Tom Homan says administration could seek to denaturalize Rep. Ilhan Omar
Border czar Tom Homan said Ilhan Omar could be denaturalized and deported if a fraud probe proves she lied.
Objective Facts
White House border czar Tom Homan said on Fox News on Oct. 17 that Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-Minn.) could lose her citizenship and be deported if investigators prove she committed immigration fraud. He said he had been told investigators "have a strong case" but deferred details to the FBI and HSI. His comments followed an Oct. 12 search of Omar's Washington home by Homeland Security Investigations, which the Justice Department described as part of an ongoing criminal investigation. The Washington Post and Wall Street Journal reported the probe focuses on whether Omar or her late father, Nur Omar Mohamed, misstated her age on immigration paperwork. Omar denies wrongdoing, has not been charged, and is running for a fifth term on Nov. 3.
Left-Leaning Perspective
The Washington Post's Ted Hesson and Jeremy Roebuck focused on the substance of the case: whether Omar or her father lied about her birth date, and whether her father omitted military service. They placed the probe against a sharp rise in denaturalization filings, at least 163 since January 2025. MPR News host Nina Moini, interviewing Minneapolis immigration attorney David Wilson, stressed how high the legal bar is. Raw Story's Robert Davis, covering Homan's earlier September remarks, highlighted critics who saw the threat as punishment of a political opponent.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Fox News built its story around Homan's warning, quoting him saying investigators will "let the evidence lead where it leads" and that Omar gets no special treatment. A separate Fox News piece by Leo Briceno paired Democratic outrage with Republicans such as Rep. Nancy Mace and House Majority Whip Tom Emmer, who cast the probe as equal application of the law. The Washington Examiner's Emily Hallas reported the WSJ account of the probe's goal and included a Hatch Act complaint from Norm Eisen's Democracy Defenders Fund. The Epoch Times' Aldgra Fredly quoted Homan calling denaturalization a "long, tedious process" and gave space to Barack Obama's defense of Omar.
Deep Dive
Omar arrived in the United States as a Somali refugee in 1995 and says she became a citizen in 2000 at 17 through her father's naturalization. According to The Washington Post, investigators are examining whether she was actually 18, which would have required her own application, and whether her father hid past military service. HSI reopened the file this year, and agents searched her home on Oct. 12. Homan's Oct. 17 Fox interview was the first time a senior official tied that search directly to the prospect of denaturalization and deportation. The administration's defenders are right that denaturalization for fraud is legal and has been used before. The Post counts at least 163 cases filed since January 2025. But Homan conceded he does not know the evidence, Omar's father died in 2020, and HSI declined a similar case years ago. Al Jazeera, citing a former Justice Department official, said a case would likely turn on whether Omar herself lied about her age. Critics on the left often skip past the fact that a federal judge approved the warrant, and that the Post reported possible charges including conspiracy and false statements. Defenders tend to downplay the break from the Justice Department's usual practice of avoiding public steps close to an election. The next markers are whether a grand jury in Minnesota returns charges, whether the Justice Department files a civil denaturalization petition, and how Omar's Nov. 3 race goes. David Wilson told MPR News that a criminal path under 18 U.S.C. 1425 requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt, a higher bar than a civil case. The Democracy Defenders Fund's Hatch Act complaint and Omar's push to recover seized items could also reach a judge before any charges do.