Supreme Court lets New Hampshire reject student IDs at the polls
The Supreme Court let New Hampshire bar student IDs as backup voter identification for the Nov. 3 midterms.
Objective Facts
On Thursday, Oct. 22, the Supreme Court granted New Hampshire's emergency request, backed by the Republican National Committee, and stayed Judge Joseph Laplante's October orders in Scanlan v. Coalition for Open Democracy. The unsigned, one-paragraph order relied on the Purcell principle and said the district court had not justified changing the rules so close to the election. Laplante had upheld House Bill 323, which Gov. Kelly Ayotte signed in April and which removed student IDs from the list of accepted voter identification, but he blocked Secretary of State David Scanlan's guidance barring officials from weighing student IDs as backup evidence of identity. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson dissented alone, arguing the lower court had corrected misinformation rather than changed the law. The stay holds through the Nov. 3 election while the case proceeds.
Left-Leaning Perspective
NBC News reporter Lawrence Hurley, in a story carried by NBC Boston, opened by calling the ruling a Republican win and tied it directly to the Sununu and Pappas Senate race. Hurley gave Jackson's dissent prominent placement and explained that Laplante had found Scanlan's guidance went further than the statute. The Concord Monitor's David Brooks told students plainly not to rely on their school IDs and wrote that out-of-state dorm residents often lack other proof of residence, such as utility bills.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Fox News reporter Landon Mion framed the order as the Court stopping a late federal intervention, leading with Formella's statement and placing Jackson's dissent lower. The Daily Signal's Fred Lucas stressed the 8-1 split, listed lawmakers' complaints that student IDs lack expiration dates, address checks and security features, and identified Laplante as a George W. Bush appointee. The Daily Caller's Mark Tanos headlined the decision as a possible Republican edge in the Senate race and quoted Republican state Rep. Ross Berry attacking Laplante.
Deep Dive
New Hampshire's House Bill 323, signed by Gov. Kelly Ayotte in April and in effect since June, dropped student IDs from the list of identification accepted at the polls. Scanlan then told officials in an April 23 directive that student IDs could not be used at all, including under a separate safety valve that lets voters prove identity with other evidence. The Coalition for Open Democracy sued in August. Laplante upheld the statute on Oct. 2 but blocked the directive, the 1st Circuit refused to pause him, and the Supreme Court stayed his orders on Oct. 22 with only Jackson dissenting publicly. The state's side has a point on timing: Scanlan's office had trained officials and run public outreach for months, and the Purcell principle exists to keep courts from shifting rules late. The challengers have a point on substance. Laplante never struck the law, and Scanlan had already posted revised guidance by the time the justices acted, so the stay itself changed the instructions officials were following less than two weeks out. Right-leaning coverage spent little time on the safety valve question, and left-leaning coverage often skipped the state's arguments about student ID security. The majority order offered no reasoning beyond the Purcell citation, which leaves both sides arguing about a one-paragraph text. Scanlan's office told The Dartmouth it is updating student voter guides and resuming radio and TV announcements that student IDs cannot prove identity. Watch whether local officials apply the change consistently on Nov. 3, especially for out-of-state students in dorms who lack utility bills or other proof of residence. The 1st Circuit appeal and the district court case continue, so the safety valve question could return after the election.