Trump administration admits clean energy grants were canceled based on states' politics
Energy Department lawyers conceded in court that about $7.6 billion in clean energy grants were cut over states' voting records.
Objective Facts
Lawyers for the Energy Department stated in a July 15 court filing that grants included in the October 2025 termination batch were selected based solely on the political identity of the recipient's state, The New York Times reported on July 24. The Associated Press said the cancellations totaled $7.6 billion for projects in 16 states that voted for Kamala Harris in 2024, while the Times counted 284 terminated grants, all but one in Harris states with two Democratic-caucusing senators. The concession was made in a suit by University of California researchers, and Energy Secretary Chris Wright had previously testified that politics did not drive the cuts. Democrats including Sen. Patty Murray and Rep. Marcy Kaptur condemned the cuts, and the department's spokesman said the filing does not contradict Wright.
Left-Leaning Perspective
The New York Times, in reporting by Tony Romm and Brad Plumer, broke the story by setting the filing against Chris Wright's June testimony and against a pending plan to let political appointees review federal grants. Democracy Docket's Brentin Mock cast the admission as part of a pattern of withholding funds from Democratic-led states, citing FEMA, HHS and DHS actions. TheGrio's Brandon Caldwell also tied the filing to earlier episodes involving social services money and disaster aid.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Searches of The Wall Street Journal, Fox News, National Review, the Washington Examiner and the New York Post turned up no coverage of the July filing between July 25 and July 28. The administration's defense appears only inside mainstream reports: AP quoted Chris Wright calling the cuts business decisions about taxpayer value, and Scripps News quoted spokesman Ben Dietderich denying any contradiction. No Republican lawmaker's response appeared in the AP, Times or Utility Dive stories.
Deep Dive
The Energy Department announced in October 2025, during a government shutdown, that it was terminating 321 awards across 223 projects, saying they did not adequately advance energy needs or were not economically viable. The July 15 filing, made in a suit by University of California researchers and reported by the Times on July 24, said inclusion in that October batch turned on the recipient state's political identity. The Times and Utility Dive reported the concession was part of an arrangement that spared the department from discovery. Earlier, in a separate suit by clean energy groups and the city of St. Paul, government lawyers had acknowledged that a state's political leaning influenced selection, AP reported, and the department's inspector general opened an investigation in December. The critics' case rests on the department's own words, and that is hard to dispute: the filing says the batch was defined by politics, not cost or performance. Coverage on the left tends to skip over the department's narrower defense, which is that an earlier review of roughly 2,270 projects was not political, and that the filing addresses only which grants ended up in the October tranche. The administration's defense, in turn, does not explain why hundreds of recommended cuts in Republican-represented states were left alone, a point the Times documented. The numbers also vary by outlet: AP cites $7.6 billion across 16 states and 223 projects, while the Times and Scripps News count 284 grants. The immediate questions are how the court in the University of California case uses the concession, whether the inspector general's investigation picks it up, and how Wright answers lawmakers who say he misled them. A larger fight concerns the OMB proposal, expected to be finalized by October according to the Times, that would let political appointees review and revoke federal grants across agencies. Republican lawmakers had not publicly responded in the coverage reviewed here.