaning coverage mostly skipped. Coverage on the right, in turn, gave little space to the administration's lack of evidence for the fraud rationale, which NPR and Votebeat reported directly. The order resolves only the 2026 midterms. Litigation continues before Talwani, and a second federal judge issued a separate injunction on September 13 in a case brought by Senate Democrats' campaign arm, according to NPR. Kavanaugh's concurrence suggests the Postal Service could try again for 2028 with more lead time, and Ballotpedia noted that states can still choose to adopt parts of the rule voluntarily.